Software
Houzz Logo Print
catwat_gw

Kitchen Cabinets:White or wood?

17 years ago

We have decided on wide plank wood floors for out kitchen, either pine or hickory and now can't decide between a white beadboard cabinet with cherry crown molding or alder cabinets in light to medium stain. This decision has kept our starting our kitchen on hold for weeks...any suggestions or experiences to share??

Comments (16)

  • 17 years ago

    If u spend enough time on decorating boards you'll find there are two types of people when it comes to kitchens: those who love white kitchens (ME) and the rest.

    I vote for white. ;-)

  • 17 years ago

    Here's a picture of our kitchen with 5" wide, site finished hickory floors with med. stained alder cabinets and a painted/glazed island. Maybe this will help you visualize both stained and painted options a bit better. I love the floors and think it's just a matter of opinion on going with the white beadboard or stained cabinets. BTW, I fall into "the rest" catagory. :)

    (Sorry it's so big. I've tried several times and just can't get it smaller.)

  • 17 years ago

    My vote is for creamy white a la jbrodie's kitchen! I'm at the beginning stages of a kitchen reno and we will be redoing our original (1860?) pine floors and installing creamy white cabinets. I love the contrast in color. Otherwise, I just personally find it's too much wood.

  • 17 years ago

    Hahahaha Buddyrose so true! I also am a white kitchen person. :-)

    I agree w/ mrs monkey that sometimes it looks like it's alot of wood. I think I prefer more of a contrast between the flooring and cabinets.

  • 17 years ago

    We did a stained wood perimeter and a painted island. I thought it was a good compromise since we like wood, but didn't want to feel like we were in a sauna or something ;o)

  • 17 years ago

    when we reno'd our last house we had the wood floors refinished and put maple stained cabinets in the kitchen. when it was done i wasn't crazy about it. too much wood for me. of course, that's when i REALLY started looking at different things. i quickly dubbed that kitchen (as well as the whole house) our "practice" house. we're building new now. needless to say i vote for dreamy white.

    you should spend some time on the finished kitchens blog to really be clear on your taste: http://finishedkitchens.blogspot.com/
    the only way to go about such a huge project is to be clear on what you like and what you don't. i found this amazing site last night too: http://www.houzz.com/
    good luck and let us know how you're project is going!

  • 17 years ago

    What kind of trim do you have in the rest of the house? Is it stained or painted? What's the age/style of the house?

  • 17 years ago

    It's so true! I LOVE white kitchens. I kept looking at pictures to figure out what I liked and I found that if it was white...I loved it. I do however think they are more upkeep. My white cabinets show dust,smudges, and dirt way more than my old oak ones.

    Jan

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with Kateskouros, check out the finished kitchen blogs. Look through magazines, books, on line design sites and mark your favorites. After a week or less find out which elements repeat in your pics. White or wood?

    You are either a wood or white person. I love White, Cream, Off White or any range of white before wood. I have had Brazillian Cherry, Dark walnut, Maple, Whitewashed Oak, Honey colored Maple and now I have white. In all the years and all my moves I always wanted white. White can turn into most any style. Be it classic country, Italian old world, traditional, transitional, modern, French country, British Colonial, Cottage, Southern sunny charm, Foodie cook's style kitchen, relaxed island, ... But as I list these it makes me think a good designer could turn an all wood kitchen into one of the above style. I am biased to white. White works for me.

    Wood does not have the same flexibility. But if you like the chunky craftsman, or light minimal scandinavian design or maybe the natural asian influences then wood would be a way to go. There was recently a post about men liking wood better than white. I tend to agree.

    Best of luck

  • 17 years ago

    to the OP, if your choices are only between white and light or med stained wood, I would go with the white, since I think the contrast would look better with your floors.

    I'm actually part of the rest too, not a white lover above all. I tend to love super dark cabs...brown or black, either stained OR painted. There are also so many pretty painted kitchens that are colors other than white or cream.

  • 17 years ago

    I'd suggest doing something that you love now, but can un-do later. Anotherwords, right now you love white (as do many, and how can you not?), but in 5 or 10 years, you might wish you could strip them and have them wood. Give yourself that option. I know that right now it seems like you could never tire of white, it's classic, but styles change and tastes change and at one point, white might not be what you love.

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with the others in that you either love white kitchens or you don't. I like painted cabs. I am doing a white, but also a yellow ochre on the island. I have an open floor plan and oak floors throughout. I have had stained cabs before but I felt it was overwhelming and very furniture store kinda looking? I'm sure that doesn't make sense to anyone but crazy ol' me :). ....I also think you should spend a lot of time looking at pictures....you will know when you see it :). Good luck!

  • 17 years ago

    Look at www.houzz.com---that is the best site I have found for decorating etc....I have looked so long that my eye balls are coming out. You may get some great ideas...I have.

  • 17 years ago

    I think it has a lot to do with what the rest of your house looks like. The style of the kitchen should not vary that much from the rest of the house. Take cues from your overall decor/architecture.

    (There are exceptions to this, such as ultra modern kitchens in an old house that may have not even had one originally...however, the style of the kitchen really shouldnt look "older" than the style of the rest, or overly rustic in a non rustic house etc.)

  • 17 years ago

    Wow...thanks for all the feedback. A lot of good advice and questions came up. Our house is a 1928 renovated summer bungalow, a few blocks from the beach. It's only 800 square feet. I like the white because it gives that airy beachhouse look, but i also like the wood because it does reflect the warm "bungalow-style." I saw a kitchen that had the white cabinets, to the ceiling, then lined with cherry crown molding, and I love it because it really warms up the white. Crazyhouse, I love the look or your kitchen, as well, it is about the same shades we are looking at, it looks so warm. We do have white painted crown molding throughout, and, in general a light feeling. We are knocking down a half wall into the dining room to open it up into one room and the dining room is kind of "sunroom-ish" with four windows and a french door style slider out to the deck. We have lots of wainscoting, and while I love the white beadboard cabinets, I am partly worried I migh get tired of the look. I wll check out www.houzz.com tonight and see what i come up with.

  • 17 years ago

    I will echo others....check the Finished Kitchens Blog (FKB)...you can select cabinet colors from the "FKB Categories" link (on the right side of the FKB page).

    I do disagree w/others though, in that I like to look at white kitchens and can appreciate them, but I wouldn't want them in my kitchen. So, while I don't love them, I certainly don't hate them!

    If this is a beach house, in my minds eye I picture natural woods....i.e., neither painted nor stained (medium or dark)...all natural!


    Good luck!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Finished Kitchens Blog

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals