Software
Houzz Logo Print
carolek_gw

Finishing quilts?

18 years ago

I'm not talking about putting on a binding. I'm talking about finishing making the quilt. I often start to read a book and if I don't like the main characters or feel the writer doesn't have an accurate grasp of the period or milieu, I have no problem leaving it unfinished. If I don't find the experience satisfying, I see no reason to spend precious hours of life doing it.(This may be the perspective of age talking).

I was certainly raised to believe we need to finish projects even if we don't love them, but quilts are mostly meant to be a labor of love, although that can include a difficult challenge. But if it ceases to be a labor of love, the quilt will be set aside and maybe saved just in case the inspiration returns. I have about four unfinished projects, mostly in the design phase or partially pieced.

What would or has prompted you to give up on a quilt?

Carole

Comments (11)

  • 18 years ago

    I think if it was for me and I started to detest it I would walk away.

    So far the quilts that I've grown most weary of while making them have been for other people who picked the colors/pattern -- so their excitement/anticipation of the quilt pushed me through to the end. If it was a quilt just for me, I HOPE I would give it enough thought/testing that I would not invest too much time and money in it before ditching it.

    One thing I have noticed is that as I have been enjoying this hobby for over 3 years now, I have started to really KNOW what I like much more than I did at first.

    Some things I no longer do:
    1) Buy/use fabric 'cause it's cheap and I "sort" of like it. NO NOT GOOD ENOUGH, I must LOVE it or I leave it. It must look PERFECT to me with the other colors or I will not waste my time on it.

    2) Start a quilt pattern just because it looks fast and easy. NO NOT GOOD ENOUGH -- I would much rather put 1,000 glorious hours into a quilt that REALLY inspires me that is as good as I can make it and perfect to MY tastes when done, than 10 tedious hours into something I don't like that much just because it was easy and I could get it done fast. If I'm going to invest my time and energy I want to really like what I'm making.

    Oh, and I'm more inclined to make sample blocks or lay things out in EQ ahead of time so I don't get an ugly surprise at how it looks half way through.

    With that said -- the lure of a NEW project is ALWAYS more compelling than the part way done one, so I do have to force myself to finish things. But I "go Nike" and "just do it." My reward is a clear conscious for the next project! (I do have several going at once though.)

  • 18 years ago

    I hate, really hate UFOs sitting around.

    Usually after 4 to 6 blocks I can see if I want to spend more time. If 4 blocks don't thrill me, I may make two more, but after that - NO. I will then layer them with cheap muslin and cheap batting, and practice some quilting technique I need to learn. Then I serge the edges, and donate them to the local vet for cage liners.

    Other than the uglies which become pet blankies, I complete every quilt within a few weeks. I know most of you don't work this way. Personally, UFOs bug the crap outta me! One or two or even three projects can be in the loop at any one time, but stacking a completed top in a box for months - nope, I can't do that.

  • 18 years ago

    Well, I can think of one Stack 'n whack that I have partially cut out, but KNOW I will never try to finish because this material did not have the right sort of design. It may participate in a backing someday.

    Apart from that, once I have cut something out, I usually feel obligated to finish it. Or maybe I should say, rather, that if I have gotten that far, it is usually a material that I really like and a pattern I like, so there is a value in finishing it. I might decide not to make a quilt as big as I originally planned, if I find I'm not liking it a lot, though. I tend not to have many UFOs hanging around. I don't work at making quilts as diligently as many other members do. (Hangs head.)

    I also might well refuse to make a quilt for someone if they insisted on a pattern or colors I hated. The closest I have come to that was when a friend wanted me to use Kelly green. However, there were plenty of prettier (to me) colors to be used with it, so it wasn't really painful, and I liked the finished product.

    In principle, though, I think I agree with you. Life is too precious to spend a lot of time doing something you hate, if you don't have to and it is not very important for the happiness of some other person. When it comes to quilts, I see no reason for keeping on with one you hate making.

    LOL, Carol: It took me till old age to become really ruthless about abandoning books in the middle or even the beginning. Now, for instance, I rarely bother to keep reading a book at all, once I realize it is written entirely in the present tense, which I detest. (I have read a few that so gripped me from the first page that I didn't notice that they were offensive that way.) There seem to be more and more of those in-your-face present tense books being written, and when I order a book on the Internet or--especially--through PaperBackSwap, I can't know much about it in advance, beyond the general theme or plot. A few nights ago I stayed up late reading the letters of Isak Dinesen, the author of "Out of Africa," one of my favorites, but after reading some 50 pages at the end of it, decided it would be too depressing and sent it on to someone else! A waste of my money perhaps, but not of my time as well!

  • 18 years ago

    The lure of a new project is oh so tempting. Unfortunately, it doesn't take much to get me started on something new. It's what keeps my quilting interesting. I'm pretty sure I have at least 10 WIPs or UFOs sitting around.

    Another answer for ditching a quilt would be...diving into a project w/out realizing the tedious nature (see below). But I find it difficult to completely abandon it if I've cut all the pieces ahead of time.

    I'm still staring at a UFO that I picked up last year after it being stored away for 8 yrs. The tedious 25 curved pieced flower blocks caused me to quit the first time. I've now completed all 20 flowers except for attaching a yoyo center. The only reason keeping me going is that I absolutely LOVE the pattern & the fabric that I chose. But I have to let it rest for a few more months until I can get the gumption to work on the flower centers. Never mind assembling the top & quilting it (which I think I will pay someone to do when I get it to that point.) Maybe it's this pieced pattern that has made me love machine applique so much!

    In the past, I felt guilty about giving up on a UFO & giving it away, so I kept it as a forever UFO. But now that I belong to a church quilting group who donates quilts to Mexico & other charities...I can just put my quilt tops in the "to be completed" pile & have someone ELSE finish it for charity. Sometimes I can't stand looking at it anymore & need someone else to finish it.

  • 18 years ago

    I have always hated leaving something unfinished, just seemed wastefull. But you are right, with age comes ... discression. I hate to waste time working on something I really don't like. That may be one reason I don't sew for other people, so I can just work on what I like.

    I have a GFG that gets worked on only when I feel like it, but there is no hurry, it is what I call a "process" I enjoy and will eventually finish. The same with my yo-yo quilt. It started as a lap quilt and now is big enough for a sofa throw, but I keep making them and adding to it so it continues to grow.

    I have started some quilts, got some blocks finished and said "what the heck was I thinking?" and those become bags, baby quilts, lap quilts, pillows, table runners, pot holders, passed on to someone else, or chopped up fabric for birds nests (if I REALLY hate it). There is a use for everything.

    beverly

  • 18 years ago

    I have only one or two quilts that will probably never be finished--early attempts that got sidelined for one reason or another and now I just don't feel that they warrant taking up time that I'd much rather put into better quilts.

    I recently pieced a top and made a HUGE design error--simply used a fabric for the borders and sashing that doesn't work. I had doubts after assembling the first row, but kept going thinking that it might grow on me. Well, it hasn't! I'll be bringing it downstairs and start ripping out the borders and sashing for replacement. I am tempted to just put it away and forget about it, but it's made from blocks from a block exchange, I just don't want to let them go to waste.

    One thing that you can use your less-than-loved projects for is blankets for your local animal shelter. They are often looking for old blankets to use in the kennels and cat cages and dogs and cats aren't fussy.

    Annie

  • 18 years ago

    Like Laura, I've learned my lessons over time. I felt I must complete everything but didn't know much about the quilting. I would finish and find the quilting poorly done and felt I'd ruined my own quilt. So, I learned to not quilt it till I knew better ways. I took lots of classes and now have finished tops to practice on.

    I will always have UFOs. But, only till I feel inspired to finish them. New ideas pull me away and the day will come when the UFO beckens. I have an antique glass china cabinet and stack all the tops and quilts in there where they face me daily as I go by. I have reminders of what I've made and what I need to finish.

    I often have several going at once. The quilting area has one half quilted and the TV area has two hand sewing projects and piecing projects going. Starting my SBS blocks has pulled me away but I shift back and forth at a whim.

    Linda

  • 18 years ago

    I have one quilt that I could go back to, but I'm no longer sure where the drawing is. It is one of my pictorial designs. I go from small sketches to full size from which I will cut all the pieces for applique. I found a lot of things when we moved because I had to pack and find new places to put things. Two other quilts are strictly in the drawing stage, but I have fabrics. One was the third in the Arab series and it came up right about the time of the Gulf war and I thought maybe that should be on hold. The last one was kind of physical therapy. We were going to have to move and that meant leaving my quilting friends, leaving my gardens and beginning again in a totally strange place. I kept getting this image of a hand reaching out of the sky, grasping a plant and violently tearing it from the ground--very Freudian. Anyway, I started an abstract piece of a forest--I love trees. It took a long time to sell the house and move, and by the time we did, I no longer needed the forest picture.

    Some neat ideas about what to do with the rejects.

    Biwako of abi: I often reject books because I'm in the mood for something else-- usually period history, but sometimes I like things light or a mystery with cultural elements. I love western and native American art, so I enjoy Hillerman. My Zuni Sunrise quilt, the only one that hangs in my house, is part of that fascination. Carole

  • 18 years ago

    Carole: I like Hillerman, too. I like books best that I can learn something from, beyond just enjoying the plot, and Hillerman does that for me. I knew nothing about Navajo culture and the 4 corners area before discovering him. Too bad he hasn't written more.

  • 18 years ago

    I almost finished a Double Wedding Ring wall hanging for above the door of a split forger that we lived in. Then we moved. That quilt sat for 12 years! All I had to do was hand quilt around the outside ring! I showed it to my friend and she said let me take it home and finish this quilting for you, so I did. She brought it back in a few days and I put the binding on and we enjoy it hanging in my dinning room. I don't believe I would have ever finished that quilt otherwise because in my mind it had a "place" and that place was taken away from it

    Sometimes I start a project and put it down for some reason like this Morning Star I started and was totally gun oh on, but then my son said to me you promised to make me a rag quilt. So I pack up my Morning Star and I can't seem to get back into it. Right now I'm making a crazy quilt for my dd. It started being a 20 block swap for another forum but she said mom I want the blocks to be made by you and only from our materials. So I didn't join the swap and I'm working happily away on this crazy quilt. My Morning Star will call my name again. The thing is I haven't anyone to give it to and it's not big enough for my bed so I think that's one reason why I'm not working on it.

    Vicky

  • 18 years ago

    OK Jan and Carole -- you guys are really starting to make me feel guilty about my reading habits, LOL!

    You like to read books from which you can learn? I find that not only with books but tv shows as well, if I think I am going to have to LEARN something, I get annoyed! I recently read a crime drama that was pretty decent but the author kept using dialog to "teach" things about something (I don't even remember what -- some area or era or profession or who knows I don't remember because I just shook my head in irritation and skipped over it but it was pretty annoying and I kept thinking "shut up, who cares about this?" -- now I know, lol!

    When I pick up a book in a store (usually an airport newstand!) I flip it open and thumb through it -- I'd better see SHORT paragraphs and LOTS of dialog or I know I'll hate it. I want action, and I want it NOW!

    When the author goes into describing a bunch of #%$^%^$ I just read the first half of the first sentence of that paragraph and then skip to the next paragraph. I don't care about the weather, the scenery, her hair color, what town they are in, what year it is. I just want to know what is going to happen to whom and let's get the show on the road!

    DH Does not read for pleasure -- but he will read business books and it irritates him when he sees me with my crime novels because he thinks it's a waste of time -- if I'm reading I should be educating myself. But I seldom get a mental vacation these days and I THINK NOT!

    Jan funny what you said about Out of Africa being sad -- I never read the book but saw the movie many years ago. I don't recall much about it other than my shirt was soaked with tears by the time it was done.