Software
Houzz Logo Print
bevangel_i_h8_h0uzz

Need advice re porch posts (x-posted)

Cross-posting this on the building forum as well but figure some of you here may not lurk there and might have good info for me...

Has anyone used Certainteed's aluminum reinforced vinyl porch posts? I'm looking for something that has the look of traditional turned wood but that is low maintenance and I need a fairly high load-bearing capacity. Here is the link to their brochure:

http://www.certainteed.com/NR/rdonlyres/BE403CAD-5DE3-41DE-8FE3-4F1EBE44423C/0/FRD_1889_001_105.pdf

If you have experience with this product, can you tell me 1) How "plasticy" does the vinyl look/feel? 2) Does it stay nicely white or begin to yellow fairly quickly?

I can order these but no one in my area seems to carry Certainteed products so it is hard to get a first hand look at them.

Also, if you know of a competing product you would recommend, please chime in.

It would be great if someone made something like a steel reinforced fiber-cement column that was made to LOOK like turned wood and could be painted whatever color you wanted and then would hold the paint like hardiboard does but, so far at least, I've not found anything like that in my internet searching!

Comments (2)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Take a look at HB&G

    The Porch Guy

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My wife and I added a front porch to our house 3 years ago, and our contractor installed white vinyl structural posts, newels, and railings. These have now gone through 3 winters and 2-1/2 summers here in Southwestern Pennsylvania, which means they have seen wintertime temperatures in the single digits and summertime temperatures in the 90s (like the past three days). I'll try and respond to your specific questions:

    1. Our contractor used his preferred supplier's vinyl posts and railings, which I do not believe are made by Certainteed - although I have a hunch most manufacturers will have similar characteristics. Although, it appears from the literature he gave us that our structural posts are rated higher than the Certainteed ones.

    2. I'll answer the whiteness issue first. Ours have shown no sign of yellowing. They look like new three years after installation - including those parts that get a significant amount of summer sun (at least 6 hours).

    3. The "plasticy" question is most likely in the eye of the beholder. Like I said, our posts look like new, so they look like they have been freshly painted. From a distance (in our case, our porch is within 50 feet of the public road), the posts and railings look like wood. Quite honestly, they feel solid like wood to me when you put your hand on them or try to squeeze them (I've had friends do that, when they find out they are vinyl. I think they believe plastic will give - but it doesn't on ours.). Now if you wet your finger and rub it on the post, then yes, it will probably sound like plastic - but I've not tried that. I'll admit this is the most subjective issue in deciding between wood and plastic building material. I think you really need to see the finished project in order to evaluate it - and by then you are already committed. By the way, my wife and I and our family love the front porch - and the vinyl posts and railings.

    4. Yes, our posts, newels, and railings look like traditional turned wood.

    Now, a couple of other points:

    1. I recommend getting the 6 inch porch posts. The 4 or 5 inch posts simply look too narrow to me. If this is for a front porch, you really want the look of the 6 inch posts.

    2. It sounds like you are doing this project yourself. If so, I recommend you go the the Vintage Woodworks web site - do a search on the web to get their web address. The are located in Texas, but ship all over the U.S. They specialize in porch posts, newels, railings, and the decorative "gingerbread" items for porches. If this is a new project you are planning, I would order their book titled "Porch Design". It is excellent and we used it to help our contractor design our porch.

    3. The Porch Guy recommended HB&G porch posts, which are made of polyurethane and can be painted. I looked at their products for our porch, so I still have their web page bookmarked. Vintage Woodworks now carries polyurethane structural porch posts that can be painted. They did not have these 3 years ago when we did our porch.

    4. Since you are looking for porch posts to be painted, check out the wood posts at Vintage Woodworks. They make them out cedar or hemlock, and we almost ordered these for our contractor to use.