Software
Houzz Logo Print
rjexit5

30 or 15 year fixed?

12 years ago

My wife and I are shopping for a new home and want to move by this summer. Our biggest question is a 30 year fixed loan or a 15 year fixed loan. The 15 year is obviously much cheaper over the long run BUT the 30 has a much more manageable payment each month. Has anyone considered getting the 30 but paying it off in 15 with the ability to fall back to the 30 year payment if finances require it? The rate on the 30 is a bit higher than 15 so doing this would cost an extra 40k in interest over the life of the loan. Is 40k worth the comfort of knowing we can switch back to the lower payment each month?

Comments (17)

  • 12 years ago

    That's the way we did it. We took out the 30 year for the more manageable monthly payment. In case our finances took a nosedive or in case something would happen that would be a big drain on our finances, we didn't want to also have to move/lose our home because the monthly payment was too high. Then, we diligently worked to pay down the mortgage as though it was a 15 year to avoid the extra interest. As it turns out, we paid it off in 10! :)

  • 12 years ago

    This was the same reason we went for the 30 year fixed. In our situation, the house also needed work done (roof, windows, appliances, water heater and cosmetic interior immediately, with 2.5 bathrooms and a kitchen remodel yet to go.) We hoped to be able to complete them, and then pay off the balance of the loan ahead of schedule. But our financial situation has changed less than four years into the loan; the 30 year fixed's payment is still easily met. The 15 year's payments could have become a big source of stress. The interest rates for both fixed mortgages are still quite low historically.

  • 12 years ago

    We did the same thing too. And in our case it turned out to be a wise decision twice. We wanted to make sure we could easily pay it on just one income and even if that single income was reduced. Both of us have been without a job for a short time, although mine was with a lot of severance and I got a new job before loosing my pay, but when we just had one income it was nice as the unemployment check wouldn't have covered the difference in the monthly payment and it would have been much tighter. We are now back to paying a higher monthly payment than the 15 year would have been, although it has set us back a few years. It was worth it to us not having to worry about moving and selling which is also a large expense.

    This post was edited by lyfia on Wed, Jan 8, 14 at 18:04

  • 12 years ago

    The advantage of the 15-year is that you will get a better interest rate, which will make a difference in what you pay, even if you pay off the 30-year in 15 years. Nevertheless, we also chose to go the 30-year route for the peace of mind knowing that we could probably manage the mortgage payments even through some difficult financial times. We will have it paid off in one more year, so that we ended up paying it off in 20 years---not as good as 15 years, but we're happy and appreciated the flexibility the lower monthly payments gave us.

  • 12 years ago

    We went with the 15-year mortgage but we were even more conservative than previous posters. Being extremely risk-averse, like the previous posters, we also wanted to be In a position where we could still afford the mortgage if one of us lost our job. So we chose a house that we could afford on one salary, but at a 15 year mortgage.

    The 15 year mortgage was important because the first of our kids would start college in 15 years and we wanted to have the flexibility to use a re-fi as a way to pay for college if we needed to.

  • 12 years ago

    The bank quoted us a home loan rate of 18.5% when shopping for our first home back in 1984. We ended up purchasing one with an assumable rate of 12.5% for a 20 year loan.

    Times have changed. I abhor debt and always opted for the shorter loan period and lessor interest rate on the three loans we've had.

    However, I understand wanting to be cautious about being able to maintain your house payments during down times. On the flip side, your finances may improve and paying the 15 year note, with additional principle will save you more in the long run.

    I guess some other considerations are how long you plan to stay in the house and what's the real estate market doing in your area? Up/down/stable?

  • 12 years ago

    Thanks everyone for all of the different perspectives. Keep them coming. jrb451...we plan to make this our forever house. One child now and we are planning for another. Real estate is quite low right now but rebounding as we speak. The home is also bank owned/foreclosure but doesn't need work in order to move in. We feel the home price will most likely be the lowest possible right now since many of the other homes in the area are starting to see higher listing prices.

  • 12 years ago

    Just curious, is this a "conventional" loan, one where you're putting down 20% or more?

    Good luck with your purchase, whichever way you go.

  • 12 years ago

    My original mortgage was 8.75% in 1999 and I got a 30 year, for the reasons listed above. Very glad I did as I am a single person and was laid off and had only part-time work for three years. Have since refinanced 3 times - 1 time was free. First two were 30 years but the last one is 15 yrs with a 3.75% rate. Since retirement is about 10 years away I want to get it paid off by then and am adding extra principal payments to make that happen. It is SO much fun to actually see the balance go down every month!

    The best advice I can give is to buy responsibly. Don't buy more house than you need. You never know what the future holds. If you win the lottery you can always build your mansion. If you have some bad times you will be able to stay put and be less-stressed.

  • 12 years ago

    Interesting question about the down payment. We have 20+% available but there is a cost for us to get to some of it (15% in savings; 5+% in investments); if the total cost of the PMI is less than the fee to get to the last 5% of the down payment then we will put 15 down; if the PMI cost more than the fee then we will be putting 20 down.

  • 12 years ago

    Sounds like you're on top of the situation. You'll make the right choice once you crunch the numbers.

    Good luck.

  • 12 years ago

    put down whatever you can, do the 30 year, ask for a waiver for if you pay it off early there is no penalty, and then do that. I like forever homes, they are rare these days. Good luck rjexit5.

  • 12 years ago

    With the interest rates still relatively cheap i chose a 30 year loan. Every month I will be putting extra money on the principal.

  • 12 years ago

    As I mentioned earlier, we chose to get the 30 year fixed and pay off early. We did buy a home that cost much less than the bank would have loaned and, thus, had a very manageable house payment each month. One other thing we did early-on was make two extra payments (considered regular payments, not principal only) so that at any given time we would be 2 months ahead on our payment. That way, if there was a job loss, incapacitating illness or injury, or even death of one of us, we would have a 2-month cushion to work with while we got our finances in order. Thankfully, we've never had to take advantage of that 2-month cushion, but it was worth it to me for my peace of mind---kind of like buying insurance, you hope you won't need it but glad you have it in case you do. After that, every extra dollar we paid was used to reduce principle on our mortgage. I don't know whether all mortgages allow you to pay a month or more in advance, but ours did and it was worth it to us---others might prefer to have used that money for extra principal only payments, but it worked well for our situation.

  • 12 years ago

    Thanks everyone for the very useful information. When I first posted my wife and I were leaning to the 15 year loan just because we hate debt. We have worked very hard in eliminating most debt. After considering all of the information provided it does make sense for us to go with the 30 year fixed rate loan and work toward paying it off early. (perhaps in 15). We might divert some of the extra payment to a few investments if they are earning better than our loan rate and mortgage interest tax deduction combined.

    We appreciate everyone who took the time to respond to our posts, the opinions and experiences did help our decision.

  • 12 years ago

    When Late Husband and I were house hunting, we chose one that could be paid for by either of us.
    LH worked for a bank at the time. Ironically, they didn't do mortgages, but he used their computer (it was 1985) to check out the results of 15 year vs. 30 year mortgages The 15 year was less than $100 more a month. That's what we went with.
    . Someone later told us it would have been smarter to go with the 30 year mortgage, and write a separate check each month to reduce the principle. LH and I were neither disciplined or organized enough to do that...it wouldn't have happened. It is a really good idea for someone that is, though.

    Even with the 15-year plan, we finished paying it off in 13.

  • 12 years ago

    In your consideration of down payment...

    Consider whether your investments are making more, as a percentage, than your mortgage interest rate as well.

    I have found that there is not much anywhere else you can borrow as inexpensively as for your primary home. If you have any other debt at all, you should focus first to pay that down before your house; because it will certainly be at a higher interest rate (exception might be college loans consolidated in the early 2000s). Similarly, if your investments are earning 5-10% or higher, consider you'll be giving up that percentage to be able to pay no PMI (so figure that as a percent) with a very low interest rate on the house. Does it make sense to take money from investments earning 7% to pay for a house with interest rate of only 3.5%? (probably not--unless you have a very high PMI percentage).