Software
Houzz Logo Print
earlygirl44

how many quotes from varoius KD????

18 years ago

I'm meeting today with my KD and am nervous (I'm new to remodeling) about the meeting . I know it is up to me to accept or send her back to the table...we are on a budget , who isn't, but she made a small remark that most of her kichens are 40,000 + and that is way over my project. We are more or less just updating a 8x9 L shaped kitchen

How many places /box stores/desingers do folks go to get a sense that if what they are being presented is a good deal ??

There is probably a thread on this,and if anyone knows of one I would like the 411

Comments (10)

  • 18 years ago

    I went to 3 different places. The prices do range but overall, they are basically all in the same ballpark!! I live in NJ (a place where everything is expensive)and will be remodeling/demo in about a few weeks and when we think about it, this one room is sooooo expensive!! I could have probably done every room over and had some money left over!!! I am sure it will be worth it. I hope!!!!

  • 18 years ago

    I started out with a KD who was really good, but generally did more expensive projects and kept pushing me to go over my budget, despite the fact that I was really clear about what it was. I eventually ended happily paying for his overall design/concept and switching midstream to a KD at a UBC (think really big hardware store) for my cabinets/counters, who was better at the little details and respected my budget. I felt bad about switching, but don't regret it now.

    See at least 3 people and make sure that they know they will be working within your budget. Not all designers sell cabinets. If you go with one that does, be aware there may be a tendency, even among good ones, to steer you towards design options where you end up buying more cabinets. Best wishes on your project.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree w/ chefkev - use the KD for design services if you think she can really put your vision on paper w/ a great plan for your space - then shop the plan to at least 3 kitchen centers/cabinet shops/etc - your KD may have someone in mind that she uses and to be fair I'd take that person/place's numbers but then definitely get others. If your KD is rigid about only using her people, then look elsewhere.

  • 18 years ago

    we priced out 3 lines initially. One of them was not working out from teh start, so for the other 2 lines, I got one more quote from a different shop for the same design. The same design varied in pricing from one place to another! So all together we got 5 quotes. We ended up getting teh cabients in a plce that had our cabinets at 55% off the list price. The other place had them at 35% off. Huge price difference!

  • 18 years ago

    We went to 3 different companies representing multiple different cabinet lines and met with 3 different KDs. gave them our initial sketches (which I drew) and desires, let each come up with a prelim plan (at no cost) and bid for the cabinets / install / etc. Then we chose the one we liked the best and negotiated from there. There was probably an initial difference in cabinetry prices of $8K between the high and low - and an overall difference of about $10K in total project costs.

    We actually ended up going with the most expensive initial proposal (we liked the cabinets the best) but thru negotiation / some minor tweaking we got it pricewise in the same general ballpark as the other two.

    Point being - don't be afraid to spend the time with 3 KDs - especially at no obligation and let each come up with a prelim plan / bid. We actually took ideas each KD came up with and incorporated them into our final plan - so all contributed in some way to the final outcome.

  • 18 years ago

    I had 3 priced. They were not all exactly the same designs, so it wasn't necessarily an apples to apples comparison. But it was close enough to make a decision. However, price on my decision was secondary to design and LIKING the KD and having very good communication from and with her. Seems like the relationship aspect if often overlooked - and I have to say that the suppliers that I've used and LIKED (got along well with and was able to communicate with) have been a cinch to deal with. Contrary to those who I just didn't gel with - who've been a pain in my butt since Day #1, and continue to be until I am done with them/their service.

  • 18 years ago

    I did 3 or 4 (gad can't remember...ds was in the hospital when they started coming in) and took their proposals for the house (kitchen and three baths). Their designs were all crap so I gave up and did my own. I then took that to two designers for bids (so really apples to apples) and went with one of them (two different companies). I got those cabinets, they were delivered and they were crap...so

    Back to three more cabinet companies looking at three different brands, all in the same quality range, but with different retailers. I ended up liking Omega Custom (they were the only ones who could do some of the more complex pieces I'd designed) and I got two bids from local retailers on the exact same Omega Custom specs. One (known the be the snotty designer in town...which is SO wrong) was $30,000 LESS for the exact same cabinets from the other company (known to be more friendly...SO WRONG!). I went with the snotty designer...who I adore :) And saved $30M :)

  • 18 years ago

    I really don't think most of the AP (Above posters) are really comparing apples to apples when they mention KD's. A real
    KD would be similar to an architect, in that they would draw up a plan and charge for their time and expertise.

    IMHO, for a kitchen and budget your size, you could get what you need from cabinet places that supply the design service free as part as their offering. I went to many, probably 7 or 8, but really only got 'designs' from 3 places, used the design closest to what I ended up with as the basis for the other quotes. the beauty of shopping around, is that everyone approaches it from a different standpoint and you can pick their brains to come up with the ultimate design that works best for you.

    But, then again, I have never used a 'real' designer for anything, so I have no experience with that. But, I do echo the relationship thing. My KG (not a designer), has our best interests at heart, and for all the problems/delays we've had, he has put in so much time and effort, that I can't imagine that anyone else would have cared like that and bent over backwards to get it to all work out.

    So, in summary, use as many free resources as you have the time and inclination for until you come up with a plan and a person that you feel really comfortable with. Our final one was 1/3 the cost of our highest quote! So, the quotes CAN vary humungeously!!!

  • 18 years ago

    As raehelen said, there is a difference between KDs and cabinet retailers - that's why I think that unless you're nuts, er, I mean talented, like igloochic and go design crazy all by yourself, use the KD for a design, a plan. Then shop that plan around - you can talk w/ whomever your KD likes to work with but also be sure to go to many different suppliers/retailers. I had 5 bids with a $60M difference between top and bottom and ended up going w/ a custom shop that I found through a friend and got everything exactly as I'd wanted for almost 1/2 of my lowest bid. In other words, use a KD for as much as you think you truly NEED her/him, then spend your own money, don't let someone else spend it for you!!

  • 18 years ago

    I disagree MNhockeymom. For a lot of projects (espeically those of folks here who have already done their homework), there is no real need IMO to pay for a KD to work up a design. Many retailers (at least in my area) / others provide enough free design services (many NKBA certified) that are comparable. IMO, it would be a waste of time and money to pay someone to design something for you to shop around. Part of the benefit of shopping around and getting different design input is not just from a pricing perspective but also to benefit from different ideas from different people.

    As I noted, even though I had already sketched out our vision and was pretty specific on a number of items, each designer we met who worked out a design / pricing added their own twist and we ended up picking up a couple good ideas from each to incorporate in the final plan.

    Now, if you have a very complicated project or have done no homework and want someone to do it all for you (which many people do), thats different. But my belief is most people on this site are so TKO they are much more hands on that for most, there is no need to pay a KD to come up with an initial design