Software
Houzz Logo Print
groomingal

Turd burglar needs help-warning gross

19 years ago

So here is my dilema.

Lucy is our shih tzu that is almost 3 years old. I took Lucy in around 3 months ago from a family that couldn't keep her, too busy, children, you know the story. The lady was a client at our vet clinic and Lucy was very sweet. Well I was duped, Lucy is a housebreaking nightmare!

In the last 3 months I have exhausted every resource of my animal knowledge to work with her. She has no medical problem and she is on a timed schedule with food, water, and potty trips. This leads to my problem with her peeing all over my dining room and (was) newly carpeted stairs and pooing everywhere. Gets worse, she eats poo. Not just hers, the other 2 dogs if they have an accident (not often), and my DD's diapers. She will get DD poo diapers and eat as much poo as possible. If you scold her she will poo and turn around and eat it. Darn turd burglar. She is eating so much poo that she throws poo up in the middle of the night. Don't worry she eats it as soon as she pukes it. This cannot be healthy.

I tried to find her a new home about 6 weeks ago and couldn't do it. I felt so guilty for taking her in and then giving up on her. Now DH and I are at the end of our rope. She has caused absolute chaos in our home. I spend the majority of my time scrubbing floors, carpet, the dog(she gets average 3 baths a day), or bickering with DH about the dog. DH is mainly concerned with the sanitary side and I agree. We have 2 children and are in the process of selling our home. A nasty dog does not benefit either of those.

DH says she needs a new home. I agree, but I think she should have a forever home. I'm so worried that she will bounce from home to home, and that is not fair. Do I keep her so I don't feel guilty and just struggle with the cleaning and bickering or find her a new home and let it go?

I love her dearly but the chaos she is causing is putting a serious strain on our family.

So here is my question, what would you do with her?

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "I love her dearly but the chaos she is causing is putting a serious strain on our family."

    There is your answer.

    I can't imagine the total stress this little dog is causing you. It will be difficult, but your priority is your family, and your sanity! Find a rescue group. There might even be a Shitzu rescue in your area. Tell them about her problems. They are better equipped to work with her than you are at this point. You're already under stress, and moving is only going to add to that.

    I had to give a dog away not too long ago. I'd adopted her from a shelter and had to take her back. I realized she needed much more time than I could give, and my other dogs were miserable. They are 12 and 14, and were obviously distressed. I felt terrible, but in the end, it was the only thing to do.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sounds like my first year trying to train Aleksander. My friend thought we had sculpted carpet in the living room because of the trailing pee stains. We don't have the diaper issue, but Aleks made up for it by eating rotten rat/squirrel/rabbit carcasses when we went walking in the woods.

    What finally helped is crating and tethering. What a godsend. If he was out of the crate, he was attached to me via a 6 foot long leash. The only time he wasn't in the crate or on the 6 foot leash was for potty breaks outside- I used a 20 foot retractable leash for that. After several weeks, he finally got it. Huskies are so stubborn!

    The other 2 useful behaviors I trained Aleks for were leave it and to sit and wait before eating anything. Leave it worked if he found something that I didn't see outside and went to eat it; I used it for both drop it and don't pick it up. Inside, he had to sit and wait for his food, if something fell when I was cooking he had to sit and wait for me to say OK to eat it, etc.

    The thing is that took a LOT of work and time. I don't have kids to deal with and only 1 other dog who thankfully had different less time-consuming issues. Plus my husband was very helpful in training both dogs. And we hired a professional trainer for several weeks of in-home sessions. If I didn't have that kind of time, money, and help, I probably wouldn't have been able to keep him. I'm glad I did; things worked out beautifully between us and since Aleks died in May I've missed him terribly. But if you don't have a lot of time and don't get help from DH in training and such, I don't see how you could possibly keep this dog.

    Perhaps a home where she can get intensive training will be better for everyone. I know it's a tough decision and I don't envy you for having to make it. Good luck.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm assuming you've done research on the problem, but here is one quote I found on a Shih Tzu site... *** Note: Coprophagia (the eating of feces) is not particular to the Shih Tzu but it is noted that many of the breed are inclined to it. If you intend to have a Shih Tzu as a companion, discuss with the breeder or rescue the best ways to deal with this behavior and prepare yourself accordingly. It is not fair for this issue to become one that would potentially threaten the security of your dog in their home. Rehoming a Shih Tzu over this behavior is not necessary nor should it be realistically considered. Management (keeping droppings picked up) can serve to prevent the question at all.***

    From what little I've read on the subject, prevention and lots of exercise is the key to controlling the problem. One site also recommended crating and when out of the crate, muzzling.

    So........before giving up on her you may try keeping diapers out of her reach, try walking her (without the other dogs) a couple times a day, and find a muzzle for Shih Tzu's that doesn't interfere with her breathing.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    meghane- we tried crating her for about 2 weeks but she barked and screamed the entire time she was crated. We started out with small increments of time and tried increasing it but it did not help. We have a townhome and our neighbors told us they can hear her just fine. Not only did the crating not work, the barking made it worse for us and the neighbors. We are consistent with commands with her, she only knows to sit. I consulted several trainers and the cost was going to be around $400 which is not feasible for us at this point. The thing is we have tried so much and put forth so much effort but is just seems useless. It might be better for a day or two and then she goes right back at it. Thank you so much for your advice
    and help.

    Annz-I have researched the issue and I work for a vet so I have tapped out all resources. I have to disagree with the website, I also own another shih tzu and she would eat her own poo but I broke her of it. It is also rather difficult to manage her from eating it. As soon as she poos she snatches it up. I would literally have to stay right on her all day long waiting with paper towels and that is not an option. You can read my above response regarding the crating I totally disagree with the muzzling. For one it is very difficult to get muzzle that will fit let alone let them breathe properly. I don't think it is fair for her spend her life crated or wearing a muzzle. I think she deserves a better home but the question is will she be able to make the next home better?
    We tried diapering her it works but if she poos in it she manages to get it off and eat it, DD diapers are put in ziploc baggies and in the trash, she digs them out, she is walked 6 times a day by herself and she goes outside and inside, I have used forbid and meat tenderizer on her food to discourage her but it doesnt stop her.
    I have tried my best but I really feel like it is a wasted effort.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have no personal experience with this breed, however, it sounds to me like the dog could be suffering from some sort of separation anxiety, some sort of mental trauma, or, simply doesn't know her place in her "pack" yet.

    When I adopted my 4 month old Shepard/Hound in April of last year she was not house trained. I spent two months of hell trying to get the creature trained. I also consulted with trainers and did extensive research on the subject, with no luck. Finally, my vet asked about her history. I discovered that the dog was completely traumatized before I came along.

    My vet made a suggestion that was very simple and to the point. At this time, the dog would have been about 6-7 months old. She said that I needed to treat the dog like she was about 10 weeks.

    Since it sounds like you have a dog that is behaving like a puppy, perhaps you should start treating her like one.

    I also had crate training issues. Putting a sheet over the crate, tapping on it when she cries, and gently saying "STOP" fixed that. The STOP command is very easy for the dog to understand and you can use it when you need to stop the dog from doing something.

    Taking the dog outside the instant it comes out of the crate was also useful for me. Then taking the dog out about every 15-20 minutes and gradually extending that time also helped.

    I also made a rule that the dog had to be supervised every second when not crated. A leash on the dog was also used when she wasn't crated.

    I discovered that house training is one of the major reasons people give up their pets. I realize that all of this must be a horrible strain on your family.

    There are numerous rescue leagues out there that would be able to take the dog if you are starting to reach the breaking point.

    Good luck!

    Keep us posted!

    SG

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You do have the option of giving the dog to someone else, but the dog will have the same problems and it will be in the same situation. I think muzzling a dog or crating it is backwards thinking. The dog should be getting out more and getting more stimulation not less. Thinking that a dog walking itself 6 times a day is productive is a common mistake. That pup should be getting at least 3 human on the leash walks a day, first one 45 minutes, second one half an hour and thrid one half an hour - minimum. These walks are very important. First you are establishing leadership, second the dog is getting a good walk, take it for a walk with your daughter in the stroller. These walks should be walks with a purpose. Not just stopping at every bush to sniff, pee and poo. Your dog is not getting enough stimulation and is suffering from the FISHBOWL SYNDROME, same place, same smells everyday. YOu should see a dramatic difference in this dog within the the first week just by walking it on the leash.
    Next, go get yourself a small travel sized tube of toothpaste and a miniature bottle of tobasco sauce. Keep the toothpaste in your pocket, when you catch the dog eating ANYTHING it isnt suppose to, A deep loud sharp NO, and a dab of toothpaste no bigger than your fingernail on the tongue (if the dog likes the toothpaste, some do, switch to the tobasco sauce) *NOTE - for those of you worried about a dog swallowing the toothpaste because of the label warning dont swallow toothpaste, this is not enough product to hurt the dog at all. Better to train it with toothpaste than have it sick or poisoned because it ate something it shouldnt. Do this a couple of times combined with the walks and I guarantee things will be different.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Boy, talking to the previous owner would be absolutely fascinating!! Can't imagine that she would have been able to put up with this for 3 years!!!

    Thanks for your post - don't have any advice really but I have an American Bulldog that used to (and maybe still does) eat his own poo. It's horrible to see it but it's a human horror.

    My dog problems seem so pleasant now. Thanks again!!

    vicky

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Mazer- Thanks so much! I will have to try the tobasco sauce. I brush her teeth with vanilla mint doggie paste everytime she eats poo and then she gets a bath. Needless to say she loves toothpaste and getting a bath. The walks will be a different change for her, we normally take her out and she does her business and we bring her back in. I really hope this works. I would rather her be sick from toothpaste or tobasco sauce than from the poo she eats.

    I have kept in contact with the previous owner. She came from a family with 3 kids that are in every program imaginable and nobody was home with Lucy. So Lucy was put in a crate for the majority of a 24 hour day. No wonder she screams when she goes in the crate. She had potty issues with the other owner but with a maid to clean the home that was not a major concern. I also know the mother of the other owner and she confided that this is a regular pattern of her daughter.
    I'm going to try the walks and tobasco sauce and see if that helps! Any more suggestions I would be glad to take them into consideration :)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I believe dogs have an instinct to keep their immediate area clean. Dogs that are kept for too long in enclosed areas may develop a habit of eating their poop, absurdly enough, to clean it up! When you see her eating the poop and scream, she may be linking your behaviour with the poop and not the eating. So the next time she poops, she figures I better get rid of this right away, or my human will be unhappy. You catch the dog and scream, and thus the cycle begins again. Puppy mill dogs may have learned to eat poop from their mother, who ate THEIR poop to keep their area cleaner.

    It might have a mineral deficiency and need different food (these dogs will usually also eat other non-food items like dirt or carpet fibers). The dog that pooped might be passing a lot of unabsorbed contents of their own food that makes the feces smell attractive to your dog. She may think she is simply eating dog food somebody left out for her. When you come screaming, she thinks "that woman wants this tasty food, I better eat it right quick before she gets it!".

    Sometimes dogs that do this are bored. My brothers dog will play hockey with frozen poops so my brother will chase her around the yard in the winter (when the birds are all gone and the squirrels are sleeping, she has nobody to play with). The dog starts to play, owner sees it and freaks out, trying to take it away. Dog is in his joy, being chased and having a fun game.

    Whatever the cause, there is a common theme here. We may not have caused the problem in the first place, but our reaction to it makes them do the exact opposite of what we intended.

    My grandparent's shi had the same issue. Impossible to housebreak, poop eater. They were going to have to give it up, as they were "snow birds" and couldn't see asking somebody to take on this kind of dog, even for a short visit. Since I work from home I offered to take the dog and see what I could do. Based on that, this is my suggestion:

    On the training end, literally taking the dog out every 20 minutes. If it did anything, instant incredible praise (your neighbours should think the dog just unearthed a golden nugget for you) and instant treat. If there are any messes in the house, they are quickly and quietly cleaned while ignoring the dog completely. Do not look at the dog, do not scold, nothing. And no attention at all for at least 5 minutes.

    In the house keep the dog leashed to you at all times. If it tries to wander away it probably has to go outside. After eating and drinking, after playing, upon waking from even a nap. Watch for the dog looking around, sniffing, walking in a sort of figure eight pattern. All signs the dog has to go.

    Every day with no accidents in the house, increase the time interval a bit (like, to every 30 minutes). Don't forget, go out with the dog and the second it squats, it is the BEST DOG YOU HAVE EVER MET. Dancing, singing it's praises, and don't forget that treat. Ignore any accidents, and go back down to 20 minutes.

    As for the poop eating. Ignore it until she is doing better with the training (going OUTSIDE instead of inside). No kisses, then ;). Keep the yard as clean of poop as possible, clean all accidents as quickly but as quietly and low key as possible (you don't want the dog to think it is a race for food). Crate the dog only when you are going out, and go out for as few hours as possible.

    Send a fruit basket to the neighbours.

    The second you come home, CARRY the dog outside. When it does it's business, be fricken JUBILANT and don't forget that treat. The crate is not to be used for punishment or time out, or for when you are tired of watching the dog. The crate is for when you go out, and for over night. The dog goes into the crate when you go to bed, and is taken out immediately when you get up (outside, pee/poop, happy dance and treat, leash and back in). Their dog wasn't ready to go the whole night yet, so twice a night I got up. If there was no accident in the crate, brought the dog out. If there was I cleaned up the mess and brought the dog out. No lights, no talking (except for jubilation if it peed or pooped outside). I gradually phased to once a night, then she could go eight hours. Now she can go from about 10pm to almost noon, I am told LOL.

    Send the neighbour a nice floral bouquet.

    If you want you can add to the above, the second the dog squats to pee outside you say "go pee". The second it squats to poop, say "go poop". Using that technique I can take my dog out, snap my fingers and point to the lawn and say "go pee" or "go poop" and she will. Pretty handy when you have to leave for a long drive, before going the vet, and so on She wasn't a poop eater, but pugs can be notoriously hard to house train and that method worked for her.

    If your dog is not excited over treats (and many shi's aren't) perhaps you know of a toy that she LOVES to play with, and trade a few moments of playing instead of a food treat.

    If you can't take that kind of time (by the way, it took three months and she still occassionally samples - but is fully housebroken) and it is causing disharmony in the family, please don't feel bad about giving the dog up. You did what you could, and gave it a good home as long as you could.


    If a trip outside yields nothing, quickly and quietly bring the dog inside. No talking, no scolding, no praise either.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Our beagle was a bit of a poop eater. She still has a taste every now and then, but usually only when we forget her outside for a little longer than she would prefer.

    Im asumming since you have a young child, you have babygates around, right?? Have you tried placing one to the entrance of the room you spend the most time in? We did that because our beagle would sneak off oh so quietly and then go bury her face in the cat box and eat to her little hearts content. When we're in the living room, she's in there, and she's not getting out. When we're out of the living room, she stays in there or we keep calling her name anytime she tries to take off.

    Is your dog consistent with a 'come' command, or coming when her name is called?? Its a bit of a pain in the butt, but when you cant keep watch on her, anytime you notice she leaves the room, call her back. Don't let her leave your side or the room. This way you may be able to keep her away from DD's diapers, and any accidents the other dogs have had.

    Try keeping DD's dirty diapers in an airtight storage bin, until you are ready to toss them out in the back. Line it with a garbage bag, and close it. OR find somewhere to keep the garbage where lucy can't get to it. Under the sink, in the garage (if you have one). OR keep a garbage can outside to toss diapers in. Don't give her the chance to get at them. I know thats a little unrealistic for middle of the night diaper changes, but you could keep a small container up in DD's room for those changes. Even keep a small bathroom sized garbage can in a few rooms, under counters, or ON counters to keep dd's diapers in. Something makes me think that the inside of diapers is really unsafe to be eating.

    Keep her on a leash when youre wandering around the house and not in one room for any amount of time. This way you can notice the squat, pull her away quick, and toss her outside. Even if you dont manage to get her out of the house before she poops, you can atleast keep her away from the poop.

    Try really hard to teach her a 'leave it' command. This works especially well if she is on the leash. Teach it to her with EVERYTHING you don't want to touch. Give her a tiny yank and say 'leave it' when she eventually gets it, anytime she goes anywhere near poop or DD's diaper, tell her to 'leave it.' Don't yell, or scold. Just a short, firm command. This has worked REALLY well with our dogs. We can now throw a hand full of cookies down on the floor, and tell them to leave it, and they won't go near them. They'll sniff and drool. But until we say 'ok' they won't go after them.

    I have a feeling, like has been said before, she used to get scolded whenever she had an accident. Now its habit for her to eat anything resembling poo or even vomit. She's scared of leaving it there, or she'll get in trouble. So don't scold her when she has an accident, don't yell when she eats it. Pull her away, even if she gets a mouthful, put her in whichever room has the gate (if you choose to do this) or outside of that room, while you clean it and go about your business like nothing happened.

    My dog didnt eat poo because she was scared of it. My dog ate it because she'll eat ANYTHING. toothpaste and tobasco had no affect on her. She absolutely LOVES tobasco sauce. She loves just about anything. Even rye and coke!! We had people over once, and I set my drink down beside me on the floor to pull out some appetizers or something, turn around and shes taking small licks, making a face and doing it again. So dont be discouraged if the toothpaste/tobasco doesn't work. Not all dogs are easily phased by bad tastes. My dog even loves the anti chewing spray they make. We tried spraying it on her bed once to deter her from chewing, and she licked it all off like it was the best thing she'd ever tasted. :/

    Its a bit time consuming to keep her on a leash at all times when you're home, but I really don't think it'll take that long. A week or two before she starts to atleast understand the commands, and then after that its just a matter of keeping an eye on her, and reminding her when she forgets.

    If none of this works, don't feel bad about giving the dog away. But do make sure you tell people what they're getting into, because you don't want to find out she's being bounced around, or euthanized.

    Best you can do if you don't want her getting into poop, is to do everything you can to keep it away.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    So Lucy has been on two lovely walks today and she really enjoyed them. Me not so much. I took her to work today to groom her (may have found her a home!) and she thanked me by only eating a half pile of poo when we got home. She managed to sneak off when I took DD upstairs for a nap. So when I came down to find a half pile she was there at the crime scene. I got paper towels and cleaner and cleaned all of it up but one nugget. I put tobasco sauce on the lone nugget and quietly walked out without even speaking to her. I let her go back to see how she would react to the spice, well she came tearing through the house barking and kicking up her back legs. I thought that did the trick, no she immediately went back to the spot pooped again and went to sniffing in what I assume a quest for the spicy nuggets. The dagblasted dog likes freakin Tobasco sauce, toothpaste, meat tenderizer, forbid, and poo!

    I do not use baby gates at home our layout on the 1st floor is pretty open and they don't fit except on the kitchen. Our stairwell is awkward and we can't get one to fit there either. Trust me I tried gating her at the kitchen but she climbed over, I put two up and she scaled both of them. She does well with staying near us but when we get busy it is hard for us to keep an eye at all times on her and that is our fault. So I tried leashing her to me, that will not happen again. We almost encountered a serious injury. I started walking she managed to dodge between my feet, I managed to not squash her on the way down. We use "leave it" with our rottie and it works, never worked with the shih tzus. I've been checking out some food tips such as cooking carrots, broccoli, or cabbage and adding it to the food. So i'm going to give it a whirl.
    So about finding her a home, we have a tech that works part time and she stopped by today and saw Lucy and fell in love with her. Her in-laws had a 16yr old shih tzu that passed away and they have been wanting another one. I told her about the bad habit and she said they could work on that and we are all supposed to get in touch and see where it goes. I would feel really good about her going to their home, they have no other pets, no small children, and the wife is at home all day to spend time with her. I know she would be well cared for and loved so maybe this will all work out. In the mean time it's off to make veggies for Lucy and head out for a walk. Any ideas? Keep them coming! Thanks for your help :)

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!