Since your light is rectangular, I like the rectangular mirror. If your light had rounded edges, I would have gone with something more rounded for the mirror. Why can't you take a picture?

Somebody (read husband!) lost the battery charger and hasn't gotten a new one. He said he did, it hasn't come, he's checking on it.......... Trust me, the rectangular doesn't fit (the rounded light covers stand out more than the flat part holding it on). I'd rather have oval, arched, or round. I think. but should it be framed, flat, beveled....

Whew! That took long enough. Ok. Here are the pictures. and now that I am looking at it, what it lacks is heft. The other wrought iron is much thicker. What is up is definitely temporary. So what will look good there?

Here is a link that might be useful: final bathroom slide show

I don't think you need to go curly. How about a heft frame in a dark wood?

That sounds good. What shape, or other specifics?