Software
Houzz Logo Print
svs128

Woodstove recommendations

16 years ago

I am currently in the market for a new woodstove and would like to hear some review/comments on what is currently available. I'd like to take advantage of the current tax credit.

Our new home currently has a very old and inefficient wood stove. This will be our secondary source of heat - somewhat decorative - but we'd like a stove that could heat the entire first floor of our home if needed (1400 sq ft). No need to be able to cook on it but should look relatively nice as it will be located in our living room. Efficiency is important.

Thanks for your input!

Comments (3)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I lived in the carolinas for years, and always used King wood stoves as my only source of heat. They are roomy enough to accomodate large logs, and they are absolutely simple in their design and operation. The inside is lined with firebrick on bottom and all sides, and it has the opening for the chimney connector located at the top on the back, no baffles or any other restrictions. This will allow a clean burn and little if any buildup of soot and creosote in the chimney or the pipe. The draft is adjustable, and thermostatically controlled to keep the fire burning at a constant rate. (as it gets too hot, the mechanical thermostat closes the draft plate to allow less air into the chamber and reduce the rate of burn) My advice would be NEVER use one of the stoves that has a series of baffles in place to slow the heat/exhaust from escaping to the chimney connector. I used one one season, and had to clean the chimney pipe several times because it would completely plug with hardened soot. Never had to clean the pipe or chimney when using a King, even when burning green pine and soft woods. Never heard anyone talk about the efficiency of a wood stove, so I really have no idea if they are rated high in that area or not. I just know that I heated homes that were about that size with one, and the house was always plenty warm in winter (78-80 degrees). I miss heating with wood, and being able to be toasty warm as I want all winter for free.
    Dave

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I don't know much about standalone ones, if that's what your'e referring to. I grew up with Buck insert in a masonry fireplace at my parents' house. It has (still running after close to 30 years) inlet air and damper controls, as well as a thermostatically-switched 2-speed fan that circulates room air around the outside of the firebox and blows it back into the room.

    We have a small fireplace that I've had thoughts of putting a little insert into over the years. I looked at the Buck ones b/c they make them in the size that I needed. The main improvements over the one from 30 years ago seem to be that you can put in an outside air intake for the fire (means you aren't sucking in room air that's replaced by infiltration from outside). And they have catalytic converters for the exhaust to meet air emissions requirements in parts of the country.

    Part of why I haven't gotten one is that we have a munchkin and the fireplace sits at floor level and doesn't have much of a barrier to the room (my folks' one has a big hearth that's 18" or so raised off the floor).

    Anyway, hope that's useful info- there also are forums out there for everything, even a 'fireplace' one here you might check out.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi,

    We live in Northwest, Ohio. We have a 1500 sq. ft. two story home with a family/living room open to the second floor. All three bedrooms have 4' wide entrys for an easy flow of warm air rising from the first floor. We raised two children in this house.

    For 28 years now we have heated the entire home with a Vermont Castings Defiant wood stove. At full output it develops around 70,000 btu. The flu pipe rises straight up inside the house for 19 feet before it exits outside so we gain some radiant heat from the flu which helps to increase the efficiency of the wood burner.

    There is no other heating system. The well insulated house was built new without a heating system except for the wood burner.

    We have a Marine Grade 316 alloy stainless steel flu pipe. A roofing company rolled it for me in 5' sections and it was an easy install. Ordinary steel flu pipe can melt in half from the high temperatures generated from a creosote chimney fire which is is essentially a coal tar fire. But, marine grade stainless has a higher melting temperature than steel an dit is higher than the maximum temperature generated during a creosote chimney fire, so it will not melt but will glow bright red during a chimney fire. Still scary but much safer than ordinary mild steel. We have the flu pipe professionaly cleaned at the beginning of every heating season for safety and for insurance purposes to show a history of responsible operation.

    Non-catalytic stoves have come a long way and now have much better efficiencies than in the past and far lower particulate emissions. They do not require regular replacement of a catalytic converter since they do not have one. If I were in the market for a new stove I would look at the EPA particulate emissions per stove and choose one with the lowest emissions that was large enough for the needed btu's. Better for your lungs in the long run and reduces outdoor emissions as well.

    Cast Iron stoves, like the Vermont Castings Defiant, are very durable but the seams are not welded together. Some of the stoves are held together with four long screws and all the joints are either caulked with stove cement or a stove rated, rope seal is used. This allows the user to rebuild the stove, replace parts as needed, and recaulk. Welded steel stoves will never need caulking but you may not be able to rebuild the stove either.

    Use a stove top temperature gage from any wood stove supplier, placed a few inches in front of the flu pipe, on top of the stove, to monitor temperature. Overfiring a stove may result in the stove top temperature exceeding 900 degrees F. and when that happens the stove can expand upward. Some of them will do this for one full inch. In a cast iron stove this over firing can cause all the caulk, which does not expand, to lose it's seal in the joint it has been applied to, and after that the stove will leak. No smoke, but you will be able to smell the wood burning. A welded steel stove might not do this.

    Cast iron has a lot more mass than steel and will radiate heat for some time after the fire burns down. Steel cools off a lot faster. Cast iron stoves with soapstone panels are the best heat retainers but take more time to heat up. they are also the best looking.

    It's nice to have a stove with opening front doors. With a spark screen in front of the fire you can enjoy an open fire on a cold winter day

    Hope that helps. Good luck in your search.