Software
Houzz Logo Print
sheilatn

Two home dilemma - long

19 years ago

In 1998, we retired and built "my" dream home in eastern Tennessee. It was a golfing community. I golfed but dh didnÂt. In 2005 dh wanted to move to western KY, nearer his brother that he fished and hunted with. We sold our TN home in a few hours of listing and purchased another home in KY in April 2005. In February of this year dh passed away unexpectedly. I was left with a home with a high maintenance backyard. It has a rambling path of colored concrete, a Swiss Alps cottage for a tool shed etc., scads of flowers, a fishpond, and a lot of other amenities. It would be an impossible yard to convert to grass. With the previous owner, the garden was on the annual Tour of Gardens twice. I am not into gardening at all.

I put the KY home on the market in April and a month later had a decent offer. I didnÂt have anywhere I wanted to move yet so I turned it down. That was the worst in a series of bad decisions. In September one of my four adult children found the "perfect" home for me which was near them (three blocks away) in central IL and I purchased it. I now have two homes (both paid for luckily) and have had several offers on the KY home which havenÂt worked out. One of the offers was being written when the manÂs boss called and said the company was not transferring him after all.

I am sick and tired of the whole thing and have about decided to sell the IL home FSBO after the holidays and use the taxes I would save to hire a yard person. The KY taxes are $1500 and the IL taxes are $5400 for almost identically priced homes. The IL home would probably sell quickly, but my family is adamant that I shouldnÂt do that. I was given advice when I became a widow to wait a year before making major decisions. I wish I had heeded that advice. My other thought is to sell both homes as soon as possible (both at losses probably) and just get a very small simple home somewhere. I have moved about a third of my belongings to IL but have left the KY home looking occupied at my realtors request.

Comments (21)

  • 19 years ago

    What is your question?

  • 19 years ago

    Question - sell one, both or neither. Sorry I wasn't clearer. I am just so frustrated.

  • 19 years ago

    Finances aside, where would you rather live?

  • 19 years ago

    Sounds like it shouldn't be too difficult to sell the Kentucky home if you've had several offers that haven't worked out. I know taxes are higher in Illinois, but living closer to your family may be worth it. I believe Illinois, or at least the Chicago area, has a policy where they freeze property taxes for the elderly so if this is true in your area the taxes won't go up. I've heard that Kentucky is extremely favorable to retirees, but if you don't have your family around will you be happy. Personally I think you should, sell the Kentucky home for whatever you can get for it, reevaluate after that to see if you need to sell your Illinois home and move to a smaller more maneagable home near your family. Just my opinion.

  • 19 years ago

    I am sorry for your loss, and for the frustrations that you feel. It sounds as though you're feeling a little bit pushed around by circumstances, and other peoples' expectations. A little time may help you figure out what you want.

    I vote also for waiting a little bit, and for deciding on the basis of THESE factors:

    You are only going to get older. Where to you want to grow old and infirm? What sort of life (activities, community, nearness to family) do you want to have between now and then--but most important, then?

    Position yourself NOW for being old enough that you aren't comfortable driving to visit family--or that the rigors of travel are too exhausting for you.

    Position yourself NOW to create a non-family community and interests, so that you don't find yourself bored and lonely if you move closer to them when you're infirm enough that it's hard to travel around, and it's too late to create a history with other people.

    Position yourself NOW to create a situation in which your income, home ownership, home maintenance, etc., will be something you can sustain long-term.

    So many people find themselves suddenly much older than they realized, and having to make a big move into a lower-maintenance home, etc., and it's really uprooting to their sense of home and community. As we age, I think many of us get less strong-willed, less able to out-reason our children, and less able to drive our own lives. Do that "driving" now, but with an eye on 15 years from now, or even more.

    My mom moved her & Dad from a small Iowa town to be in a bigger city, so they could get to a major medical center by taxi or bus. In that small town, they'd have had to rely on the kindness of neighbors (no taxi services), and there is only a VERY small hospital, so going to the doctor for some complicated medical procedure would involve a 2-hour drive just one-way--not something many neighbors could provide.

    And they're not even old--but they've needed that access to medical care, and that ability to rely on public transportation, etc., more than once already.

  • 19 years ago

    forgot to add:

    one of my friend's mother moved from NYC (which seems like a big city that would have lots of services, but actually isn't that great in that regard) to Albany NY, near one of her daughters. She moved NOW, not later, because she wanted to move while she was still energetic enough to volunteer for stuff at church, or in the community, which would help her make friends and give her a purpose to each day that takes our OUTSIDE her home, and is NOT family. Her own life.

    She and her daughter were lucky--and smart. They looked in a neighborhood one over from the daughter's, but on a bus line that led to the daughter's house. So Grandma can come by bus, even if she decides not to drive. Or grandkids can go to Grandma's by bus as well. But Grandma still has some feelig of privacy, of feeling that she can have neighbors who are HER neighbors, and every detail of her life isn't under her daughter's scrutiny (and vice versa).

    They picked that neighborhood also because it has good bus connections to the mall, and grocery store.

    I don't mean to make you feel old and vulnerable (and it's true that I have NO idea how old you are--Mom made her plans when she was 60 and dad was 65--still quite young), but in a way, you've got a great opportunity to lay plans for your life now. Maybe you need a little more time to figure out what you want that life to be, now that you're solo.

  • 19 years ago

    If you were my mother, I would advise you to continue to list the KY house. It sounds like the house is desirable, you just have to find the right buyer. You don't want to live there, and with your DH passed it sounds like there isn't much keeping you in that area. As far as the IL house goes, do you want to live near that child? If you do, I would keep the house. Live in it for now. If it ends up being too big you can sell it then. Once you know the area better you may know the exact place you want.

  • 19 years ago

    My condolences on the loss of your husband.

    As suggested above, you should probably wait a bit before making any more decisions. There are many stages to grief, but it is suggested that people who have had a traumatic grief experience (loss of spouse or child) wait a year before making any life altering changes. Moving and selling homes are life altering.

    Once you get to the point where you can think clearly, consider all advice from friends, relatives, your accountant and your attorney. Decide what is important to your quality of life. Taxes are less important than family, quality health care, public transportation options, familiarity of surrounding, weather, etc. Make a list of life priorities based on today, ten years from now and twenty years from now. Think of it as life planning tied to financial planning. Let the lists sit for a month and revisit them. See what you have forgotten, make changes as you've rethought priorities.

    After you decide what is important to your quality of life and your pocketbook, then make the decision on what to sell and where to move. Decide what type of housing suits you best; it may no longer be a single family home.

    Good luck and best wishes.

  • 19 years ago

    I am so sorry for your loss and the complications that have arisen. I also lost my husband suddenly when our kids were 6 and 10, so I pretty much had the decision made for me about what to do with the house because they were in school and I didn't want to move them, adding additional stress for them. We lived there for three more years, when I remarried and we bought a different house in the same town. I think what you need to decide first and foremost is where you want to live, not which house costs you more or which you like better. Decide which area makes you feel happiest (I know that being happy is probably tough right now, but it will come!), sell the home or homes you don't need, and choose a place that you can afford and maintain. Good luck!

  • 19 years ago

    Why would you consider selling both?
    Do you not like it in KY or IL?
    Is there somewhere else you would rather live?
    Is there something about the IL house that you do not like?

    Just trying to understand what your thinking.

  • 19 years ago

    I think selling the KY home should definitely remain your goal. Once you have that accomplished, take some time to just relax in the area you are. If after a little while you don't like it there, you should then consider moving either from that home or IL.

    I am so sorry for your loss.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks so much for all the helpful advice. I should have listened to that type advice earlier. Right now I am down at the KY home, without TV or Internet, as I cancelled them when I moved partially to IL. I can occasionally get on the Internet via some unknown neighbors' wireless connection. It doesn't last long and I am not even sure if it is legal to do that. It just popped up when I was playing some card games.

    I guess I am going to wait a little longer for this KY home to sell. The IL home is cheerier and smaller. And most of all there is no fancy garden. All of my children are 3 hours or less from there so I will give it a try. I must have done something right as they all (including inlaws) are determined I should be in their area. If things hadn't happened I would still be in TN but that is a ten hour trip each way for them with little ones strapped into car seats. I can't be that selfish now.

    I've lowered the price, decluttered, staged and tried to beautify so now I may have to just plant one of those "saint statues" in the yard for good luck. I keep asking my realtor what else I can do and she says she only receives positive comments on the house and yard. It is a nine year old all brick 3000 sq. ft. well built home, but is the most expensive house in this neighborhood which doesn't help. I can't change the neighborhood. I bet Californians would love to have all that for $220,000 or so, including the showcase yard which I detest.

  • 19 years ago

    Are you offering a one yr home warranty? or any closing costs?

  • 19 years ago

    At this point, I could probably offer a warranty, but I don't understand the closing costs specials. My closing costs on the IL property were $60 for the title search. I forgot to mention there is an 8 person hot tub that is two years old in a gazebo with a patio and a fire pit with a tin roof for safety. The wall construction of the house is 2x6 instead of 2x4, with extra insulation, and two furnace/ac units and two water heaters. There are 3 full baths also. Not a bad deal? But, I can't find a buyer, so it might as well be a simple shack for sale. It is even in a college town which Rand/McNally listed as the top place to retire a few years ago. If I had realized how hard it would be to sell this place I never would have purchased the IL home. Life isn't fair, but we weren't promised that I guess. 2007 has to be better than this year.

  • 19 years ago

    My condolences as well on the loss of your husband. What a tough year you've had. Take comfort in the fact that your kids want you close by. We can't say the same thing about some of our family....

    I don't understand the closing costs specials. My closing costs on the IL property were $60 for the title search.

    You assumably paid cash, right? Your closing costs for cash would be very small. Most folks, however, will be mortgaging the house they buy. Closing costs for them will run somewhere between $3000-$5000. Offering to pay some or all of their closings costs means they have less to bring to the table to close.

    You'd be surprised how many people are cash-strapped when they buy a house! It's just an incentive to make your home more appealing than the one 3 blocks away that is similar, but doesn't offer closing costs.

    Best of luck to you!

  • 19 years ago

    $220k? Wow. I don't know how they built it for that.

  • 19 years ago

    I think you should figure out where YOU want to live instead of caving into family pressure because it is, after all, YOUR life. That not being "selfish." Your children have their own lives, don't they? What's wrong with you having yours?

    Besides, there's really no way for you to know whether or not all or any of your children will remain where they're now living, so I wouldn't base my decision on that, alone. That may mean selling both houses, but you shouldn't do that until you have developed a more long-range plan.

    If you you enjoyed living in Tennesse and still golf, you might consider a site condo in a golfing community. That would cut way back on your maintenence and you could probably unload it if and when your personal circumstances change and you might want to be nearer family. Or you could visit other areas that you find appealing, perhaps renting something for awhile before purchsing a residence.

    I don't buy the argument that you should plan your life now with the expectation that you're eventually going to be decrepit and dependant on others. That never happened to my mother who lived on her own and drove her car right up to the day she suddenly died at age 87. I had begged her many times to move in with us, but her independance was very precious to her. Ironically, I think she grew closer to all of her children because she remained her own person. She had become a widow at age 68 and I suspect her last two decades of life were maybe her happiest.

    If you are like most wives and mothers, you have spent your life pleasing others. Now it's time to please yourself.

    Good luck and enjoy all the blessings you are lucky enough to have!

  • 19 years ago

    I agree with what feedingfrenzy is saying to some degree, but since you've already closed on the IL house, you might as well live there for a while to see if you like it.

    It is unfortunate that you rushed into the new home purchase, but the upside is that you have children that are eager for you to be near them and it sounds like you like the house in IL.

    I think you should talk to a grief counselor, concentrate on getting through a difficult time of year, feel confident it's going to get better, and get the rest of your stuff out of the KY house. Why are you even there? It doesn't sound like you like it there at all. Can one of your kids handle the sale details?

    Take a breather and next year you can re-evaluate where you really want to be. Also, don't get caught up in worrying about expenses that are small in the grand scheme of things. A few months worth of taxes and yard care is nothing compared to realtor commissions.

  • 19 years ago

    I disagree with feedingfrenzy. I am older and we planned very carefully when we searched for a home after we sold the farm. We knew that a one story, low maintenance yard and close proximity to grocery stores etc was going to matter when we were more limited in what we could do.

    I would sell the KY house and move to be closer to my family. In some ways doing so is so limiting. I would like to live anywhere but here. But family is very important to us so we need to be by them. And we will definitely need them as time goes on.
    But I also agree that you belong to yourself and should do what is right for you.

  • 19 years ago

    Hmapton

    Just so you know, I'm 61 and this is a topic I think abou quite a bit.

    While I agree with your 1st paragraph, I definitely do not agree with living near your family when you'd really rather live somewhere else. I'm afraid I know a few too many older people who did just that, only to find that some or all of the family moved somewhere completely different. So they're stuck in a place they really don't care for, with no family nearby.

    What I see happening in this case is that the family has pressured the OP to move nearer them, even finding the "perfect" home for her to buy. While that's flattering, I don't think the children realize that they're maybe not being quite fair to Mom, especially when she's been so recently widowed. They should trust her to make a decision that's best for her. If that means living near them, great. But it should be after she's given it a lot of thought.

    Also, don't forget that there's nothing that says one can't experience a new part or the country for some years, and THEN move closer to the kids in extreme old age.