Software
Houzz Logo Print
ridingagain

repainting exterior trim question

21 years ago

I wanted to replace some exterior trim that has warped and I'll also go around the house and recaulk, set nail pops and repaint trim. Siding is beige and trim is gray. I noticed that the sides of the trim are beige (same as siding) and only the fronts of the trim are gray. Is this how it should be or should the entire trim piece the same color (grey)? Just wondering if this is another example of my builder cutting corners.

Comments (6)

  • 21 years ago

    Sounds like a painter cutting corners. However, how long has it been ---and you never noticed? Takes much more time and money to paint the edges---and you had until now never seen the difference.

    Do it the way you wish. (Happy smilie here.)

  • 21 years ago

    agree, its been that way for 7 years and never bothered me too much. Although the warping is driving me nuts so I want to fix that. If I have to go thru the hassle of priming, caulking, etc, I might as well paint the edges.

    When I pull off the old trim pieces, should I caulk in the existing nail holes before I put up the new piece?

    thanks for the help!

  • 21 years ago

    Paint the edges to get more depth.

    I have a customer who ordered me to paint the edges of the door and window casings in her home the same color as the walls. It doesn't look bad. Besides, the customer is ALWAYS respected for their options.

    It's actually more difficult to paint the edges the same color as the field. Try keeping that paint from coming around the front on a colonial, beaded trim board casing takes time and patience. Patience I have; time is money.

    Michael

  • 21 years ago

    I never thought of caulking nail holes that would be covered with new trim---but I don't think it is a bad idea---just a bit----um------intense.

    If you are finishing the trim before installing----paint all four sides. That will limit future warping/twisting. The only reason it was not done that way on the house was because it was probably painted in place---and more time consuming to do the edge that way.

  • 21 years ago

    thanks guys. A couple more questions:

    1) My siding has simulated wood grain (some texture) and the trim is rough cut. Some of the trim looks a little shaggy/splintery. I was going to hit the trim with a hand sander to smooth it out a bit and replace the warped pieces with pieces that are a little smoother than what I currently have. Bad idea, is trim usually rough?

    2) My trim is 5 1/2" wide. Seems pretty wide to me, but I have some arched windows that will prevent me from going to a smaller trim there. I assume it would look funny having wider trim on some windows and smaller trim on others. Does 5 1/2 wide trim seem overly wide for 2 story house? I'll likely just leave the trim width as is, I'm not sure I want to put more money into replacing all trim pieces and I don't have the creativity to figure out how to deal with the arches.

    thanks

  • 21 years ago

    If you have wood siding, the siding probably butts against the wood trim. If you reduce the width of the trim, the gap between the siding and trim will be too much for caulking.

    If you have aluminum or vinyl siding, then the J-Channel will be too far away from the smaller trim to be effective in water prevention.

    I would replace the warped or rotted trim with a composite trim or Tech Trim in the same size.

    Michael