Software
Houzz Logo Print
qbert_gw

Oil to Heatpump

18 years ago

Hi and thanks for any replies.

I live near Bowling Green VA. My house was built in 1945 of brick, block and plaster- minimal insulation- just attic mostly. I just installed new double pane windows.

The house is Cape Cod style, 3 levels including basement for a total of 2400 sq ft. Presently I have a dedicated AC unit (2 1/2 tons) and a Lennox forced air oil furnace. The furnace is rated at 104,000 BTU but was new in 1961 (I think). Presently the top floor is either hot or cold depending upon the season. We use the AC rarely as the house has plenty of shade. The heat is the big issue.

A Carrier dealer gave me a quote of $4700 for the following:

Carrier Compressor 25HPA342A003 and Carrier air handler FX4CNF402. He said it is a 3 1/2 ton system with an SEER of 14. This quote is for removal of oil furnace and install of new unit.

I'm wondering if I should go up to 25HPA542.

I'm having three quotes made but only one done so far.

As quoted does this sound ok for the climate I live in?

Thanks,

Bert

Comments (31)

  • 18 years ago

    SEER on that setup is 13.50. I would go with the variable-speed indoor unit, the FV4 series. I suggest the 25HPA542 with FV4 indoor unit. Talk to your contractor about it; I'm not sure why he didn't offer variable speed to begin with. 25HPA542 + FV4BNF005 = 12.5 EER, 15.5 SEER, and 8.5 HSPF. Make sure 3.5 tons is the right size. Why is he going up 1 ton in size? A load calculation ("heat load") needs to be done on the home to determine the correct size. My home is newer than yours, but I have a 3.5-ton conditioning ~3500 sq. ft.

  • 18 years ago

    there is a big difference between heat pump heat and oil heat. if you like to feel that warm heat you may want to go with a gas unit. you could also go with a duel fuel. do you have natural gas in your area

  • 18 years ago

    This is Bert,

    I'm in the country. The guy who built this place owned two businesses- 1 was fuel oil and the other was brick and block. I have a 2000 gallon oil tank, the first delivery guy drained his truck- then he called me! No gas lines, no cable TV. I guess gas (propane or natural) could be utilized via an above ground tank.

    I'm wondering about setting up a heat pump with a gas backup then adding gas logs for the main room. Would that sound like a winner?

  • 18 years ago

    A heat pump with gas backup (dual fuel) would be a good setup if the gas rates are reasonable and you get lower temperatures. You'll want a thermostat such as the VisionPRO IAQ to control a system like this so you can lock out the heat pump at a certain temperature. Or a heat pump alone with electric backup may be plenty sufficient. It depends on your climate and electric/fuel rates.

  • 18 years ago

    Bert

    I suggest you read the recent thread by "wamead" who also is considering discarding oil heat for a high eff heat pump system.

    IMO

    http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/hvac/msg0622461916133.html?11

    Here is a link that might be useful: Wamead Thread-Oil to Heat Pump

  • 18 years ago

    Got it!

  • 18 years ago

    2nd estimate was done today. It will be faxed to me in the AM. Basically... Carrier HP- 3 ton, I think the 25HPA542, variable speed FV4 indoor unit, 58MTB gas furnace for supplemental heat. New thermostat. Install and all that other good stuff came out to $8200.

  • 18 years ago

    You can't have a variable-speed air handler (FV4) and the gas furnace; it's one or the other. In other words, the furnace acts as the blower, so you won't use the FV4 air handler. I strongly suggest the 58CVA Infinity 80% furnace, which has a variable-speed blower. Then, you can use the Infinity Control, which interfaces with the Performance heat pumps as well. It's hard to get 15 SEER out of that heat pump without the variable-speed blower. The variable-speed blower provides efficiency and comfort. Here's what you should be looking for, in my opinion:

    Carrier 58CVA furnace (80% AFUE Infinity with variable-speed blower)
    Carrier 25HPA5(42) heat pump (3.5 tons, Performance Series)
    Carrier A or N coil
    Carrier Infinity Control

  • 18 years ago

    Man! I appreciate the help so much. I must have remembered wrong. In the morning I'll have an official proposal. This guy was more knowledgeable than the first and both are local. He said the gas idea was a good one because it would allow someone to use gas or electricity to heat depending upon which one was less expensive. He also said many people around here in tidewater Va are switching from oil to heat pumps.

  • 18 years ago

    You're welcome. If you want some additional advice, post the results of the proposal here tomorrow so I can see what was proposed. Hopefully he includes details like thermostat, lineset, ductwork, warranties, etc... I do recommend the variable-speed blower, and the 58CTA ain't gonna have it.

  • 18 years ago

    Let's see...
    Proposal 1 in hand (but not itemized).
    25HPA336A003 Puron 15
    58MXB100F-16 LP gas furnace
    CNPVP3617 heat pump coil
    thermostat TP series
    Linesets, condensate drain, duct work, concrete pad
    1 year full service warranty
    total $8270

    Proposal 2 (no gas furnace)
    25HPA342A003 Puron 15
    FX4CNF402 plus all the other stuff (except gas furnace)listed in the first proposal
    Total $4700

    I'm not sure how much a gas furnace costs, would it make that large of a cost difference?

    Thanks, Bert

  • 18 years ago

    A few things strike me as odd:
    1. One heat pump is sized at 3 tons, and one is sized at 3.5 tons. Sizing needs to be determined by a load calculation, and heat pumps are sized typically based on cooling needs--so just because you don't have the furnace for heat backup doesn't mean you oversize the heat pump.
    2. The large difference in price--that's only a Comfort 92 furnace anyway (and it definitely doesn't cost $3500, though maybe you need work on the gas lines, PVC, etc.?).
    3. No variable-speed blower! I'd ask about this because it seems odd that the salesman wouldn't at least give this option. This is the way the market is moving; they are superior blowers in terms of efficiency and comfort.

    I'd address these issues to the dealer and see what his response is; I'd sure be curious to know.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree.
    What is here now is a 3 ton AC and a 104k BTU oil furnace. The first guy assumed that was correct size. He promised to spec a variable speed furnace, 98MTB, but didn't.

    The second looked at the same AC and furnace but did not size anything until he ran stuff through a computer program at the office. He offered a variable speed air handler but when I told him I hope to move in 2 or 3 years he said "save your money."

    Manual J...I've downloaded that little gem and am doing one myself.

    I'm giving no one any money until I'm properly satisfied.

  • 18 years ago

    Are you using the HVAC-Calc program that I linked to in another thread? The 58MTB doesn't have a variable-speed blower, either; only the Infinity Series furnaces do. Even though you hope to move in 2 or 3 years, you could still enjoy the comfort and savings, and it might please the next homebuyer (then again they could not care one bit). I'd look into the 25HPA5 (15 SEER one--I suppose you could go with the 25HPA4. I thought I heard that they were discontinuing the 25HPA3, but I'm not 100% sure on that at all.) heat pump with a FV4 air handler and a programmable thermostat.

  • 18 years ago

    Bert, just curious. Are you having much duct work done?

    The reason I ask is, I am in the process of getting quotes for a similar 3 ton system (no Carrier quotes yet tho) and thought you may be interested in seeing some of the prices I have been quoted. Not really any duct work for me.

    I am a little south of you in NC. Let me know if you are interested and I'll post my quotes.

    Bill M.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi,

    It looks like I'm close here. Using existing ductwork.

    Furnace, Carrier 58CVA110-1-16
    Coil, Carrier CNPVP4221ACA
    Heatpump, Carrier 25HPA342A003, Puron
    Labor, linesets, vent for gas to existing flue.

    I may have to run more juice for a heat pump. Does 60 AMPS sound right?

    Cost? $5000 plus tax- That I can live with I guess.

  • 18 years ago

    why shortchange yourself with the Carrier Performance 13?

    The main idea is to save operating dollars by going from oil to HP. If correct, you want the correctly sized Performance 15 25HPA5 mdl paired with Infinity furnace and controller....

    IMO

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with Tigerdunes 100%. Go with the Performance 15 heat pump (properly sized) and the Infinity furnace with the Infinity controller. You'll have yourself a nice system. $5000 is a great price for the setup as it is--less than I'd expect.

  • 18 years ago

    Well, the saga continues. The installer just dropped by to eyeball the place. He is returning to HQ and telling the sales guy to upgrade to a 90 series furnace and the HP to a Performance 15 series, like you have all said, it makes more sense. He said my present heat system is an antique.

  • 18 years ago

    Make sure that 90% is an Infinity for variable-speed blower; that would make for an outstanding system.

  • 18 years ago

    "I may have to run more juice for a heat pump. Does 60 AMPS sound right?"

    Bert

    with dual fuel, a var spd gas furnace will be your backup, not heat strip backup that might require an electric service upgrade. var speed motors use very little juice to power a gas furnace.

    get a quote on the Infinity 96 most likely Mdl 58MVB

    and the Infinity 80 most likely Mdl 58CVA

    you are getting there. I really would take a hard look at a straight Infinty HP system over dual fuel if propane is involved.

    IMO

    Here is a link that might be useful: Carrier Infinity Heat Pumps

  • 18 years ago

    That's what the installer said. He said "Gas, oil, electric... they're all getting to be about the same."

    I'll be talking to them tomorrow and give them all of your ideas. I sure do appreciate all of your help!

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Guys!

    I reckon I've decided upon a winner... finally...

    HP 25HPA542A003
    Gas Furnace 58MVB100-20
    Coil CNPV4221A
    Thermostat: Infinity Control

    Install and etc included

    Total comes out to $6800

    As an asside to all this, a buddy of mine who runs an HVAC company in Richmond told me he'd do the ultimate- dual zone, new ducts and all if I wanted for between $15000 and $17000. That was before I told him I hope to move one day...

  • 18 years ago

    Good system at a great price. Make sure they are competent and are fully experienced with the Infinity system (at that price, I'd be concerned with things like this). Ask if they will seal the ducts around the unit, run a new lineset (if size change needed), provide a labor warranty, etc... Also ask for the CNPVP4821 (4 ton) coil for 14.50 SEER and 8.30 HSPF rather than 14 SEER and 8.20 HSPF

  • 18 years ago

    I'll surely ask. They've been in Ladysmith for 40 some years but they have competition now due to development of the county. These guys are trying to regain lost business I guess. Sealing the ducts is in there, new linesets too. Labor warranty- good to go.

    They told me that EVERYONE is trying to replace oil and go to heat pumps. That ought to reduce our dependence on foerign oil at least a little.

  • 18 years ago

    I wish I could get that system at that price. I would sign on the dotted line today.

  • 18 years ago

    Boy oh Boy!

    I have 4 proposals for complete installs and removal of old equipment. All include labor warranty one year, compressor warranty 10 years, parts warranty 5 years. They vary widely. I've signed a contract with vendor number one!

    1) Carrier 25HPA542A003 , 58MVB100-20, CNPVP4821 cost $6750

    2) Carrier 25HPA336A003, 58MXB100F-16, CNPVP3617 cost $8520

    3) Trane 13 SEER 3 ton, 350AAV048100, coil unknown cost $7654

    4) Trane 16 SEER 3 ton, 355AAV060100, coil unknown cost $11,203

    Thanks guys, you all steered me straight!

  • 18 years ago

    bert

    five observations

    1.good pricing from vendor #1

    2.is Infinity controller included? you definitely want it.

    3. any whole house filter cabinet included?

    4. if keeping LP furnace, I would ask dealer if a different coil is available to boost HP eff.

    5.I personally would ditch the LP gas furnace-nat gas OK, propane I would ditch. go with Infinity air handler with electric backup.

    IMO

    AHRI Performance numbers
    1396473 Active Systems PERFORMANCE 15 PURON HP CARRIER AIR CONDITIONING 25HPA542A30 CNPV*4821A** 58MV(B,C)100-20 41500 12.00 14.50 41000 8.30 25000

  • 18 years ago

    Good job, Bert. Make CERTAIN that's the CNPVP4821ATA coil; you don't want the CNPVP4821ACA coil (plain copper coil that I've heard issues with regarding coil leaks--the *ATA is a tin-plated copper coil, which is supposed to be better). Great system. As Tiger said, go with the Infinity controller with that system (Infinity furnace, Performance outdoor unit that can interface with the Infinity). A media filter cabinet would be a good idea. 5-ton coil may be able to boost efficiency. G'luck.

  • 18 years ago

    Out here there is no natural gas- we're too far out in the country. The Infinity controller is included. Yup, those are the same numbers I came up with on the Carrier site and I'm afraid if I ask for any more changes they may figure out that they should charge me more...

  • 18 years ago

    bert

    if operating costs are important to you, just make the comparison between electric and LP gas. See attached calculator.

    If you do this, and are still happy with LP gas as backup, then that's fine. be aware that the spread between LP gas and electric will probably widen.

    IMO

    Here is a link that might be useful: Fuel Comparison Calculator