Software
Houzz Logo Print
tuba_paul

Calling all kitchen designers! Looking for ideas...

17 years ago

So, I posted the question earlier about whether I should leave a coat closet alone, remove it to add some kitchen space, or steal some kitchen space and turn it into a powder room--consensus seems to be that the powder room would be most useful (house is a 3 bedroom 1 bath ranch) and add the most value.

Which leads me to the next question--how would I use this space most efficiently? Here are the existing kitchen dimensions:

I've indicated where the existing plumbing, gas and 220v power is--no trouble changing location of gas and power, I'm less excited about moving the plumbing.

I have a 30" gas stove and a 12" Miele radiant combiset (my stove has an odd burner configuration--a triple ring 16k btu front right, a simmer burner rear right, and a 27k griddle burner on the left side ('U' burners left front and back with a 'II' bridge burner in the middle) so I thought I might use the two-burner combiset next to the stove and put a 48" hood across both which would give me 4 burners and a griddle), but I was also thinking of putting the combiset in the basement in a bar/mother-in-law's kitchen. Someday I'd like to have a 48" bluestar heritage, but budget won't allow it at this point... I am leaning towards a counter-depth fridge.

I also have an Elkay Avado EFU401810CDB sink (40x18-1/2) but I'm not emotionally tied to the sink--if it doesn't fit in I will use it in the basement or sell it. So, if you are in love with this sink, make me an offer! :^) Kohler has a cast iron large single bowl sink I kind of like...

At this point, I'm leaning towards white cabs with a marble or pale green subway tile backsplash and a combination of soapstone and butcherblock countertops. There is a small pantry by the rear door and basement stairs. Walls will be sage or mustard, the rest of the house will be a warm grey--cobblestone or taupe, whatever they call that these days.

So, knock yourselves out! Turn the coat closet into a powder room, move walls around--whatever you want in order to come up with a kitchen that has a good work triangle. I am open to dine in kitchen with less storage as well as a 'cook's' kitchen with no seating, as there is a separate dining room, and I do enjoy cooking... and I wouldn't mind opening up the space to the dining room and/or living room in some way--the wall between kitchen and dining room is not load bearing, the wall between kitchen and living room is, but a support beam can be put in to deal with that, there is already a soffit or whatever it's called on the ceiling between the living room and dining room...

Here is a link that might be useful: What is more important--a coat closet, powder room, or kitchen space?

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago

    I hate to burst everybody's bubble, but have you thought of how much space the "powder room" will have ? Right now you have a 30" x 36" space is that interior room space or the dem. on outside of closet, cuz I just scaled the whole thing out on paper- just for giggles & I don't think it'll work as a powder room even taking a few feet out of kitchen, which is all you could take.
    Gotta go for now- I'll try to scan & post pic. later.

    Here is a link that might be useful: granite countertops

  • 17 years ago

    Where are you thinking the door would be? I personally wouldn't like a powder room opening directly into the kitchen. Where is the pantry? Is it off a back hallway? Would that work as a powder room and you could use the coat closet as a pantry?

    I didn't see any of the previous discussion, so I missed what was suggested earlier.

  • 17 years ago

    The powder room would have to more than double in size and take up the whole corner between the two doorways. It could be done because it is not a particularly useful space over there, being between two doorways but the door Would have to open either into the kitchen or into that space that says rear entry, pantry and stairs. And the door would have to be a pocket door or-- it could open into the powder room but the sink would have to be tiny in depth.(I had a powder room that was 3 x 6 something with an inswinging door, you would have less space) You also had to manouver around a bit to get in and close the door.

  • 17 years ago

    I figured I'd loose that corner entirely, which would make for a 3' x not quite 6' powder room (door swinging out into the kitchen--I don't like pocket doors on bathrooms), and it would have to open into the kitchen (basement stairs on the other side).

    I'm toying with the idea of removing the living room and dining room walls entirely and putting a dual height iesland (bar hight on the living room side), which would open up the house as well as make the powder room door into the kitchen less of an issue.

    Pantry is too small for anything--only 22" deep.

    Thanks!

  • 17 years ago

    Can you post a layout of the entire first floor? Simple sketch sort to scale is fine, doesn't need to be as detailed as the plan view above..

  • 17 years ago

    There are code requirements you must meet for a PR...e.g., the distance b/w the front of the toilet & the wall or vanity (usually 21" or 36"), distance b/w toilet & wall or vanity on the sides (15" from center of toilet to wall or vanity), etc. (Red in diagram shows code or manufacturer requirements, blue suggested.)



    Right now, I think you're going to have to move some doors if you want to fit a PR in the closet space. Here are a couple of possibilities. Both keep the walls mostly in place b/w the DR & LR for some room definition, but w/some changes.

    The LR doorway moves to the right to accommodate the PR in both cases & is about 5" wider than it was.

    Note that your kitchen is really too narrow & short for an island unless you eliminate at least one wall of cabinets and fiddle with the walls. (You should have approx 42" aisles around the island/54"-60" on the seat side, 15" overhang if no sink or range in island/18"-24" overhang if range or sink in island.)

    The first one leaves the plumbing, gas, venting in the same general location... You could make the DR doorway a little narrower to protect the range...maybe 48" or 54" instead of 60".


    This one moves things around... I wasn't sure if the south east wall was an outside wall or inside...and I wasn't sure how it fits in the rest of the house. If you cannot open it up as far south as I show, then you will have to add approx 6" filler b/w the refrigerator & wall to allow the refrigerator to open fully...or put in a 12" pull out utility cabinet b/w the refrigerator & wall.

  • 17 years ago

    If the sink and toilet were Across from each other they could share the minumum floor space (30" for toilet 21" in front of toilet and a tiny wall mounted sink would fit in the 62" (+4" wall) between the side of the closet and the back entry door. Internally it would have to be 36" wide so a 4" wall makes 40" so the door would need to be shifted slightly from the front hall. I see this type of bath in NYC apartments a lot. It would be tiny but it would make the kitchen less L shaped and prevent too much of the work triangle from extending beyond that bathroom enclosure. In my location, the minimum for a powder room door used to be 24"...now it may be 28".

  • 17 years ago

    Wow--helpful post, buehl, thank you for that. The south wall with window is an outside wall, the east wall is non-load bearing and can be removed entirely withou issue. Is there a reason the stove would work better on one side than the other, or is it purely personal preference/aesthetic?

    Palimpsest, I was thinking of the toilet and sink facing each other as well, but with buehl's idea, I could rotate the entire affair and have three choices for doorway location, which has a certain appeal--it does take some space away, though.

    I wasn't too keen on putting a bathroom in the basement--it's unfinished, but I do have overhead sewer--perhaps I should revisit the idea?

    I would be reusing the closet door as the bathroom door, it's birch and 29", and I have 3 pretty small SS sinks that I could use for the lav--two are round (a vessel and an undermount) and one's a seashell--pretty proud of that one, as I made it myself!

    bmorepanic, I'm about to run around with a measuring tape--full layout is on the way!

    Thanks again,
    Paul

  • 17 years ago

    One thing that we havent really considered is where the plumbing stack is, and where your other plumbing is.

  • 17 years ago

    Palimpsest,
    The existing plumbing is west of the pantry (about 4 feet past the print shown above). The overhead line that goes out to the street is under the pantry--tying in to that in the basement would not be an issue, I can run straight S to the wall and then over to the main out without running into troubles--basement ceiling is high enough and there's nothing structural in the way. It is an unfinished basement, as well.