Software
Houzz Logo Print
ranger1_gw

Heat Pump Recommendations & Questions?

17 years ago

Hi. I live in Phoenix, AZ. & have a 31 year-old block construction home (1500 sq. ft. with an asphalt roof) with a roof mounted American Standard 3.5 ton heat pump that was installed in Aug.1995. In two months, this unit will be in its 15th year of service. It has been running well with only a fan motor replacement. Considering the fact that this unit has been living & operating in a severe environment for 14-15 years, is the life expectancy of this unit nearing its end?

Home Depot is offering Trane units with $1500 government tax credits, about $500 credit from the local power provider, $1000 credit from Trane & 10% off from Home Depot if the deal starts on a Sunday, according to their add in the paper.

With all these discounts, would this be a good time to consider the purchase of a new unit? The old one works well but is only a 10 SEER.

In the past, I've heard that the Trane products were considered to be of excellent quality. Is this still true? If not, what do you recommend?

The H-D salesperson said that some of the Trane units were using 2-stage compressor pumps but, that some of them are converting to variable-speed motors. I got on Trane's website & saw nothing about variable-speed motors. Am I wrong? What's best between the two?

Thank you.

Joe

Comments (6)

  • 17 years ago

    It's hard to say when a unit will reach its end anymore. But, if you got 14-15 years out of that unit in severe conditions, I'd say you're doing pretty well!

    With the tax credit and other rebates, now is a great time for replacement. The question is are you willing to replace a working unit now, which likely may have 5 years of life left in it (max, in my opinion), given these incentives.

    Trane products are still of good quality. But nothing's built like it was years ago. Reason being people are looking for lower upfront cost.

    Variable speed blowers and 2-stage compressors go hand-in-hand but have nothing to do with each other really. The variable speed blower has the ability to be setup for further dehumidification (not a huge issue in AZ as I understand it) and also adjusts its RPM for full airflow. So if you have slightly undersized ductwork, it can make up for it (keyword slightly). It is also more efficient in most cases (unless, again, ductwork is in poor shape) and considered quieter. It's becoming more and more common. The 2-stage compressor allows the a/c to run at a lower capacity and a higher capacity. I am not a huge fan of these. They only come in full ton sizes, so that means putting a 4 ton in your home unless a 3 ton would work per heat gain calculation. Upfront cost is higher, and in your area, unlike Florida, the dehumidification benefits these compressors offer aren't of major importance. A good single-stage, high-efficiency unit properly-sized would be a better option in your case, in my opinion. Sometimes the 2-stage units don't meet the required EER ratings for the tax credit as well.

    Home Depot subs out their work. I suggest you additionally get estimates from reputable local companies as well.

  • 17 years ago

    RYANHUGHES,

    Thank you for your informative reply. Today, I had the Home Depot sub. come out & give me a quote. He recommended a their 14 SEER rooftop heatpump (Trane) with a variable speed motor. However, the prices are not as good as I thought they would be. The $1,000 rebate from Trane is only on their most expensive, 2 stage pump model. The 14 SEER unit comes with a $200 rebate. Total price, installed, with a new fancy filter & duct cleaning & a Honeywell digital thermostat is around $6,356.00. More than twice what I thought it would be. I was told by the Home Depot, Trane rep. that the units usually sell in between $5,000 & 6,000. With all the rebates they told me about, the discounts would be in the $3,000 range. $3,000 off of a $6,000 price would give me a new Trane for around $3,000. I thought that would be too good to be true!!! But, I didn't think the price would be more than double what I was led to believe.

    The "Good Deal" just isn't as good as I was expecting.

    Joe Fihn

  • 17 years ago

    If you want an American Standard (Trane same thing) give Hendel's a call. They will give you a price on the phone. And then if you want them to come out and look things over they will do that also. They sell like 10 diff brands. If you would be interested in a Rheem give Joe at Alaskan a call. His cell# 602-410-2615. His price for a 4 Ton 15 seer, 13 eer unit with 12 yr parts and labor after all rebates is like $4000.00. This is for a split system on the ground.

  • 17 years ago

    neilaz,

    Thank you for your suggestions. I've heard that the American Standard units are NOT the same as the Trane, anymore. I don't know that, for sure but, that's what I've been told by a/c people a number of times, now.
    The price of a Rheem from Alaskan sounds good but, I have a rooftop heatpump. Also, I've had a bad experience with Alaskan. They called me up just as I was considering having the annual maintainence done on my unit & the "price was right". So, I had them come out & by the time they left, I had an expensive service contract along with a re-usable air filter. They came out & replaced the fan motor & wired it up backwards. Never knew it for years until another repairman & his partner discovered it. I've had numerous a/c repairmen say that the re-usable, cleanable filters are much too restrictive & that it is not a good idea to use them. So, I have an expensive filter that is now a wall ornament!!! I don't mean to "knock" Alaskan. You may have had great experiences, with them, & I hope you have. But, this has been my experience.

    I DO appreciate you taking the time to respond to my questions. I had never thought of the Rheem products. I may be mistaken but, for years I have heard that the Trane units are considered quite good. With that information, that's what I'm looking for.

  • 17 years ago

    Ranger1,
    I have Trane that is 20 years old and has cost me a total of $300 in repairs (bad relays)over that time frame which is fantastic. In fact every year I have the maintenace done the repair man says to never get rid of that unit cause they don't make them like that anymore. I have not ruled out a new trane yet but know they are not made like they used to be. Most units install parts made in China to keep costs down as that is what the customer wants, low cost up front. So with that in mind i am looking at all units. When Alaskan came out last week they told me that the $1 filter is the way to go

  • 15 years ago

    I would like to know what kind of heat pump will be good for beach area? some dealers says Trane heat pump is pretty good, should I believe it? Any one know when is tax credit for heat pump end and how much?
    thanks for your advise

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!