Software
Houzz Logo Print
gardenut213

sad and regretful (warning, LONG post)

19 years ago

Hello Everyone:

I have posted here a few times with questions and concerns about our family dog, Belle. She was a rescue whom we adopted on September 3rd. You all helped me with my housesbreaking concerns, and that situation resolved itself well. But my other concerns were with some incidents of aggression directed towards my husband and children. They originally occurred when she was laying down on the couch next to me, and someone would approach or walk by me and she would, at first growl. Then it progressed to showing of teeth, then snapping (at air). We took steps each time, with a verbal "NO", making her get off the couch, ordering her into a down position, etc. After consulting with our vet, trainer, and you helpful folks, we decided as a family to stop allowing her up on the furniture next to us. We followed the "NILIF" philosophy and in addition, added extra time to her walks, spent extra time in teaching her new commands, and she was taken to the dog park once a week for some running and fun with the other dogs.

There was some improvement, but after a few weeks with no changes to the above routine, it has started up again. She bit me last week when I attempted to pull a piece of tape off her paw, (hard enough to break skin.) I was shocked, and she actually seemed surprised as well, immediately licked my face, wagging her tail, etc. I corrected her, put her in the crate for 15 minutes and walked away. Last night, she was lying on the floor next to the chair I was sitting in and when my husband walked in to say goodnight, she stood up, with hackles raised and growled, showing teeth. He yelled NO, SIT! She did comply, but he and I both discussed the possibility that the aggression was showing itself again.

Then this morning, the last straw. We were in the kitchen, eating breakfast. Belle ran into the kitchen, jumped up with front paws on the table and tried to grab my daughters plate. My daughter said NO, BELLE, DOWN; she reached up to take ahold of her collar and Belle just snarled and bit her hard on the thumb. My daughter (to her credit) remained calm and told Belle to go to her crate, (which Belle did after I stood up and walked towards her). There are 3 puntures, not deep but they did draw blood. We washed it well with soap and water, and some antibiotic ointment. The school called later and I had to go pick her up. The thumb has become very swollen. (She will see the doctor later this morning).

My daughter is heartbroken that this will cause us to return Belle. I am upset as well, but I feel we have done all we can. The shelter was very understanding when I spoke with them in early December, as it is part of our adoption agreement that the dog be returned if we cannot keep her for any reason. Belle was only there for a short time, they do not know much of her background. I feel so much that we failed her, but I honestly do not know what else to do. She has been checked out by the vet, tests run, etc. She is healthy and happy, but it is the sudden unexpected aggression we just feel we can't cope with. To top it all off, my mother-in-law (87 years old) will be staying with us for a while, maybe up to 6 weeks while she recovers from pnuemonia. There will also be stranges coming in and out every day, so I worry that Belle will react badly to that as well.

I guess I just wanted to vent a little. Belle is such a fun dog in so many ways, and she loves us. It is breaking my heart to think of her back in the shelter, wondering where we are and what happened to us! God, it is killing my daughter and I. (My son and husband are the stoics)

Can you folks think of anything we may have done or overlooked? I want to be as sure as I can be that we didn't cause this somehow...

We will discuss what's to be done tonight as a family. But in my heart, I know that she cannot stay any longer. It's just a sad situation, all around!

Comments (10)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I really doubt you've caused this at all. It sounds like you've done nothing but love and care for this animal.

    I'd just like to ask one question, Is she food agressive with her own food?? You mentioned she nipped when your daughter was eating and she tried to take her food. Has there been food around her everytime she's bitten or snarled??

    If thats the case, Im pretty sure there are ways to break that. Im not sure what they are though. Its possible she had food taken away from her, or wasn't feed consistently or had to fight for it when she was younger.

    I'm really sorry this dog is causing so much greif and posing a danger to your family. But if you can find a common link between every incidence, you might be able to solve your problem!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm sorry to hear this, and I feel for you. I think that Belle was not properly tested at the shelter, so that her aggression could have been revealed there. This poor dog should never have been placed. The shelter should not place her with any other family. They could place her with a person who has experience and success keeping aggressive dogs. But if such a situation can't be found, Belle should not go to another family's home.

    Don't feel bad, you did what you could, but you need to protect your family first and foremost. Hugs to you and your little girl, and to Belle.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Your first obligation is the safety of your family. It sounds like the aggression is not only food-related situations. From your post it sounds as if the aggression is not something that only occurs infrequently. It doesn't really matter why Belle is exhibiting this behavior, what matters is what you do about it. Scolding her and sending her to her crate is not going to stop the behavior. Life is hard and you have to do what is best for everyone. Perhaps Belle would be better off with an owner who lives alone.

    I have an old gal who has "bitten" two children at my home. She bit the first at about age 6 when she began having problems with pain from hip dysplasia. These two incidents were precipitated by the kids teasing my old gal (still not acceptable). Old gal has never broken the skin on a person, she just gives a warning bite when she's had enough. She has never shown agression toward myself, DH or my daughter. If she had shown any aggression to my daughter, she would have been rehomed. I would not put up with that worry of not knowing if and when she would bite again.

    My gal has been with me since she was 3 months old and was rescued by me from an abusive home 12 yrs. ago. We have made every accommodation so as not to put any child at risk. We have locked old gal up when children were visiting, etc. The last incident was about 5 yrs ago. We had a family over for a bbq and swimming in the pool. Old gal knows that when there is company at the pool, she won't be swimming. All 3 dogs were in the yard, occasionally running up and down the fence line while we were in the pool. My friend's son kept putting his arm through the fence gate teasing with old gal. She just gave a bite on the top of his arm. No skin broken, but I was very concerned about the child and my old gal. I feel the parents weren't watching the child, but on the other hand, I should have been in control of my dog. She has never since been in a room with a child unaccompanied. This particular child had a small bruise on his upper arm. I felt as did the child's parents that if my old gal really wanted to, she could have torn the child's arm off before we could be up out of a chair and to the situation. She gave a warning bite and let go. (still not a great scenario)

    My nephew and neice 9 and 6 have been around old gal since they were babies and they know not to sit on her or tease her. There have never been any incidents with them. It seemed to be a stranger thing. Kids who were not common to our house.

    I did have our trainer come over and work with old gal after the last incident. This was about 5 yrs ago we started working with her again. We went back to her initial training and started reinforcing her with the common commands, sit, stay, come, etc. The trainer did comment that old gal was picking up on my anxiety about the children visiting and I needed to change some of my behavior when people visited with children.

    I haven't had anymore incidents, but I will say that the kids are older now that come to the house.

    There seems to be a problem with a certain size/age children with dogs that bite. They feel threated for some reason. A pack thing apparently as explained by the vet.

    I don't know how old your daughter is, or your dog (what breed), but I don't think I would keep Belle. You were very lucky that she didn't bite your daughter's face. She may not, but then again, there are no guarantees with a dog that bites. The aggression shown by Belle is directed at your husband and child (living in the house full time). I just wouldn't take the chance.

    I knew my old gal hadn't shown any aggression toward any of us and has never made any signs of aggression toward any extended family member.

    I guess what I am saying is - do you want to worry about your daughter's well being constantly? You also have to worry about anytime she may have a friend visit. It is a difficult situation to deal with. If you cannot make it 100 percent safe for your daughter and any other person visiting your home, you need to seriously think about finding a new home for Belle.

    Have you spoken to a professional about this behavior? There are alot of behavior specialists who you could consult for answers to what is best.

    I wish you the best of luck. I haven't been exactly where you have been since old gal hasn't ever been aggressive with DD, but I have experienced another parent's anxiety when old gal did her warning bite. Not good.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    What you are dealing with is dominance aggression. This can be worked on but it takes extra concerns. Below is a link to a free
    service done by dog trainers in which you can call them and get some counseling.
    Also another good person to get some advice from free is Stever Rafe @
    http://www.starfire-rapport.com/s_index_body.html
    Just type your concerns and he will get back to you.
    This isn't going to be easy, you will have to set limits for the dog including where it can go in the house etc.
    I feel for you, I know this is hard as all heck. Best of luck in whatever you decide.

    Here is a link that might be useful: training link

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    No more letting Belle up on the couch. Your dog has not gotten the message that you all are in charge and it is not. First congrats to your daughter for standing her ground - she did a great job, and in fact she let the dog know she is not afraid and wont take the dogs attitude, BRAVO!!! Now lets get your daughter to walk Belle on the leash, have her do some commands. Sit Stay and Down, Drop it, leave it - these will all help your dog turn around.
    As for visitors, first line of defense, everyone who enters your house ignors the dog, NO EYE CONTACT, NO PETTING, NO TALKING TO IT - The dog does not exist. Next, the dog stays off the couch, and I think increasing the leash walking times is paramount, especially just before company comes. Your dog CAN overcome these problems. NOTE - I think you made a bit of a mistake in correcting the dog after it tried to apologize to you after nipping you. You need to act IMMEDIATELY with this dog, or it is too late, you in fact corrected the dog for licking you in the dogs mind....

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Question - Do you have any qualms about putting a muzzle on Belle while company is ther? Do you have any qualms about putting a halti on your dog? Do you happen to live in Northern California???
    I dont think you have to pick between keeping the dog or getting bit. I think the communications between you and your dog could withstand some improvement without anyone else getting bit.
    I really would like to help you though this, if you feel you just can not deal with it, then contact a positive reinforcement trainer. Man I wish you lived near me...

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you everyone for your thoughts. I did speak at length with the shelter earlier this morning. We have decided to return Belle. The shelter agreed that our family might not be the best environment for her. It is possible, (and we had not thought of this) that there is just too much commotion in a house with 4 active people, (2 being teenagers with all the noise, friends, etc. that goes along with all that...) Belle's previous owner was elderly and lived a very quiet existence at home; so perhaps she finds it hard to deal with? Nontheless, it was a very long, sad evening at our house.

    My son did inform me privately this morning that Belle had bitten a friend of his on the back of the calf on Thanksgiving night. It didn't break the skin, his friend thought it was no big deal, so he told my son not to say anything.

    This makes me even more sure of my decision. Thank you all for your help. We may someday adopt another dog, but for right now I just need some time to miss her. We will be spending the weekend with her, just to make some final happy memories. I appreciate all your concern, and did think about all your suggestions. Thank you very much.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm sorry gardenut! It sounds you did whats best for you and belle. If she's used to a quiet existence and minimal noise, its probably best for both your family and belle. Perhaps she's even just to loyal (and was maybe super babied!) to be around a ton of people and not get possesive/agressive of things she was free to do before. She was not a good fit for you. Did the shelter say whether they will try to place her again??

    I hope if you do decide to get another pet down the road, that it goes smoother for you and you don't have to give it up!!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We had a similar situation in which I adopted a dog from a shelter that turned out to be a biter. It's sort of a long story, so I'll shorten it to mention we had a trainer out to help us with her, and tried doing what she taught us to do, but when she snapped at one of our children's playmates for no good reason - the boy was just very quietly petting her, not harming her in the least, we came to the quick decision to get rid of her. We were not working with as understanding of a shelter as you did, though. When I called them, they refused to take her back because they said it's their policy not to take in or adopt out dogs that bite. I pointed out to them that they adopted her out to me. They stood their ground, and pretended that I hadn't even pointed that little irony out to them. Anyway, we were lucky, and the Humane Society took her in for us. It was a hard decision, but I absolutely will not tolerate a dog that bites, especially one that bites children.

    Sally

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If someone else has her by now.........you may want to mention to them to have her thyroid levels checked. I was reading an article at the Humane Society the other day and it said biters should be checked for thyroid problems in addition to a complete physical.