Software
Houzz Logo Print
mara_2008

About laundry detergent - has anyone noticed this?

17 years ago

Whenever I run to the grocery store for just a few things, I still take a few moments to go down the laundry products aisle to see what they have for HE washers. (Mine is a Maytag HE TL).

Maybe everyone else knows this, but I just noticed yesterday that detergents labeled "HE" have the words "2X Ultra", while other detergents which are not labled "HE" also have the words "2X Ultra" on the label.

What gives? If I'm the last one to notice this, please be gentle. ;-)

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If I'm not mistaken it means "ultra concentrated" formula so you use less. Of course it seems that the bottles are smaller so you're also getting less......

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    So - are the formulas the same, regardless of whether "HE" is on the label, or not? That's what I'm wondering.

    Yes, you're right - the bottles are definitely smaller. But not cheaper.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Some detergents are also 3X concentrated too. If it doesn't have HE on it, it is not for FLs. I never liked the concentrated detergents. Somehow it just didn't seem to work for me w/ dosing.l I always had to use more than they said so it actualy cost me more money.That's when I started using the regular detergent mixed w/ HE and it worked, but I found this forum and learned about CS thanks to you guys and now I save ton of money and don't have to fiddle w/ adjusting anything anymore.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    mara, yes I noticed it too, but it seems now most all liquid detergents are "ultra" concentrated, HE or not. My thinking is that it's the mfg's way of selling more, because they figure people will still use more than the recommended amount because it's what most people are used to doing.

    I think that's when my problems started using the liq Tide HE when it went 2X Ultra. I was probably using way too much and it was building up on everything I washed. My Neptune didn't have a window in the door, so I couldn't see how much sudsing was going on, but I did notice our clothes and towels getting noticeably stiffer and then there was that awful musty smell! One day I finally watched as it drained out the rinse water and there was still a huge amount of suds. That's when the light went on for me, lol.

    I'm glad I found this forum and bought some powder HE detergent. Unless liquid detergents change in the future, I'm going to stay with powders from now on. I'm currently using Sears HE Powder, but I also bought a small box of SUN with oxygen bleach from the Dollar store just to try. It's supposed to be quick dissolving and has dosing amounts for front loader machines, but I think it's still saying to use way more than one would need, because it says to start with a small amount like 1/4C and add more until the suds are half way up the door!!! I have been using just half the scoop from the Sears detergent and I think it's plenty.

    I have tried Charlie's, but I'm still not convinced it's right for me. Maybe I have to give it more time.

    Janet

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Liquid detergent gunked up my washer. Now I use Sears and I tried a scoop of my neighbors cheap detergent and it didn't suds much.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I agree, I also think that liquid detergents leave behind gunk in the washer and it is a major contributor to the famous FL washer "musty" smell. People who use powdered detergents seem to have way less of a problem with this than people who use liquid detergents.
    After a year of using liquid detergents our TL washer it started to stink too. We switched back to powdered detergents and eventually the odor went away.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think people have a tendency to use more than is directed or needed b/c they think it will clean better, this my be true if the clothes are heavily soiled and there is a prewash and extra rinse, but other wise not.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Many time the instructions on detergents tell you to fill to line one for medium loads. There is no mention of soil level. This is something the detergent manufacturers have left out. If your clothes have no visible stains you don't need as much detergent. I NEVER follow the manufacturer's recommendations. Instead I try it a few times until I find the amounts that work for my soil levels and water conditions.

    Another thing is that many HE detergents sold make too many suds to begin with. Tide comes to my mind. You can see this if you use some of the European detergents. Many of them create less suds, and the composition of the suds is more compact instead of being frothy. I find that these detergents rinse better in my water conditions than many sold in NA. On top of this detergent additives also contain surfactants and increase the suds produced. As the emphasis on water conservation, and lower fill machines continues it would be great if manufacturers stepped up to the plate and made lower sudsing, better rinsing products in the first place. Foamy suds are not required for cleaning. The cleaning action is happening in the water- same for liquid dish detergents no need for the suds.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    cynic, why should there be a connection between reduction in water consumption, and reduction in detergent usage? You aren't cleaning the water, you're cleaning the laundry.

    As for regular vs HE detergents, this PDF

    http://www.cleaning101.com/laundry/HE.pdf

    is worth reading.

    I don't believe the HE detergent thing is a conspiracy by the detergent manufacturers, aided by the appliance makers, to get more of our money. In fact, I imagine that the current system of non-HE and HE detergents is a shelf-space and inventory headache for manufacturers and grocers, and they'd be happy to sell universal detergents instead.

    The manual for my Miele says that too little detergent may cause mineral buildup on the heating element. This is probably not unique to Miele, though maybe not everyone warns about it.

    What is your pattern of cold vs. warm vs. hot washes, in your washer which is free of gunk after 20 years of liquid detergent? BTW, this is a non-HE machine, right?