Software
Houzz Logo Print
jduffie_gw

Help! Which HVAC unit should I buy?

17 years ago

Hi Everyone,

I am adding an addition to my home and have been advised to replace my current unit which is 15 years old with a larger 3ton to cool/heat new and current space!! +- 1800 square feet. Have no idea about the systems quoted and would greatly appreciate any advise on these systems.

1. A new Trane 4DCY4036A1075A 14 SEER R-410A dual-fuel variable speed 2-stage gas heat packaged unit and duct for the new room. This system has a 20-year heat exchanger warranty, a 10-year compressor/outdoor coil warranty, a 5-year parts warranty, and a 1-year labor warranty. The price for this system is $7,597.

2. A new Trane 4YCC3036A1075A 13 SEER R-410A gas packaged unit and duct for the new room. This system has a 10-year heat exchanger warranty, a 5-year parts and compressor warranty, and a 1-year labor warranty. The price for this system is $6,652.

Comments (7)

  • 17 years ago

    jduffie

    where do you live?
    what is electric rate?
    what is nat gas rate?

    I will assume for installation reasons, you must have a package unit. how long do you plan to be in home?

    post back.

    TD

  • 17 years ago

    I live in chapel hill nc, natural gas costs $0.12182 winter-$0.13255 summer - electricity $.1148 per kwh and I plan on living here forever!! Any advice would be greatly appreciated!! thanks a bunch

  • 17 years ago

    I also live in Chapel Hill, NC and I also plan on living here forever. Thanks so much!

  • 17 years ago

    Same company quoted both systems? The more expensive one is certainly favorable with its variable speed blower and 2-stage heat, but as seen there is a premium price for it. If you can afford the increase, that's the way I'd go.

    How did they size the system? Load calculation? Guess? Previous size? Very important in having a good system--having it sized properly.

  • 17 years ago

    jduffie

    #1 is a much better choice with var speed blower, two stg gas heat , and the HP. be aware though that the gas heating is only 80% with a low HSPF of 8 for the HP which is typical for package units. your electric rate and nat gas rate are close so you really can't leverage the electric rate against the nat gas rates.

    I would get a quote for the straight gas/electric package unit XL14c for comparison to the dual fuel model. if operating costs are important to you and you think utility rates will widen between gas and electric, then go with dual fuel.

    BTW, same units are available from Trane's sister company Am Standard and may be less expensive.

    you could also get quotes on the Carrier/Bryant package systems which are nice.

    IMO

  • 17 years ago

    thanks so much for the help, I will get some additional quotes for the other models and will come back to get your invaluable opinion!! thanks a bunch

  • 14 years ago

    Home owners in Los Ageles visit http://affordableairconditioner.com/
    for Low Cost Air Conditioning and Heating equipment.