Software
Houzz Logo Print
ld14051

are we being scamed?(fascia board problem)

19 years ago

Hired a guy out of local penny saver to clean gutters-55.00. He says the gutters are too level. So he comes back to fix that-125.00. Now he says he can't nail gutters into fascia properly because fascia board is rotten. Says another 850.oo to replace about 30 feet of fascia board.

We did have a problem with water overflowing but when the gutters were cleaned out the problem seemed solved.So does all this seem reasonable. 850.00 seems an awful lot to replace the fascia. Scam? The house is almost 15 years old and we had a new roof on 2 years ago. no mention of rotting boards then.

Comments (4)

  • 19 years ago

    Roofers don't usually do the fascia or even look at them. We just replaced ours (along with a new roof) and yes, they are very costly because you are getting a large, long and hopefully straight piece of lumber. Plus you are paying for this guy's labour. The angle thing sounds right too. Don't ya hate how quickly the house eats your money?? Personally, I'd say to do it yourself, if you can. THere is alot of help on the internet as well as from stores (although I'd stay away from Home Depot's advice...they have given us alot of wrong info at the store we frequent).

  • 19 years ago

    the gutters need a gap from the fascia if the origial installer didn't gap the gutters enough and angle them correctly the the overflow got to the fascia and rotted it out as for $850.00 get another estimate for replacing fascia

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the responses. Unfortunately, DH can't work on ladders or roofs-huge fear of heights. And as I was typing my original post, he sign a contract with the repairman. He'll be here in a few hours(yes, on a Sunday). Maybe that's why it's so expensive.

  • 19 years ago

    "the gutters need a gap from the fascia"

    K type box gutters are mounted directly on the fascia.
    The front of the gutter is lower than the back so overflow goes over the front before it can go over the back.

    A drip edge should be present to prevent water from running back up the shingle edge and getting on the fascia.

    The other problem is that no one removes the gutters and paints the fascia until the rot has already occurred.
    Even paint behind the gutter eventually fails.

    You do not need a single piece of wood for the fascia, though the fewer the pieces the better.
    Joints should NOT be scarfed, but butted.
    I treat the end of every piece with Minwax wood hardener before priming an painting. End grain is like a collection of straws that will suck up moisture. The filler impregnates the wood and fills the straws.
    I also will not use the 'pre-primed' exterior trim.
    The primer is not a very high grade.

    The screw in type gutter spikes are much better than the old nail type.
    For copper gutters I use brass thread inserts in the fascia and thread the spikes 1/4-20