Software
Houzz Logo Print
junkjon

Water Treatment Help!

20 years ago

Hi all, we have well water that has been tested twice in the last 5 months. Perfectly safe but acidic (pH 5.7 and 6.0 - results for 2 times tested) tested high for manganese once and high for sodium the other time. Softness is good - 28 and 36 mg/l.

I've heard of several ways to treat this.

1. acid neutralizer and then a softener (neutralizer incr hardness softener deals with manganese, iron etc.)

2. acid neutralizer and aeration

3. chemical injection for acidity and chlorinate/dechlorinate w/filters for metals..also kills any bacteria though none are currently present

what is interesting is the co. that recommedned the chlo/dechlor specifically said don't use a neutralizer and softener, the pH is too low and it wouldn't work and the water is already soft. They seemed to be the most knowledgeable.

Curious on thoughts, pros/cons...I'm VERY confused!

Thanks!

Comments (3)

  • 20 years ago

    First...I'm no pro, but here's my story on this. When I discovered that my well water was a PH of 5, I added a neutralizer. Ground Calcite+corosex in a tank moved the PH to 10, so now I just use the ground calcite and get 7. My water is still soft I believe, I mean soap easily works and suds. The "Fleck" machine on the tank automatically backwashes into a drywell (or other) every 4 days to prevent minerals hardening in the tank. Clean out the tank once or twice a year, replace the rocks for $20 and it seems everything is working. I'd love to hear more on this topic as well. PS the tank and backwasher were under 500$ if I remember. Final note: that water that sits in the tank a while will be most "neutralized." You can see this by testing the pH at different times during high or low water use.

  • 20 years ago

    That's actually more like $50 per bag of calcite now.

  • 20 years ago

    Your hardness is about 2 grains per gallon, so you will have fairly good lather when you soap up. Adding a acid nuetralizer (AN) using calcite (crushed limestone/marble) will raise your hardness slightly 1-2 gpg per point on the pH scale. Often a softener is placed after an AN to counteract the reasults of raising the pH in this manner.

    The company who said your pH is too low to treat, is not making a sense. Too low would be something on the scale of less than 4.0 and containing a mixture of mineral acids in combination of high dissolved cabon dioxide. But that is rare.

    What would be the purpose of an aeration system? Iron or odor removal?

    Get water tested by microbiotics, specifically pathogens. If none present, then not to worry about equipment. If you want reassurances, use an ultraviolet light system. No chemicals to add, no chemicals to remove, no filters to backwash, no media to replace, no wasting water, easy to monitor and repair and it works!