Would you post two separate photos, one each of the different countertops with the tile?

I think the tile will "pop" more with the white countertop. It seems like it will be a more subtle look with the grey countertop. What look are you going for?

Definitely the whiter one for me.

White

The gray or one shade lighter in gray is preferable. There is a lot of white going on-the grayish or a darker smokey white works. Either one you pick will actually work as they are neutral and ..[ceiling is unique and the strongest feature anyway]

Quelyn, It looks beautiful!! I can't wait to see the finished product! I love your ceiling!

I vote pebble. It add some nice contrast without being heavy. I included a couple pictures from houzz with pebble counters.

[contemporary kitchen design[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/contemporary-kitchen-ideas-phbr1-bp~t_709~s_2103) by toronto interior designer Jessie Kelly

[traditional bathroom design[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/traditional-bathroom-ideas-phbr1-bp~t_712~s_2107) by Caesarstone

looking good!! The pebble is really standing out to me. i really like it. You really can't go wrong with the misty. beautiful tile.

I prefer the gray.

I'm a misty carrera girl. Must vote for the lighter one.
Love your Paris nights.
~boxer

Paris Nights...ooh, la, la! I vote for the white...let that tile be the star!

Definitely white for me. Someone doesn't buy a tile like that for it to blend in, and the white will make it pop!

love the gray one. it would be very sophisticated.

I vote for the white!

I do like the grey and navy, but maybe not so close together. If you were doing grey lower cabs, I think that'd look great with white counter/navy backsplash. But I like the white counter against the navy tiles, even with white cabs. Happy renovating!

White. BTW-I love the blue tile. I definitely say white!

Love the white!!! Tiles are going to look absolutely amazing. Congratulations!