I think you DO dare hope.

Sometimes people just need a jump start, even if they do have hoarding tendencies. And sometimes hoarding tendencies are just inertia, really.

She's also gotten a really big reward--being able to find and use her mother's stuff. That's always good for a dose of energy.

Way to go, and what a great strategy.

Now, when's your next visit, so you can get her started on the linen closet?

That's great news! Sounds like a really great accomplishment!

Sadly we only get up there about once a year (we're in Texas, she's in Maryland), so she'll have to hold the fort alone for quite a while.

Oh, the linen closet!! I'd love to get some old nasty things out of there! And I've already started working on the "animal shelters could really use some of those old towels" strategy.

I should have mentioned that she allowed DH and his brother to remove 2 giant broken console TVs from the 70s along with other assorted large trash items and take them to the dump - kinda makes me glad I don't have a basement so I can't be tempted to store large crap. (DH's brother lives close to her and helps her out, but these were things he couldn't lift by himself and he's too embarrassed to ask a friend to go into his mom's house).

Jena,

What a great time had by all! That is just SO wonderful that your MIL has realized that there ARE things she doesn't need. The "animal shelter needs old towels" idea was a good hint!

If you can make this your "thing in common" it might help keep her motivated until you see her again. Like if you can tell her, "Would you believe I found a shirt in my closet I haven't worn in 10 years??" might compel her to look in HER closet to see if she can clean out things she doesn't wear, too. Or if you say, I got rid of that ___ in the back bedroom, and then gush about how much BETTER the room looks to have that thing gone from your house. Or tell her, "Why did I find 6 butter bowls cluttering up my cabinet when I NEVER use them?" And tell her, "I just got rid of a fake flower arrangement Aunt Susie gave me 20 years ago... and I don't know why I kept it because as much as I love Aunt Susie it's the ugliest arrangement I've evern seen" so she knows she doesn't have to keep things just because someone special gave them to her. Little things like that might get her thinking more!

Why not ask her if she would like a gift certificate for a professional organizer to help her continue? Now that she's on a roll, she may be very open to that and the "towels to the shelter" stuff would be forthcoming with other items.

Gloria

I just took about 10 big black plastic bags of clothes to a local shelter store. I can easily declutter someones elses stuff but mine is a different story. My big problem is storing it somewhere until I get rid of it.

I enjoyed reading your success story.

I have a friend in your MIL's situation (probably worse) and she has been saying for years that she is going to get rid of a bunch of this 'stuff'. I have offered to help her in any way I can, but the day never comes that she wants to get started on it.

If I could just get rid of the piles of sale bills and junk mail, and box (by years) all the important things (receipts, etc), it would be a great improvement.

Not wanting to upset her, or 'make her nervous' about it all, I don't push the issue.

I do fortunately get to take off the recycles, but often cannot find where all the newspapers are, and it makes her nervous, if I even just look for them a bit.

Sue...

If you wanted to make a project of helping someone like Sue's friend, I wonder if they'd have less anxiety if you made it less a "let's get this stuff out of your house" and more of a "other people need things; let's see what we can give to them out of generosity."

You know, "the high-school art class is collecting newspapers--let's find as many as we can for them!"

Or, "the day-care center is collecting old margarine tubs to use when painting; wouldn't you like to help those cute little kids?" (of course, then they might save them even harder, so she'll have them to pass on)

or "a family at my friend's church just had a fire; could you give them some clothes? or linens? or extra kitchenware and tableware?" (whatever your eye tells you is most important)

talleu_sue:

You have hit on something that I have found works with "hoarders". I have members of my family that are like this. You need to convince them that they should give their stuff away. It is less painful since many of them keep that stuff because they don't want to waste it.

Even if they give it to you, and then you go home and throw it away or bring it to goodwill.

Often times, churches will take your old furniture and clothes and stuff. They have lots of contacts of needy families, call them up and they can see if they can use it.

But the old food, that is just a health hazard... that's gotta go. I know one time I took 3 garbage bags full of ancient expired food in cans and boxes, like old soup, hamburger helper out of a family members pantries.

Jena --congrats on making her get started. I like Talley's ideas about motivating savers. For some of us its hard to just throw stuff out or even give it to Goodwill--but I have found people who take clothing to Mexico for families who need help, and that makes it easier to transfer an item which is almost new.
Churches and the food banks collect canned food items this time of year thats a good destination for extra (not expired) canned food.
Its also a good time to go through the Christmas decor now and collect items which somebody else could use before the season is over.

Warning:
I tried the "generosity" approach once with my step-MIL. Turns out she wouldn't give anything away without proof that the recipients were worthy of, and truly needed, her donations. Quite frankly, it wasn't worth it to me to get a note from my son's art teacher that she needed EXACTLY "x" number of butter bowls, with a notation on EXACTLY what she needed them for so my MIL would know whether or not the teacher also TRULY needed the lids.

Oh no Julie, that's horrible! Fortunately my MIL is very big on giving to charity - I swear she sends a check to any organization that sends a request, so playing to her desire to help society works on her.

But I know my grandma (who was a HUGE hoarder) would never have been convinced to part with stuff just to help others. Her argument was that if they needed it, they should have gone out and bought it - afterall, her stuff came from garage sales and goodwill anyway, so they had their chance to buy it cheap. Sometimes you just can't win. We never got her house cleaned out until she was in the nursing home.