Software
Houzz Logo Print
bgetchel

Powder or Liquid Tide HE?

19 years ago

We just purchased a set of Samsung FL units from Lowes with "VRT". They're beautiful machines (though my wife wishes I had purchased the blue instead of the "Tango" red).

Everything I have read seems to indicate that POWDER detergents work better than liquids, but I did buy both liquid and powder Tide HE variants just to be safe.

Anyway, we've used the powder exclusively for the first few batches of clothes, and it seems to work very well. Unfortunately however, the glass door has some very noticeable undissolved powder residue and/or spots after the load has finished. On cold washes there is significantly more residue.

Should we abandon powers altogether or should we first try to use less? Right now we're using nearly a full scoop full (the scoop that came in the Tide HE box) for most loads. Or should we just ditch the powder and switch to liquid? Or should we mix it up?

I've read most of the varying opinions and analysis, that the detergent in liquids is NOT actually dissolved and that the detergent actually dissolves at the same temperatures as in powder, but that could just be heresay (or heresy). I'd prefer not to sacrifice the cleaning potential of powder since it does seem to perform noticeably better, but if it's going to adversely affect a $1,500 washer we will, of course, fore go the use of powders.

Thanks in advance.

Comments (7)

  • 19 years ago

    I can answer just one part of your post -- you don't need the full scoop to get your wash clean -- about half the recommended dose of Tide HE powder is plenty. I used the liquid first and then switched to the powder (also using full scoop at first) and find the powder much more effective (Kenmore HE2t washer).

  • 19 years ago

    I have a 3.5 cu.ft. Kenmore 44092 (twin of Frigidaire 2940). I use a quarter-cup measuring cup so it doesn't vary in case the vendor-supplied cup changes along the line. 1/4 C of Tide HE powder works well, hot or cold water, and I have never seen undissolved detergent on the glass plug at the front of the tub.

    I don't like the way liquid detergents slime up the insides of the chute below the detergent tray, so I rarely use them.

  • 19 years ago

    FWIW, I use Tide HE powder in my Duet....about 1/4-1/3 cup for full load with soft water. How much you use will have to do with your own water quality.

    What temperature wash/rinse are you using? Do you know actual temp? Suspecting failure to dissolve may be related.

    How large a load are you washing? If the load us unable to slosh around freely, that could be part of it.

  • 19 years ago

    I use liquid detergents for everything except whites/hot water washes. For those I use Tide He powder so that I can mix in a scoop of OxyClean with the detergent for a cleaning boost.

  • 19 years ago

    Tide HE powder
    Use 1/4-1/2 cup per load.
    Clorox 2 powder
    Use 1/4-1/2 cup per load.

  • 19 years ago

    I switched from liquid to powder Tide when I bought a new W/D set, to take advantage of the timer feature (manual says not to use liquid det. when using the timer b/c it can drip down on the clothes prematurely). Also b/c I use powdered Oxyclean frequently and the manual also says not to mix powdered stuff and liquid stuff in the detergent dispenser.

    Anyhow, I've also found that 1/4cup (i.e. a measuring cup, not the scoop that comes in the Tide box) is perfect for a full load in my Kenmore He2t. We have relatively soft water. If I'm doing a partial load I adjust downward accordingly. It took me a few weeks to get the amounts figured out but now I never have problems with soap residue or suds left at the end. It just takes some getting used to :)!

  • 19 years ago

    bgetchel-Tell me how well you like your machine. I have read a couple of other post on this machine. Is yours as quiet and vibration free as they say??
    About the Tide-if you go to the liquid I would watch it. For me it makes a lot more suds than the powder,but your water has a lot to do with that.