Software
Houzz Logo Print
3katz4me

is there a good, shallower depth FL?

19 years ago

I have an HE2 pair that are at least a couple years old - I've been very happy with them. I'd like a FL for my lake cabin but the space is not deep enough for HE or Duet models. Is there a good quality FL that fits in a space that's only deep enough for your standard TL? I've scoped out a few and they all seem too deep.

Comments (32)

  • 19 years ago

    What depth dimension do you have?

    Even "standard" TLers vary in depth from around 25ish inches for some GE models to 28ish inches for some Speed Queen and older Maytag ones.

    The 5 to 6 kg Euro-sized FLers (Asko/Miele/Bosch) will all come in less than 26" of depth. Even though they are small, you could argue that a 6 kg Euro-FLer might exceed the effective washing capacity of the standard TLer. I believe Speed Queen FLers are 28" deep, but are very expensive and have an unusually short wash cycle, but also well built. Also, the Frigidaire Affinity series is listed at 27" depth. All the big FLers are atleast 30" depth.

  • 19 years ago

    Gibby, what is the depth of the space? Obviously, you already have an HE2 so you know it's depth, but when we were researching we measured and remeasured and remeasured again, and ended up with the HE2t (which we like very much). It turns out, not only is the depth not an issue, but there's room to spare. I have no idea where we were off. If you need it, I can find the closet dimensions (which I've posted here previously).

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks - I'll remeasure again this weekend. I know the Duet/HE2 is too deep as I've measured mine and compared with the space available - which is in the 20's not 30's. It's in a walkway next to a doorway and I don't want it sticking out at all into the doorway.

    I don't need a huge one but I'd like one that's reliable and not any more expensive than the HE/Duet models.

  • 19 years ago

    Gibby, if your depth is in the 20s, not the 30s, I think your only options might be the European machines, or maybe the Bosch Axxis.

  • 19 years ago

    Okay - I finally measured this. I have 30x30 for the washer and dryer. Right now I am using two inches behind the washer and almost three behind the dryer for hookups. So I figure I have 27-28" of depth. It sounds like I need to go with Bosch, Asko or Miele. What do you all recommend? I have a Miele dishwasher and while it's nice, I really don't think it's a very good value. I'm just not sure it's "enough better" to justify the much higher price.

    After seeing my TL fly around the room yesterday, out of balance with a small throw rug, I'm looking forward to a FL. I love how that never happens any more with my FL at home.

  • 19 years ago

    We had to cut our laundry room size to accommodate a kitchen expansion, so size became a big issue. In our research, the best option we found for the smallest available full size W/D was the Frigidaire Affinity (7000). We haven't taken delivery yet, so I can't tell you how well they actually work. From what we read online and in publications, these machines give you most of what you get in the ritzier models at a cut-rate price. One downside is that washer's on-board heater only engages on the super-hot cycles rather than constantly regulating water temp. Frigidaire is running a rebate now (I think it ends mid-June (just after we scheduled our delivery). The rebate is misleading online - appears to be only for kitchen appliances, but the w/d are listed once you open the rebate form. Good luck with your decisions.

  • 19 years ago

    Hmmm.....what's the quality/reliability of a Frigidaire?

  • 19 years ago

    Gibby,

    As a space challanged laundry person I envy your 30x30 space! :-) Almost every appliance store website (Best Buy, Lowes...) has the dimensions of products and there are quite a few 27" or so you can try out. Also, for dryer vents, you can reduce the 4" you need for the vent pipe to 2" by using a retangular vent - they have them at all the hardware stores. I myself am limited to about 28" and am really forced to get a Miele/Bosch..., but from my experience you really aren't. Take your time if you can and take a tape measure when you go shopping.

    Thanks,

    Deke

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks Deke - so far I was shopping rather casually and only went by what the store personnel told me - which was that all their frontloaders were as deep as my HE3's. My own tape measure is certainly in order. However I'm also interested in knowing about quality and reliability experiences for anything shallower depth than Duet/HE.

  • 19 years ago

    The Danby is still sold under the Simplicity name. It's a great machine, but the suspension leaves a lot to be desired. I don't put rugs in. It has a very small footprint. Heater rocks.

    The only problems I've had with it are leaking hoses - they rub up against the drum and develop wear holes. I need to have them secured away - should be an easy fix.

    Here is a link that might be useful: online Danby/simplicity

  • 19 years ago

    Jessy, that Danby you describe sounds way more problematic than what I'm looking for.

    I've been reading the specs for Bosch - thought that might be good quality but better value than Miele. It appears that you can either get a good sized washer that's about 31 inches deep or something that must be really small 23x23. Am I missing something on their website or is this right? Most of their models are 31" - a couple are the really small size.

    I guess I'll check Miele too....

  • 19 years ago

    FWIW, I haven't had any problems with my Danby. Plus, after rebates, it was only about $350 incl. tax. The biggest issue has been user error of once making the mistake of washing white cotton WITH ELASTIC at 200 degrees. Oops! Ended up with a lot of elastic curlies in the socks and underwear. Also, I had to learn to wash smaller loads, which I think would be what you would want in a vacation place -- throwing in just a couple of towels or bathing suits without guilt.

  • 19 years ago

    Frigidaire washers are ok, the company used to not have such a good reputation in the past from what I have been told. I bought a fridgidaire front loader in april 2005 and have had no issues with it. its been working flawlessly since new. I even moved with it, god was it heavy to move though.

  • 19 years ago

    Well, maybe that Frigidaire is the way to go. The size seems about right and the price is certainly more favorable than most. If it turned out to be piece o' junk in a few years not so much would be lost so I'd be less concerned about longer term reliability and quality. Does Frigidaire actually make these or is this someone else's rebranded product?

  • 19 years ago

    Okay - I've been investigating more. Frigidaire Affinity is just the right size but after reading more here and elsewhere previous Frigidaire models seemed to have many problems particularly with bearings. I'd like to get an appliance that doesn't have fatal problems at the five year mark. Does anyone know if there has been any improvement in quality of Frigidaire products? And while Consumer Reports may not be perfect I've found it to be pretty reliable on non-high end brands - Frigidaire is never high on the reliability list.

    I'd consider Bosch and but their small sizes are much narrower than my space - I'd rather fill my space and have additional capacity if possible. Plus these are out in the open by my back door so I want a matching dryer - meaning I get a super small dryer too. Frigidaire seems to be the only one that is the "right" size.

    I found a Whirlpool that is also "too small". Does anyone know anything about this one? Model LHW0050P

    Here is a link that might be useful: Whirlpool LHW0050P

  • 19 years ago

    Gibby,
    Consumer Reports data needs to be interpteded cautiously. Their repair data is based on surveys, which have lots of room for error. Who fills out these surveys (not random)? What is the rate of difference between brands? and Remember that "repair rate" info is old data based on machines that could have been improved substantially over the last X years, but the older machines don't reflect that. All these questions could affec the value of the results. Still, the CR results are one piece of data and do reflect past history of a company. So, don't take CR results as "truth" but use it as a guide. That being said, the data we reviewed from CR showed (using percentiles - not a strong type of data) repair rates of 5- 10% with the most comnon # being 6% (5 out of 15 listed). Frigidaire was one of the 6% companies (under gas or electric; can't remember which). LG wasn't listed; I'm guessing because it's too new of a company. Miele and Bosch were also absent from the list (no idea why).

    So, in making our choice of Frigidaire, we looked to see how many "yuk" responses came up on GardenWeb. Every company will have some vocal lemon-owners, so we looked for higher hit rates. Frigidaire seemed to do well on that account, too. Some very knowledgable members of GW also seemed to like it. Other possible data sources are "best rated" purchasing websites and your local repair company.

    I wish I could give you personal experience stories, but our machines haven't been delivered yet. Since the Frigidaire size works so well for you, I'd consider buying from a company that allows returns (without exorbitant restocking fees) if you're unsatisified. Think of the higher price you may pay as "insurance." You can also buy the extended warranty, but I almost never do that. You could also buy using a credit card from a co. that includes "warranty extensions" with purchase as another back-up).

    Good luck!

  • 19 years ago

    The Maytag Neptune (6500) has one of the shallowest footprints of all full size front loaders. Just make sure you get an extended warranty.

    For the dryer you may want to investigate venting through the floor or to one side, instead of taking up space in back.

    I've been able to fit my Neptune 7500 set (same foot print as the 6500) into a laundry closet that has at most 30" depth. I vent the gas dryer through the floor; use an elbow on the gas fitting. It's a tight fit but it works and I can close the bi-fold doors just fine.

  • 19 years ago

    i have the frigidaire affinity and absolutely love it and would recommend it--it's also much more reasonably priced. do get the pedestals, though.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks all

    Yes Ready, I take CR with a grain of salt - but historically it's been very accurate for me for non-high end purchases. I think people who can afford high end items simply aren't into consumer reports so they just don't get enough data to work with on some of those brands.

    I have been reading everything I can find in terms of ratings on Frigidaire - including here - hence the concern about the Frigidaire history of bearing problems and wondering if they've improved. Apparently they've improved their poor quality hinges from what I read.

    I'm kind of leaning toward this though - seems to perform okay and it's just the right size - just the fatal problems at the five year mark that bother me and it's not just a few - it's epidemic. Maybe that has changed in newer models. At least I'd be going in with low expectations. I actually might consider some kind of extended warranty depending on the cost - Lowe's seems quite inexpensive. I think I also have something on one of my credit cards so that's a good idea.

    I know there were lots of complaints about Duet/HE when I bought mine but I went ahead anyway and I've been happy so far - once they replaced the dryer that had fatal electronic problems within the first week.

    Good tip on ducting down or sideways - unfortunately that won't work since that would mean a duct through the middle of a bedroom or a tunnel under a slab.

    What I have is still working so I'm taking my time investigating. If the old ones hold on long enough there may be more options - but is seems like everything keeps getting bigger - not smaller.

  • 19 years ago

    Gibby, have you made a decision yet?

    I just had the control panel and computer on my dryer replaced under an extended warranty. I have another year on that warranty, but now that the kitchen is nearly done, I'm itching to find a better way to use the limited space in my laundry area too. I also don't expect my Calyso pair to last too long beyond that extended warranty and I'd rather replace them on the time of my chosing than theirs.

    The guy who repaired this dryer suggested looking at the Duets (not the sports though) or the Frigidaire. The size and the fact that he said he's only repaired 2 Frigidaire units -- a switch and a slammed door, have me thinking about them. I'm thinking I don't need all the bells and whistles on some of the really expensive machines, but I would prefer a soak setting and a larger dryer drum.

  • 19 years ago

    Lascatx, why not the "sports"? I have the Kenmore version and like them a lot. They've been in operation 7 months now.

  • 19 years ago

    I thought I'd seen more complaints about the sport versions here and the repairman told me not to get them. He says they are made by a different company in a different country than the larger units and that they have more trouble with them.

    I know there are some units of every kind that have problems. I have a Calypso that has worked well. I don't want to push my luck with the one.

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Gibby, the Maytag MAH2400AWW is what your looking for. This is not a Neptune disign. I have worked on a couple here now, and one of the ladies has hers in their cottage at the lake, and has had hers for 5 years with no problems till the other day. Her husband is a welder, pulled a welders chalk out of the pump and its running great again. The other lady, removed some money from her pump on this Maytag FL'r, and its up and working great also. Check this machine out, as I recommend this machine. I also like the smaller Frigidaire models also. Good luck.

  • 19 years ago

    DM, my other issue is size. I have 2 boys, lots of clothes, sheets and towels, camping laundry, sleeping bags, comforters, pool towels -- would like to have a similar sized washer or larger -- not smaller. The sport is a little smaller. Not a lot, but some.

  • 19 years ago

    lascatx - I'm pretty much leaning toward the Frigidaire Affinity. It's really the best size for the space - others including the Maytag mentioned above are "undersized" for my space and I'd really prefer to fill up the space for esthetic reasons - rather than having W/D that looks too small for this space that is out in the open. Since the ones I have are still working I'm just waiting - trying to get more feedback on reliability of these models. Or maybe there would be some other options by the time mine bite the dust. However if they died tomorrow I'd get the Affinity.

  • 19 years ago

    Our machines are still working and are under the extended warranty for another year. Even so, if I have another problem, it's quite likely that they wo't be able to get parts. They almost didn't find them for this dryer repair, so, as we told a salesman today, we could be buying next week or in a year or two. If we figure out a great way to make the laundry room work better, we'll probably do it sooner rather than later.

    Right now, I like the Frigidaire for size, but I like the Duet for the soak cycle and larger size -- especially the dryer capacity. Now to play witht he options. The kitchen was more fun. LOL

  • 19 years ago

    Hello Gibby3000 and lascatx

    Do you need to stack your W/D? If not, might I recommend the Amana Enlighten FLer? I believe it is an aesthetically dressed-up Maytag Neptune 6500/7500 but they seem to come at a pretty decent price! The only catch to that is that you would have to buy them online for I do not see them available yet at Lowe's Best Buy, Sears, etc. However, you may be able to find them at an independent appliance store, though.

    Also, would you consider an HE-TLer? My grandmother has the Maytag Bravos and loves it! But I'll be honest, I've heard mixed reviews on these machines. They seem to be a love it or hate it type of item. I have, however, heard glowing reviews of the GE Harmony HE-TLer here on this forum and elsewhere as well as Fisher and Paykel HE-TLers.

    As far as longevity of any machine, I think it is a crapshoot with whatever you buy because I don't think they make 'em like they used to, except for maybe Speed Queens and Mieles. Hope that helps!! :o)

    Kevin

    Here is a link that might be useful: Amana Enlighten FL washer

  • 19 years ago

    Lascatx, you said Right now, I like the Frigidaire for size; when I was looking, the Affinity had only a very small dryer, much smaller than even the Duet Sport. Just suggesting you double-check since you said size was an issue for you.

  • 19 years ago

    I meant the size of the box or overall size. The depth is our biggest issue. The 3.5 washer apears to be about the same capactiy as what we have, but DH did some internet searching and it appears our current dryer is a 7.4 cu ft one. DH said he was fine with the Frigidaire washer and figured we could work around the lack of a soak cycle somehow, but he was concerned about the smaller dryer. I think finding out that it was 25% smaller than what we have now probably killed the idea. I'm looking now at how find a way to fit the Duets. I have 64" from the back wall to the opposite side of the room. It's not a lot of room to stand in front of the Duets.

    Researcher, I do like the idea of the TL HE. I currently have a Calypso and have really been pretty happy with it. The dryer just had to have the control panel replaced, but that was done under and extended warranty. The TL is really better for me in some regards -- I have several bad discs in my neck and the TL involves less bending and crooning of my neck. I just feel that another one migth be pushing my luck, especially in light of the very mixed reviews I'm seeing. If we don't need to replace sooner, we could wait until next year and see if things improve any. The other factor is that we have thought about stacking the W&D so we could have some space for sorting and folding laundry. The laundry room in this house is the one thing that is smaller and worse than our last house, and it really drives me crazy.

  • 19 years ago

    lascatx, how many inches is the Duet from back wall to the front of the door when the door is open?

  • 19 years ago

    It looks like I would need to allow 55 inches -- 50-1/2 plus 4ish for the vent. The door would open, but there wouldn't be much room to move around. If we stack them, it looks like you need to add an inch and a half.

  • 19 years ago

    Yeah, that would be tight in a 64" area. I wondered because we don't have a laundry room, just a laundry closet, but it opens onto a fairly wide hallway. I forgot to measure last night, but I think the hallway is 3-1/2'-4' wide, which would make the entire width from the back of the laundry closet about much more than 64". I see your dilemma.