Software
Houzz Logo Print
alldaylaundry

Has anyone tried SA8 detergent?

18 years ago

Wondering if it cleans well, what the scent is like, and how much you settled on using? My MIL uses and loves it, and says it is a huge money saver as she only uses half of the recommended amount. I'd like to try the powder, any comments on it versus the liquid version?

Comments (5)

  • 18 years ago

    I bought the powder in April, to try with my new FL. At that time, Consumer Reports rated it very highly. I couldn't see why it was rated so high. You use a very small amount, and it did as good a job as other top-of-the-line detergents, but I didn't think it was worth the price. I did like the SA8 matching enzyme cleaner for non-greasy food stains. Then my son started complaining about itchy underwear. I can't really say that it was all the SA8, because this was soon after I bought my FL, and maybe I wasn't rinsing things as thoroughly as with my old TL. However, I read about Charlie's Soap on these forums and bought a bag of the powdered detergent. The first load, he noticed a big difference in softness. Well, when a teenaged boy notices a difference in how I wash his underwear because it feels softer--I'm sold! My sister later suggested that I always rinse twice, so I started doing that, as well--but *after* starting using Charlie's, so the extra rinse is probably overkill. I never use fabric softener, by the way.

  • 18 years ago

    We also bought some powder SA8 for our new FL washer based on the Consumer Reports recommendation. I agree we the above post with regard to cleaning ability (good) and the softness issue (not good). Using the extra rinse and vinegar helped with the softness issue. We used about half what is recommended, but I agree it is still overpriced. Probably will not buy again.

  • 18 years ago

    I have a friend who swears by SA8 and uses nothing else - and has for many years now. But as pointed out, it's really expensive per load. Charlie's soap is about 11-cents per load when you purchase the 5-gallon (1280 load) bucket.

    Another Charlie's fan here. No softener used, other than some white vinegar in the bath towel load, and the kitchen towel load. No extra ingredients except to pre-spot things, and I usually use Charlie's All-Purpose Cleaner for that.

    -Grainlady

  • 16 years ago

    Yes I have tried and they are the best. Check this link for cheaper SA8 products. http://www.amway.com/healthnutrition

    Here is a link that might be useful: Amway

  • 11 years ago

    I wanted to make quick post, just for reference.


    I was given two bottles, of the "Legacy of Clean" Fabric Softener in the "Floral" Scent. If you smell it straight from the cap, it's got a strong, rubbing alcohol scent to it. But... your clothes don't come out with that smell to them.


    They really come out, with a... sorta better smelling, floral scent to them. Very Strong, I might add. Definitely different. Honestly, I don't think I'd go out of my way to buy it... but, it's definitely not bad. And it rinses out of the dispenser really well, so it's not likely to gunk up a machine.


    Mitch :)