Software
Houzz Logo Print
sixtyohno

Does this appraisal make sense?

12 years ago

DS in the PNW is getting a divorce. She has some inherited money and she made the down payment before the marriage. They paid $260000 8 years ago. Since then they did floors, appliances, heating system, terrific gardening, roof updated bathroom, and a small addition. She wanted to buy him out, keep it as a rental, and buy herself a new house so she started working with an agent. The agent had the house appraised at $260,000 and she bought him out by subtracting the down payment, which was her money, subtracting what was owed and splitting the rest. He accepted $16,000. He won't fight with her because he doesn't want animosity because of their child. He is broke because he had to buy a car and rent an apartment and get some furniture. I think he should renegotiate. Does this appraisal sound realistic? Does he have reason to re negotiate? He is not a fighter. He hates argument s. Do I intefer? We have been sending money each month because he can't cover his expensives. I can't keep doing that. We are on the east coast.

Comments (17)

  • 12 years ago

    Location is everything. Lots of places haven't gone back to pre boom prices. It's entirely possible that this is the case here. Agents don't do appraisals after all, and you cannot cherry pick your appraiser.

  • 12 years ago

    "He is not a fighter. He hates argument s. Do I intefer? We have been sending money each month...."

    No, you don't interfere; he won't fight and you have no standing. He may "hate arguments", but if you do get in the middle, the only argument he may gin up will probably be with you. Stop sending money. He's a grown man.

  • 12 years ago

    "He won't fight with her because he doesn't want animosity because of their child.âÂÂ

    To be frank, your son is showing more maturity than you are. Be proud that he puts a childâÂÂs well being above his own desire for more cash -- and back off, your interference will not help this situation.

  • 12 years ago

    Hopefully he has signed a final agreement so there is no renegotiating.
    Stay out of it and top paying for him, he will/can find a way to support himself.

  • 12 years ago

    By interfering, I meant telling him I thought he need an independent appraisal. I would never contact my soon to be ex DIL. I have never said an unpleasant word about her to DS. Her mother still sends me photos our shared grandson and her.

  • 12 years ago

    double message, sorry

    By interfering, I meant telling him I thought he need an independent appraisal. I would never contact my soon to be ex DIL. I have never said an unpleasant word about her to DS. Her mother still sends me photos our shared grandson and her.

    This post was edited by sixtyohno on Sat, Sep 13, 14 at 12:59

  • 12 years ago

    So she bought it at the height of the market and is now "selling" after prices have dropped in most places and maybe on the upswing. It makes sense that it's worth the same amount now. The time for an independent appraisal was prior to the agreement. I commend your son for his behavior and not making it into an issue because of his child. Money comes and goes. A relationship with a young child with divorcing parents is more important.

  • 12 years ago

    Are they handling all of the divorce and child custody/support issues without any legal representation?

  • 12 years ago

    That is not how you buy out the other partner. If his name is still on the mortgage, he is liable. He may never qualify to purchase another home as long as he is still considered an owner on this property.

  • 12 years ago

    Linda117 is correct. Your son should not sign a "Quit Claim" deed for the property until his ex has refinanced the house into her name only (and proves she has done so). A "Quit Claim" means that he no longer has ownership rights to the property but can still be held liable for the mortgage debt.

    If he hadn't already accepted the settlement, you would have been right to suggest to him that he have an independent appraisal. However, it sounds like it's already a done deal now.

  • 12 years ago

    Since 2006 was the height of the real estate bubble and people rarely recoup the cost of home improvements, it is entirely possible. It depends a lot on the location.

    On principle he really shouldn't rely on an appraisal by her real estate agent, however.

    Your original post didn't mention a "Quit Claim" deed, but Jewel654 is right. If the house isn't paid for, she really should refinance to get him off the mortgage.

    I find if people try to do this without a lawyer whoever sees the process as more "adversarial" scr3ws the other over. He really does need to get a lawyer...to sort out the real estate, if nothing else.

    This post was edited by edlincoln on Wed, Sep 17, 14 at 10:24

  • 12 years ago

    What is DS and what is PNW?

  • 12 years ago

    DS Dear Son
    PNW Pacific Northwest

  • 12 years ago

    We are lacking some important details. They are both equally taking a loss on the $$ invested into maintenance and improvements it seems (if the house is sold now). She ponied up the down payment; did he then make the majority of the house payments or were they splitting that burden equally or was she also paying most of that? It could be that she was carrying the majority of the house financial burden all along and so this agreement might be more than fair.

    I'd say, don't interfere. No reason to stir up hostility, he needs to do what he needs to do to support himself, his child and to be a good father.

  • 12 years ago

    EDIT: Wow, everyone is making A LOT of assumptions here. As I said, I didn't see you mention a quit claim, deed. Also, everyone seems to be seeing this through the lens of "Dad helping his poor helpless wife support their kid". For all we know he's the one caring for the kid and the financial settlement is leaving the kid destitute.

    More importantly, a financial settlement that is unrealistic is the gift that keeps on giving. It can lead to bitterness or a gaping financial wound that you bleed from forever because you can never quite catch up. Nowadays lots of people seem to want to bypass the lawyers, but I find this tends not to turn out well. Someone ends up getting screwed. It's really best to focus on the numbers on these things and treat them as financial decisions.

  • 12 years ago

    I just sold my house in the PNW for 15% above its bubble high. I'd replaced the roof, sewer line, electrical panel and the like, but done zero remodeling. My house was also in a really really hot neighborhood.
    I've seen houses in my new neighborhood 10 miles south that are still selling below their 2006 prices. So perhaps the appraisal was too low, maybe it wasn't. It's probably too late to get involved, even if you "should."

  • 12 years ago

    My soon to be ex DIL is well set through a series of inheritances. My DS has nothing. He is a craftsman who worked out of their house. Now he is working for someone else and struggling. Supposedly they shared expenses, but I am pretty sure she did more than he. We have decided to say nothing right now.