Software
Houzz Logo Print
carol_from_ny

If you don't like

16 years ago

scrappy quilts do you also not like crazy quilts or are they two totally different things in your mind?

Comments (11)

  • 16 years ago

    In my mind they are different: crazy quilts traditionally included lots of velvets, satin, brocade, silks, lace, etc. and were traditionally spread out on a piano or sofa to show off the hand embroidery. Also, they usually did not have any batting - just the top and a backing.

    You can make a scrap quilt with backing and batting done in a crazy quilt pattern, but I would call this a scrap quilt, not a crazy quilt.

  • 16 years ago

    I consider a crazy quilt a scrappy quilt. I have a big block from one with the date 1918 embroidered on one square. It's obvious that the fabrics were taken from men's clothing, coats, blankets, women's shirts. They were called crazy because there wasn't a rhyme or reason to matching the fabric. It's a Victorian touch to decorate them with embroidery and embellishments, but crazy quilts existed before Victorian times without all the garnishment. It was written in one quilting article I read that the fad started from seeing patched fabrics in Chinese clothing on exhibit at a World's fair. The patched fabric was utilitarian, bringing a scrappy Crazy back full circle to how it began.

  • 16 years ago

    They are 2 different things in my mind. I don't care for crazy quilts, especially the traditional ones with all that fancy fabric. But I love to make scrappy quilts! I'll pick a pattern, then maybe a focus fabric, then add scraps for the other colors. Currently I'm making a bunch of miniatures and I plan for them to be all scrappy...using up that stash!

    Donna

  • 16 years ago

    I enjoy the old traditional crazy quilts with all the embroidery and fancy fabrics.

    Will I ever make one - NO. I don't enjoy embroidery by hand, and I think most machine embroidery is to small and fine for a true crazy quilt.

    Contemporary crazy quilts? Well, yes, I like them well enough. I admire many I have seen. Will I make one? Probably not. I like them, but not enough to devote my time to one.

  • 16 years ago

    They are two COMPLETELY different things in my mind. I don't like crazy quilts. I cringe inside every time I see one.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm with petalpatsy. I made a semi-controlled crazy quilt once with scraps from different people in my husband's family. It was for my niece and she loved it. Not my cup of tea at all.
    {{!gwi}}
    I love scrappy but it must have some sort of order to it--it's more difficult for me to randomly organize a scrap quilt than to just use 6-7 basic fabrics. I like contrast but not clashing colors/patterns:{{!gwi}}

  • 16 years ago

    Diane - love both of those! My grandma had 2 crazy quilts with the embroidery. My mom has the one that was in the best shape and is original - very pretty. I have the second one that was worn and spend many decades rolled up as a bolster on my grandparents bed. My mom talked my grandma into 'rescuing' it, and my grandma, being practical above all else, took out the worn sections and replaced them with fabrics at hand - 70's polyesters. An old blanket is used as the batting so it is really heavy. I don't know what to do with the thing. I feel guilty for not liking it, but it is not pretty, very utilitarian, but not pretty!
    Karlene

  • 16 years ago

    While I consider them 2 different things, a crazy quilt falls under my definition of scrappy:)

  • 16 years ago

    I also think of them as the same but different!!! I guess when I think of crazy quilt I have an exact picture in my mind but with scrappy I think of lots of different ideas.

    Beautiful quilts.

  • 16 years ago

    I think of them as different; like all Siamese cats are cats, but not all cats are Siamese. A crazy quilt is a type of scrappy quilt, but any pattern or block can be made scrappy, 'controlled scrappy', color scrappy (one part of the pattern all blues, just not the same blues), or totally planned. Crazy quilts would always be scrappy.

    I'm not crazy about crazy. It does not fit my sense of order and pattern. The ones made with velvets, lace, and a variety of lush fabrics along with trim, embroidery and other embellishments can be very interesting and I can admire them but it's still not something I want to do or have.

    We tried a crazy block for one of the lottos (last year?) and I have to say I failed miserably! LOL I just could not get comfortable with it. I made and threw out 2 blocks before I figured out that was how they were supposed to look! OK, I'm exaggerating but I think Dian57 said it best: it's not my cup of tea.

  • 16 years ago

    6 of one a half a dozen of another--although I don't class them as the samething I have to admit that carzy quilts are scrappy, but you can say the same of a charm quilt and a crumb quilt--the difference in a crazy quilt is the embroider. Jayne