Software
Houzz Logo Print
jamesbodell

Redo support beam in crawlspace

19 years ago

Hello all, I am looking for help on how I can easily replace the load carrying beam in my house.

I have an old story and half barn with several additions built off it. This section of the house sits on a rubble foundation. It 18x25. The floor is old timbers that are 3x8 nominal spaced at 18" on center. The subfloor is roughly the same material. The sub floor is THICK, you can barely see a floor junction box from the basement!

The 18' span is supported in the middle by rocks and concrete block balanced on rocks with concrete thrown in. About every 3rd floor joist spans the entire 18 feet with no mid span support.

A few of the joists are rotten. They have been sistered with newer lumber, and in many cases the sistered boards does not span the full 9 feet!

So, I want to solve these problems. I am addressing the source of the rot with a sump and plastic on the floor. But I also want to fix the joists that are rotten. I figured the best way to do this is to create a new beam to support the joists mid span then replace the rotten and sistered joists with new ones that span the sill to the beam. Then I will most likely blow icynene into the joist cavities. This room is extremely drafty!

What I was orginally going to do was put a temporary beam next to the rock support, remove the rocks, and put a new beam in the center span. My plan was to use a triple 2x10 with jackscrews every 8 feet. They would rest on ledge.

However, since it is a crawl space and it does not have to be pretty, I am now considering splitting the 18' span into 3rds, and placing two beams 6 feet in from either side, again supported every 8 feet. I was thinking to use a built up beam made of double wood I beams. I have extras from a recent addition. I believe these are 10" I beams. Then I can just leave the rock center "support" alone.

I guess my question is, will the doubled up I beams with 8' supports be adequate? Can't be any worse than it is now! Would anyone be concerned about bugs living in the space created between the webbing of the I beams? Would regular dimensioanl lumber be better? Would this stuff rot and fail faster than regular lumber if I fail to keep the crawlspace adequately moisture free?

TIA

Comments (4)

  • 19 years ago

    Take a deep breath and set your resolve. Now tear out ALL the existing floor and joists and dig and install concrete footers use a span of no more than 10ft use extra heavy new lumber and put her back together. The little woman would probably appreciate a nice Quercus ruba floor on there now git at it and giterdun.

  • 19 years ago

    I thought about ripping the floors out, but that won't work, nor is necessary. Since I live on ledge, and I know is about 2-3 feet below the dirt in the crawlspace, I am planning to dig holes either put the posts on ledge or fill the holes with concrete as a footer.

    I really jsut want to be sure the double I beams will be sufficient.

  • 19 years ago

    If the joists are rotten, how do you know the flooring isn't? I know it's more work, but if you were to rip out the floor, it would be so much easier for you to work, I assume the crawlspace is fairly cramped.....I can think of nothing better than being able to stand up to work.

    In order to prevent moisture creeping up into new joists, you need suitable damproof course between the piers and the joists/bearers, but before you totally seal the underneath, shouldn't you ascertain where the moisture comes from?

    Presumably you're in a cold climate, and I know that dictates different construction methods, but I used to live in a warm, moist climate, (Australia) and the big priority was to VENTILATE sub-floor areas, to keep them dry.

  • 19 years ago

    I know the sub floors are sound from the screw driver test. Just jabed it around and looked for soft spots. The finished floors are 100+ years old and if I pick them up, they may never go down again. They are a beautiful pumpkin color now.

    The foundation is lose rubble, ventilation is not my problem! After I fix the supports, I will put plastic on the floor or a comercial product that won't puncture as easily. I also am putting in a sump pump.

    When all done, I will have icynene blown in between the joists.