I think it's totally a personal choice. I think you can definitely mix glass knobs with cup pulls -- a very classic or vintage look. Since your island and perimeter cabs are different finishes, I don't see why the hardware could not also be different, but you might want to try a mock up with samples to make sure everything meshes and doesn't look too busy. As for larger pulls on larger drawers, you can do that. However, with cup pulls, my preference is to put two pulls on a longer drawer in a two door cabinet, and center each pull above each door, kwim? If there is only one drawer below, then only one pull on the drawer. I like the look. Some people don't like this because they feel they need to use two hands to open the longer drawer. However, if your glides or good, you shouldn't have to.

Sounds neat!

I love thinking outside the box!

Would also like to see pics.

Hi,

My KD said there is no hard and fast rule regarding knobs and pulls. She said it is totally up to your individual taste where to use knobs or pulls. The person installing my cabinets agreed.

Sounds like you have some great suggestions. I'd do whatever you think looks best in your kitchen.

Karen