Software
Houzz Logo Print
northcarolina_gw

Probably naive question - do we need an architect/designer?

15 years ago

Please excuse the naivete of this question; I've never remodeled a kitchen before --

As I mentioned in my earlier post about layout, we have decided not to commit too much of our savings to our kitchen, so our budget will be pretty tight. I am not looking for high-end finishes and we are willing to do a lot of the work ourselves (or with our handyman's help), and I'd like to reuse some of our cabs if possible, so I hope those things will help lower costs.

We had a residential designer come out yesterday to have a look and give us an estimate on drawing up plans. We have gotten great layout advice from this forum, but our old-ish house has some quirks and also will need electrical updates etc so I thought it might be wise to call in local help. This designer was recommended by the structural engineer who looked at our floors and also has pages of wonderful ratings on Angie's List. Here is my question. His quote for plans/elevation drawings etc was entirely reasonable in my opinion but is still a pretty good chunk of change considering the size of our overall budget. (It's not quite but almost 10%.) Given that we will not be moving doors/walls but will probably relocate some appliances and will certainly need to bring the electrical up to code, is it the experience of most of you that this is a good way to spend part of our budget? Or would we be just as well off coming up with a plan ourselves or with a big box KD (which might not be very fair since I wouldn't want to buy a new set of cabs)?

I realize this may not be an answerable question (we all have different houses, different budgets, and different expectations) but I would like your opinions on whether professional elevations/measurements/lighting plans etc are generally a worthwhile investment even for a semi-DIY project. Meaning, I am frugal and like to cut costs, but I don't want to cut in the wrong place.

Thanks!

Comments (13)

  • 15 years ago

    In my area, if you are doing that type of electrical work, you are going to need a stamped plan to give the county for a permit. I would say that you might want to check on that first, to know how you might need to proceed.

  • 15 years ago

    We're in much the same boat as you, tight budget and mostly a DIY project. We are tearing down one wall, moving plumbing, and adding electrical so it's somewhat involved. We realized that the first thing we were going to need was a layout and then a plan.

    We looked into getting a designer to come up with a new layout and plan and got quotes of anywhere from $2,500 to $5,000. Since I wasn't convinced that I would even like what they came up with, I paid $165 for Home Architectural Designer 9.0 and worked with it until a we got a good layout. Version 9 is not the most current version now, but still gets the job done and it's available for under $100 at Amazon right now. I was able to see every imaginable layout this way. It did take some time to get to just the right layout for us, but the time spent was worth it. It was fun to see the 3-dimensional views, the walkthroughs and so on. It is pretty easy to use and really shows how things will look. You can do one room or the whole house.

    We took printouts to the County who was more than happy to use them for issuing permits. We didn't need elevation printouts, just floor plans, although the program will print elevations as well. As far as the electrical, we'll have an electrician who will get the permit through the state.

    I agree with the advice above, go to your county and see what they will require and go from there.

    I've added a link to a online video of this product if you would like to see how it works.
    Click on the Home Designer Overview.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Home Designer (Architectural) Demo

  • 15 years ago

    You can do the project you describe without a professional designer since you already know what you want. You can get a permit with a hand drawn sketch or simple computer drawing.

    In our area a licensed electrician can get the permit with a hand drawn sketch or even just a written description such as "rewire kitchen" on the application.

    I recommend you try your own drawings and see how it goes. You can also post them here for help. If you find it doesn't work for you then you could go to a designer.

  • 15 years ago

    The process of doing the drawings yourself is a worthwhile endeavor even if you eventually engage a professional. When you do the drawings you become intimately familiar with all the pinch points and it will help you work through exactly what you want and help you decide where you are willing to make trade offs. I learned a great deal doing this with just basic graph paper and pencil, and a big eraser!

  • 15 years ago

    Here's a second vote for the Home Designer software. It is super easy to use once you get the hang of it. After starting down the path with a design/build company, we realized we had some design ideas as well. We did finally hire an architect to review our design and do plans for the city, important since we were adding on as well, but the design is ours. This site is great too! Many people have posted their plans here and received terrific feedback.

  • 15 years ago

    Well, it hadn't occurred to me that we might need stamped drawings for the permit, so I called the permit office and it turns out that we don't -- but thanks for the heads up, senator13, now I know where our permit office is [grin] and they told me the other things I'd need when it's time to start. Athomesewing, if we'd gotten estimates like yours we wouldn't be able to hire the designer either; it would eat up too much of the budget. The estimate he gave us yesterday was nowhere near that. From what he described, he would give us a few layouts to think about and tweak things to suit us before he produced the final drawings. (I presume this is what they all do?) What I don't know myself are things like where to put the lights and electrical outlets (and how many) and how to fit X amount of stuff into X-1 amount of space and how to work around doorways (but without spending any $ to move them, of course) and whether what I want can actually be done with the amount we are willing to spend. (He thought we would be cutting it close.) So... these are all things for me to think about, and I'll have a look at the Home Designer software too. Thanks all!

  • 15 years ago

    If you are not changing anything that is structural, you don't need an architect or structural engineer. All you need is a competent Kitchen Designer. And, don't be afraid to move doors or windows. It's not that involved or expensive, especially if you can bring some DIY to the table to stretch your budget further. You just need to install the right size header for the opening and redo the exterior cladding to match and redo the interior drywall. It's a day's work and maybe around 1K if you have to pay labor for it to be done.

  • 15 years ago

    Yeah, you're right, live_wire, I will try not to let my hatred of drywall dust get in the way of a functional kitchen. (ha.) When I was working on layouts myself I couldn't get things to work quite like I wanted even with a doorway move, but I told the designer that if he worked up layouts for us, a doorway shift would be OK if it would fit in the budget. The problem I ran into was that a single doorway shift wouldn't have been enough; I found myself moving two of them and also ripping down what was originally an exterior wall (and it still wasn't quite right). So everything is theoretically on the table (to a point), but the more I play with it, the more I think we'll be able to get a livable layout without doing that. The designer might be able to finagle things better than I could; I don't know. I have several layout suggestions in my other thread to contemplate as well. The fresh eyes are very helpful.

  • 15 years ago

    If you are doing extensive rewiring of the kitchen you do need a licensed electrician with a permit for the electrical work. The city inspector will be an important check and ensure the work is up to code.

  • 15 years ago

    Third vote for the home designer software. We had an architect give us a bid and it was outrageous--apparently architects usually bid in terms of a percentage of the total budget, but our $25k-$30k budget was too small for his usual approach (!) so he quoted us a flat fee of (COUGH COUGH COUGH) $10 to $15k. Um! No!! We ended up buying a new iMac and the Home Designer software, and we could've bought another four or five iMacs for what this architect wanted. And he wasn't a big firm, just a well-respected, established local architect who specializes in remodeling old homes in a way that looks appropriate to their original style.

    He personally would not bid for just drawing up plans and letting us take it from there--he liked to be more involved, help choose contractors etc.--but my understanding is that the architects who would just give us plans would still want at least $3000 or more for that, which, again, is a lot more than our iMac + Home Design software. I ended up doing a ton of different plans with the software, posting them and getting feedback here, and now we have a plan we like a lot. No architect OR kitchen designer required.

    That being said, you will need to hire an electrician to get your wiring designed and implemented properly--even if you are very handy and capable of doing it yourself, that would probably void your homeowner's insurance, so if there were ever an electrical fire you would be totally screwed. (I say "probably"--check with your insurance company to be sure.) It also can mess with resale value.

    The only way I can think of to get the electrical system designed properly without hiring an electrician to do the design, assuming you can do this without voiding your insurance, is to get the version of the Chief Architect Home Design software that lets you (1) design the electrical system in detail AND (2) check your design against national codes. As you can see from this matrix (in the link), that means you have to get the "Pro" version.

    By the way, be sure you read what the Chief Architect website says about the computer requirements to run the software. Very few laptops have fast enough processors to do the 3D rendering, and ours certainly didn't, so since our only desktop was literally like ten years old we ended up having to get a new computer to use this software. But still, I'd rather spend $2200 on a fantastic 27" iMac and this software, and be able to create infinite kitchen plans and tweak them as much as I need to, and have this great computer for years, than spend $3000-$5000-$10,000-whatever to get an architect to give me one or two kitchen plans. And if you use PCs rather than Macs, your computer expense will probably be smaller than ours was anyway.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Chief Architect Home Designer product comparison

  • 15 years ago

    Yes, the fellow at the permit office told me about that (will need a licensed plumber and plumbing permit as well). That's no trouble -- we have found some scary "creative" wiring done by previous homeowners, so I am leery of un-inspected electrical work. Thanks for the warning!

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks, ideagirl2, I typed my last response before I saw your post. Our handyman can do electrical work, but I was planning to hire a licensed electrician anyway -- that is one of the places I didn't want to cut costs. So if I decide not to hire the designer, it sounds as though we will be covered at least as far as the electrical work is concerned.

    I'll look into the software too, it sounds cool! Our computer is also ancient so thanks for the recommendation. [grin]

    From what you all are saying, it sounds as though the designer I found is a real bargain... it turns out he has done work for our neighbors (not kitchen), so I'll ask them how they liked working with him.

  • 15 years ago

    I don't know if your designer's a bargain--a designer isn't an architect. Whole different ball game there. And we never priced out a kitchen designer; our thought was basically, either an architect will help us or we can design this ourselves, using knowledge gained from this website and kitchen books and our own good taste. If you don't feel up to designing your own kitchen (with an assist from this website), then sure, go for a kitchen designer. Some people know what they like when they see it but don't have a knack for coming up with ideas or combining colors and surfaces--if that's you, then a good designer can certainly help.

    But KDs are kind of a crapshoot. And I have certainly never seen a thread on this forum where someone posted a design from their KD and people answered, "Wow, that's amazing, I really can't improve on it--you can tell that was done by a design professional!" Whereas I've seen lots of threads where people here improved on the KD's design, and also threads where people's responses basically pointed out that the KD must have been on crack when he or she came up with that ridiculous layout. In other words, I'm really not sure what you get from the average kitchen designer that you can't do yourself with a combination of layout software and advice from this forum. Definitely ask your friends/neighbors who used a designer what their experience was and what the designer brought to the table. A good designer is a great thing, but paying for a so-so designer would just be a waste of money.