Software
Houzz Logo Print
pedimom

What's Cheaper? Drawers or Pullouts

18 years ago

I am wondering if anyone can tell me if they know if Drawers or Pullouts are more expensive. I have just gotten a very high cabinet quote and am wondering if changing from drawers to pullouts will make a big difference.

Comments (11)

  • 18 years ago

    Whatever the difference, drawers will pay you back each time you use them. Try to find another way to save $$.

  • 18 years ago

    I think that would depend on how you specified your drawers. Do they have soft close/full extension? Full wood / dovetail joints? At one of the places I went to upgrading from their bottom basement drawer to their top of the line was $250 a drawer. However, I would think that pullouts would have similar "upgrading" problems.

    That having been said, I would try getting another quote before changing your design. The differences between quotes we got dwarfed what would have been spent downgrading drawers. Quotes I got from custom cabinet makers differed by as much as $15000 for the same work. That's a lot of drawers.

  • 18 years ago

    Pedimom,

    How many different places have you received quotes from? It definitely pays to shop around. I mystery shop and once did a job where I had to get quotes from 7 outlets of the same chain for the exact same job. I kid you not, every single quote was different and the high one was exactly double the low one!!!

    So, having said that, fustian is also right, there are many different 'levels' of drawers from metal metaboxes (which many people like) to plywood stapled, to solid wood dove-tailed construction. Then the slides can vary from regular, to full-extension, to soft-close...

    I personally love the look of solid wood dove-tailed joints, though many people say there is no structural advantage, my engineer DH disagrees, thinks dove-tailed makes a stronger joint and as I don't like the look of staples, we actually agree on this one. I can concede that metal boxes give you more inside room, so if you're OK with the look, that is something you could consider.

    I would definitely NOT compromise on full-extension, whether it is for a drawer or a pull-out. Soft-close is nice, but not a deal-breaker for me.

    ONe thing I discovered with my base cabinets, is that the drawers are significantly shorter than the cabinet, so some long items will not fit. I like to keep a serving tray with placemats and napkins ready for the deck, and it won't fit in a drawer, so I have one base cabinet with bottom pull-outs and adjustable shelves to fit those odd-sized items. My pantry has pullout shelves (or will, when the @#$! carpenter delivers them) that are adjustable. For me, this is more practical than fixed drawers.

  • 18 years ago

    For our Omega Dynasty/Embassy cabinets, we have a:

    • 27" 3-drawer Drawer Base: $525.68

    • 27" cabinet w/a top drawer and 2 pull out shelves: $665.79

    Both have full extension, soft-close (drawers and/or pullout shelves)

    So, in our case the pullout shelves were more expensive!

  • 18 years ago

    Get the drawers or at least as many as you can. They are the holy grail and I was too change averse to go all-drawers-on-bottom ----> should have, and regret every time I use the dang pull outs.

    I love drawers.

  • 18 years ago

    I should mention the construction details:

    • Drawer Construction: Solid Wood Dovetailed Drawers......Drawer fronts solid hardwood (MDF if opaque) and attached to 5/8" hardwood drawer box w/dovetailed joints at all 4 corners......All drawers sealed & top coated for a find furniture look

    • Roll-Out Trays (ROTS) Construction: Both Dynasty & Custom feature dovetailed, adjustable roll-out trays w/full extension undermount glides w/soft closing mechanism

    • Glides (Drawers & ROTS): Standard glide for both Dynasty & Custom is fully concealed, full extension undermount glides w/soft closing mechanism. Self-closing glide features smooth & quiet operation & carries a 100 lb. weight capacity.

  • 18 years ago

    The pull outs are typically cheaper. We have both and have to admit there are times I wish we had gone with more drawers.

  • 18 years ago

    thank you all so much for the advice. I do like drawers but can see how pullouts would be helpful for items too tall to maneuver into a drawer. I know what u want for certain items in the kitchen but thought if this was a big savings I could compromise. Like I don't understand why I would save $150 per unit if I went 24" depth instead of 18" paying more for less doesn't make sense. I've been to 2 places with qoutes. Will go to as many more that I need to to get over the price shock!!! Thanks.

  • 18 years ago

    Try to check out the Ikea cabinets. They have wonderful drawers with the best hardware available. You can save a bundle on your cabinetry cost and not compromise on function. They have limited cabinet front styles, but maybe you'll find one that's right for you, or you can have custom fronts made, and it will still be MUCH less expensive than Kraftmaid, Merrillat, etc. You do not have to DIY to do Ikea-- installers are available.

  • 18 years ago

    zelmar, you mentioned that your pull-outs are adjustable. Do you mean that you can unscrew the mounting hardware and remount the pull-out drawer either higher or lower? If that's the only way an "adjustment" can be made, I have to wonder whether anyone actually goes to the trouble to do that after the cabinets have been installed.

    Bob

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio