Software
Houzz Logo Print
gas_prices_suck

Switching from LP to dual fuel...help!

18 years ago

Hi, This is Mike from Indiana, and I'm sick of getting gouged by high LP prices. I'm definitely switching from my straight LP system and going with a dual fuel system. I'm in Indiana and it gets pretty cold, or I would completely convert to a heat pump.

My sq. footage is around 2950. I have two systems(main floor and upstairs). I built our home in 2005, so all of the ductwork etc. is modern. I thought that I was getting a top of the line/efficient system, but paying way too much for propane is not efficient at all. It makes me sick when the LP truck backs up in the driveway.

Here's what I have:

MAIN FLOOR - 410A - Trane XV90 furnace(TDY080R9V3W4), XL14i AC(4TTX4030A100AB), coil(TXC031C4HPCO), Honeywell VisionPro stat

SECOND FLOOR - 410A - Trane 80% furnace, XL14i AC(4TTX4024A1000AA), Honeywell VisionPro stat

I'm not really concerned about the upstairs LP furnace, because the house is open and the main floor system does the heating workload. I think that my best money spent would be to replace the main floor XL14i AC with an XL15i heatpump. I would still want to keep the LP for when it gets below freezing, thus the dual fuel concept.

I would like to stay with Trane, if for no other reason than that a different brand heat pump would look wierd sitting next to the other AC unit. The Trane XL15i looks identical to the XL14i AC unit.

I have two estimates. One is from the original installer for a Trane XL14i heat pump. It's for $3600 and is basically a swap out of the AC unit for the heat pump.

The second opinion is from another Trane dealer. This quote is $5600 and is for a Trane XL15i heat pump AND a NEW COIL. Yeah...a new coil. This dealer said that I have the wrong coil for my system. It is supposedly 410A and all, but it is only rated for 10 SEER. Now that has got me a little upset if I have an underperforming coil matched to my XV90 and XL14i system. The model #s are above if anyone can make since of it. The second opinion dealer said the the coil that I need is 5.5 inches taller. Was this coil available in '05? Has the original installer goofed up and installed the wrong coil? If they've made a mistake, I've been getting 10 SEER from my 14 SEER system for the past three years. I could see where thay may have goofed up because the crawl space ductwork had many leaks before I used three rolls of sealent tape on it.

I've contacted Trane via their "ask a question" link, but I have gotten 3 incoherent replies from a rookie that knows less than me...or maybe he doesn't want to give the goods on the original installer. Hopefully, I can get some straight honest opinions here. ...any Trane guys out there?

Thanks,

Mike

Comments (4)

  • 18 years ago

    "MAIN FLOOR - 410A - Trane XV90 furnace(TDY080R9V3W4), XL14i AC(4TTX4030A100AB), coil(TXC031C4HPCO), Honeywell VisionPro stat"

    You may be missing a digit in the coil model#. I get a match with that condenser and "TXCB031" coil.

    Use the directory below to search.

    Good luck.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Air conditioning, Heating and Refrigeration Institute Directory

  • 18 years ago

    The TXC031C is a piston coil designed for 10 SEER. It did rate with 12 SEER equipment but required an expansion valve be added to get a full 12. A piston interchanges between the 2 refrigerants so that could could be used with either. Unless a R410a TXV kit was added, you are a long way from 14 SEER with your existing XL14i A/C. If you do want to reuse it with a 14i R410 heat pump, I certainly would suggest a TXV (expansion valve) be added to it to get the SEER closer to 14 though probably will be shy due to the smaller size of the coil.

    The 15i is a better performing heat pump. It gets full heating capacity (the 14i is often very shy) and better HSPF. Looking long term, the 15i with matched coil is a wiser move. Sell the existing coil with your current A/C.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the replies...

    It sounds like the original installing dealer matched the wrong coil to my system? Was there a better-matching coil in '05 that should've been used? I don't believe anything was done as far as a TXV with the coil, as I saw the installer take it out of the box and put it in place. Is there an easy way for me to see if the TXV was installed?

    It sounds like I may have a bargaining chip to use with the original installer.

    This may be a dumb question, but I'm not fully understanding of how HVAC works. Does the A-coil function when the furnace is on?...or just when the AC is on? So the under-performing coil is hampering not only the AC efficiency, but the heating efficiency as well? If so, we are talking some serious dollars between 10 SEER and 14 SEER the past three years.

    Thanks,
    Mike

  • 18 years ago

    "Does the A-coil function when the furnace is on?...or just when the AC is on?"

    The A-coil, also called the evaporator coil, is only part of the air conditioning system. It has nothing to do with the gas furnace. If you have a heat pump (which you don't), it would also be involved with heating.

    "Is there an easy way for me to see if the TXV was installed?"

    The TXV (thermostatic expansion valve) is installed where the small refrigerant line meets the indoor coil (evap coil). You may have to remove the access panel on the air handler cabinet to check if you have a TXV. Some TXV's, like mine, are installed external to the air handler.

    Take care.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting