Software
Houzz Logo Print
2ajsmama

Depression in sheetrock suddenly appeared

17 years ago

Hi, I've got a wall under a window that I think I may have skimmed last year (hard to remember all the spots I've skimmed here - this wall was fairly straight, no problems with baseboard so if I skimmed it it was just b/c there were some air bubbles in original paint job, I don't recall a nail pop/sink there). I repainted, we put up baseboard and a new window stool this year and a quarter-sized dimple appeared in the paint, months after repainting/baseboard but before putting in new stool! The house is 2 years old. I skimmed some ready-mixed compound over yesterday, even after it dried that spot seems to "give" when pressed. Not sure why this suddenly appeared - will setting-type compound get rid of it? It's almost like some gypsum might be missing from behind, though the paper is intact, but the perplexing thing is that the spot is almost round, very regular edges, not jagged so it's not like the back got ripped. It's almost as if as the house dried out (or settled?) that spot just sank, without cracking the paint. It is fairly close to the cripple on the right side of the window (about 4"), but it's not *on* the stud, and as far as I can tell there is no screw/nail head within the dimple.

Any ideas how to make this disappear forever?

Comments (22)

  • 17 years ago

    It's hard to say without actually seeing it, but it could be anything...almost want to blame moisture because it is below a window. We also see this sometimes when the drywallers used a nail and missed the stud by just a bit so what you end up with is a floating nail head causing problems because the drywall isn't secure there. The only real way to fix it is to cut out with a razor knife whatever it is causing the movement and then fill it. If it is a floating nail/screw, then find the stud that was missed and secure the drywall there with a screw.

  • 17 years ago

    It's really weird b/c I can't see or feel a nail head - the paper looks pristine, it's just like there's nothing *behind* the paper. I was thinking moisture (or lack thereof) too. So the ready-mix patch wasn't helping since it was just making the paper wet when I put it on. I picked up 20-min setting compound yesterday - think that'll work? Cutting it out is last resort but I told DH that might be what we'd have to do. The drywall *is* secured to the cripple 4" away. It's just this one little spot that's moving/sinking, the rest of the wall (app. 27" high x 36" wide) is fine, no cracks, no mushy spots. And by mushy I don't mean wet - there is no moisture visible on the surface of the paint (though who knows what's on the other side of the drywall).

    If I have to cut it out, can I cut out just that spot and put a small 2"x2" piece of tape, fill? Or do I have to cut out a section of sheetrock and put a new section in (we've got spare partial sheet in the basement)? I'm not great at taping, either way I'm afraid the tape would show but I don't want to try to replace the whole section from inside corner to outside corner (this is a side bay). Thanks

  • 17 years ago

    The 20 minute setting compound will work fine, but you really need to remove whatever it is behind the paper facing causing the issue. I wouldn't use any tape or replace any part of the wall just yet. Just cut the bubble out so you can see what is moving behind it, remove whatever that is and then patch the hole with a couple coats of compound. After you have cut through the paper facing, pressing on the wall surrounding the hole sometimes will reveal what is moving so you know what you need to remove.

  • 17 years ago

    Occasionally a sheet of drywall has voids under the paper in manufacturing. If they become annoying, you have to cut off the blistered paper and tape with durabond, (finish off with any kind of regular mud that you have.)
    It's not unusual that these spots appeared after painting or taping, as moisture seems to bring them to notice.
    Casey

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks guys but I'm confused - it's not "bubbled" or "blistered", it's sunken. It could be a void under the paper as Casey said. But how would cutting out the spot help? I'm assuming there isn't anything behind it, really feels like just the paper. So I'm thinking I'll see insulation if I cut it! Then will have to patch it either with tape or a small piece of drywall?

    I can try taking a pic in the AM but might be hard to tell with a coat of mud on it from the other day. Here's a pic from July when I first noticed it (just getting around to fixing it now).

    Casey - I only know Durabond as thinset - do they make a tape? Or are you saying mesh tape, thinset (to get it to set hard), then mud?

    Thanks

  • 17 years ago

    OK, I googled Durabond and found that USG (makers of Sheetrock) make a setting-type joint compound called Durabond. The only thing Lowes had was the Lightweight setting compound - I'll have to check Home Depot. But I'm still confused as to what you think could be behind the sunken spot and how much I'm supposed to cut out (just "X" the paper and fold back if possible to keep damage to minimum?) and what I might have to remove from behind? I'm afraid of opening a can of worms and making the cosmetic problem worse!

  • 17 years ago

    Okay, Durabond these days is pretty much just a generic term. You don't really need Durabond and you probably don't even want it because it dries rock hard and is very hard to sand. Just get some USG EasySand 20. The EasySand products are what a lot of us refer to as Durabond even though it is not. I wouldn't really make an X, but I would cut out the actual circle of the depression. You really have to fill the void behind the paper if that is what it is because that dead space behind is inhaling the drywall paper and causing the depression which is why you have to keep fixing it over and over....this is my best guess. I would fill the hole with the EasySand, however many coats it takes. You can use tape over the hole, but then you may have to float a huge patch over the area to disguise the tape....depends on the size of the hole. IMO, if you can fill the hole with mud and not use tape, I would do that.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks - Sheetrock (USG) brand EasySand 20 is what I picked up this w/e. If I want to fill the hole, don't I need some type of backer? Use mesh tape pushed inside the hole, stuck to back side of drywall?

    Thanks - I'm going to try this tomorrow (so it looks really bad when the tax assessor comes over LOL).

  • 17 years ago

    I would just fill the hole with the EasySand. There is a way to do it so that the mud sort of sticks to the edges of the hole....really hard to explain online. This won't work if the hole is too big though and all your mud will just fall into the hole. Then you would have to use tape or the mesh tape would work just fine too.

  • 17 years ago

    Being under a window I would also suspect moisture problems.

    When you said it feels like it's just paper it reminded me of something else I've seen in the past. Have you ever heard any weird noise coming from that area? I have seen something similar in ceilings where paper wasps created a nest in an area and there was nothing left except for the thin layer of paint.

  • 17 years ago

    I got up the courage to cut the paper this AM, it's like the gypsum was crushed just under the paper (little chunks) even though the paper was intact and the backing is solid. Maybe a void like Casey said? So I will just fill the hole (1/4" deep?) with the Easysand and try to smooth the final layer out flush. Should I use the bucket stuff for the final coat?

  • 17 years ago

    I just cut out more paper til I hit solid wall, but when I press on the stuff inside (after blowing the powder out of the hole), it moves. It's like there are 2 layers of gypsum and they're not bonded together. Do I have to cut out what's left in the center? Then I'm afraid I'll have no backing. If I just vacuum out the loose stuff and fill with 2-min setting compound, will it go in the crack b/t the layers and bond it? When I press the wall on the outside of the hole, it's solid. Thanks

    This is all the stuff that fell out/I blew out. Didn't vacuum anything yet.

  • 17 years ago

    I would cut out anything that moves when the mud is dry. If nothing is moving, it should be good to patch.

  • 17 years ago

    So I'm OK to fill over the inner/back part that's moving now? Just see if the first layer of Easysand makes it stiff?

  • 17 years ago

    oh, just for reference, the hole is now a little bigger than a silver dollar - about 2" diameter.

    Think I can just start filling it with the 20-min setting compound and then smooth/sand final coat (ready-mix?) flush if it doesn't move after I get it close to flush with several coats of the setting compound?

  • 17 years ago

    Yes. The ready mix stuff is actually better for final coat because it's very sandable.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks - didn't get to it yesterday b/c DD came home with fever just as tax assessor drove up (and she didn't say a word about the hole, just was interested if we finished master bath - I could have told her No over the phone!).

    I will try to get 2-3 coats (since it sets in 20 min - or should I allow a day b/t coats?) on today, see if it moves, if not will do final coat Sat or Sun.

  • 17 years ago

    You can recoat in 20 minutes, but it may be hard to sand until tomorrow.

  • 17 years ago

    Oh, let's see, I put a coat on around 10:30, it looks dry now (didn't look dry by 11) so I'll put another coat on. It did feel pretty solid but then I pushed too hard and the middle cracked - think I can go over it or do I have to dig the cracked stuff out now? Ooops! I didn't over-fill, wanted thin coat so it would dry, wiped around the hole with wet paper towel so I shouldn't have to sand the 20-min stuff, I plan on just doing ready-mix green lid stuff for final coat.

    Thanks for your help!

  • 17 years ago

    I dug out the middle - still seems a little cool/darker color so not quite dry? Maybe I mixed it too wet (hard to mix just a small amount). Anyway, the middle moves - do you think the EZ Sand will bond the back of the drywall to the front of the patch, or do I have to cut all the way through (and find some way to get backer material in there?)?

    At this point I'm wondering how good a patch it has to be, since we'll eventually put a window seat/built in bookcases there? That might be 10 years from now though...

  • 17 years ago

    I decided to dig out all the patch that I just cracked and start over. The original gypsum came with it, so now instead of a 1/4" deep hole with moving gypsum in the back, I've got a 1/2" deep hole with moving *paper* the only thing b/t me and insulation! What to do now????

  • 17 years ago

    I suppose if you can't patch it without using tape then you need to use tape. The mesh tape would probably work best because it is adhesive.

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals