Software
Houzz Logo Print
uafly1

Going against your designer advice

14 years ago

I have been in my home for 8 years. It was my first place and when I first moved in I could not afford much. Slowly I've managed to decorate it myself. A few years ago I hired an interior designer to help me pick out a dining room table. I was having a hard time. She made some other suggestions, some that I took and others I thought well...

Fast forward, I just expanded a room, and the the space is a little small, so I thought it would pay to get her opinion again. I agreed with most of her suggestions, even though some of them were costing more then I wanted to spend. But she had 2 ideas that I was just not sold on.

One being using roman shades for sliding door and the other for a built in tv console.

I currently have a curtains covering the sliding door but I need something sun blocking. I guess I thought it would be easier to buy new curtains, rather then having to go through the hassle of roman shades (installation).

As for the built in TV console, I cringe to think of where TV's are heading and would have to have this elaborate built made for today's TV.

Anyone else go against decorator's advice?

Comments (9)

  • 14 years ago

    I would not go with these particular pieces of advice because roman shades need to be all the way up in order to allow the door to be used. It is easier to get partial shade and still have use of the door with a treatment that works in the same direction.

    I would also only do a built in TV unit under certain conditions--It would have to be very flexible in terms of the type of TV one used on it. I would consider a built in that simply had a large grommet on the horizontal surface the TV sat on for all wiring to run through with all outlets and hookups hidden away underneath, but I am not sure I would commit to a built in that completely enclosed the whole TV at this point.

  • 14 years ago

    Today's TVs are slim enough to hang on the wall like a picture, and they have the ability to show your images. So, instead of a large piece of furniture to hide the TV, hang it like a picture and display your own video art on it.

    Here's a table to show the cost per year in electricity use. Assumptions are set on 5.2 hours per day, 365 days a year, electricity cost 11.55 cents per kilowatt-hour. Even the most expensive set to run will cost far less than a built in TV console.

    Here is a link that might be useful: HDTV Power consumption

  • 14 years ago

    I've not worked with a designer but I have worked with an architect, and it wasn't easy finding the right one whose taste and mine were sympatico. Even at that we had our disagreements...sometimes he would win, sometimes I would win and sometimes the budget would win! I drew the line at function. While he knew a lot more about design, I knew a lot more about how we lived. Form follows function, and if the design doesn't function, it's irrelevant how beautiful it is.

    But it's important to remember that you are paying for the designers taste, and if you are going to ignore his/her advice, then why pay a designer...or at least why pay this one?

  • 14 years ago

    I've never wanted to live with someone else's idea of design. I do read books and research online, but I know what I like, casual sort of contempory/casual- mix with antiques. I do not like a modern look at all. I just know what I enjoy, and find it is cheaper to look around and see what I think i would like living with. At my former home of 35 years, I built on twice, and never hired a contractor. I decided what I wanted, and hired my own workmen - saved a lot of money. I still miss my gourmet kitchen and 4 acres - and added pool, deck and patio. But downsized to move near my daughter. I'm still working on making this house mine. Laid hardwood flooring in the entire house, replaced vanties, sinks,faucets, light fixtures, mirrors, landscaped, have a small orchard and garden (on .16 acre). Right now I'm deciding on new paint colors. Been here 10 years and it is constantly elvolving - but as my budget will stand to do things only.

  • 14 years ago

    I agree with you, roman shades on a sliding glass door? No way! I like to play with lighting too much and would hate the hassle they'd cause when I want to use the door. That idea is just not practical at all.

    I also agree with your thoughts on the built ins. While I love the idea, the practicality is just not realistic. Maybe you can have built ins built around the spot for the tv and hang the tv on the wall.

  • 14 years ago

    If you feel that it goes with your current theme of room, then you should go for that cover and I don't think so that roman shades might work well.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Irish Gift

  • 14 years ago

    Me thinks St. Paddy's Day has come and gone. :)

  • 14 years ago

    I don't get why people want to build a shrine around their tv. If it is shelves that the person wants, thats one thing, but to build around a tv on an entire wall, I would think is overkill. I hope I don't sound snotty, I just don't get it. No way would I do a roman shade, its just plain not practical. Who wants to live with something so bothersome?

  • 14 years ago

    Thank you everyone!
    I am happy that I hired her as she gave me some great advice for other things, or more so peace of mind. But I had to wonder where she was going with the roman shade and TV thing.

    I am not trying to make the TV the focal, so I am planning on going with 1/2 her suggestion. Leave it where it's at and just buy a new piece for it to stand on.

    As for the roman shades, I like my curtain rod, so I am just going to buy new curtains and be done with it.