Software
Houzz Logo Print
gsciencechick

Yet another 'help me pick a rug' thread

15 years ago

Hi, everyone, I think we've got the basic elements in place. Now we need a new area rug, and then a runner yet! I'll start with the area rug. Our walls are SW Halcyon Green. I'm anticipating a brown background, but I'm open to other colors. THANKS IN ADVANCE!

New vintage sofa (green with yellow/gold threads)

Re-upholstered channel back chair:

New slipcover for recliner (yes, I'd like a new one that is more aesthetic, but this on is very solid and comfortable for DH, so it's not a huge priority). Also, I think MIL is looking for vintage lamps for us for Christmas, so you can ignore the shiny brass lamp.

My favorite rug, Shaw Floors HGTV Mod Links. It is available in dark brown vs. the black here. However, it is $500 and not wool. All the other rugs posted are $250 or less.

Home Decorators rug (wool)

Overstock Circles rug (wool, currently sold out)

Overstock geometric, wool

Overstock Trellis rug, wool

Ebay rug, polyproplyene

Rite Rugs, shown in ad but does not seem to be available on site:

Spello Arabesque rug, available in black or even orange, synthetic

Comments (12)

  • 15 years ago

    Can you make a "board" that groups your elements and can be seen with each rug choice? It is hard to scroll back and forth....
    My first thought is with the channel back chair, you need to be careful dealing with a busy pattern in the rug. I think the Overstock circles rugs works in that regard or the HD rug. I also like the Spello rug, but that could be a little too bold...

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks. I have no clue how to do that, or I would!

    As much as I *love* the HGTV rug and that was my plan, I am leaning towards probably the first two. We planned on a solid brown sofa but now we have green, so all my plans changed. Here is a review from the HD site for the rug: "A perfect neutral for a room with a lot of design already---either "busy" designs on the furniture or, in my case, on the bedspread in the Master Bedroom. The under-stated "design" of the rug gives interest without conflict with other design elements in the room...."

  • 15 years ago

    For what I'm gathering of your space I think I prefer the coloring of the eBay rug but the simpler designs of the Overstock Geometric, Trellis, and HGTV rugs better. I read that you're thinking brown for the rug but my eye wants to see some of the other colors in your delightful room down there, too, like the green, damson, orange. Hmm, I guess if I had to pick I'd pick the Trellis.

    Can you post an overall pic of the room?

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks, rmkitchen, for the feedback. I'm not opposed to orange either. I was thinking of this rug for a runner in the paprika color, but maybe this color and style would work better for the room.

    I will try to get a photo of the whole room as is.

    Here is a link that might be useful: JCP rugs

  • 15 years ago

    Not the greatest, but you get the idea of layout.

  • 15 years ago

    This is rough... but it may help





  • 15 years ago

    Can't help you with the rug because I can't choose my own, but I love your vintage sofa and your orange chair!

  • 15 years ago

    THANK YOU!! Wow, I like them all, but I do tend to like the bolder colors better. Can you try adding the orange?

  • 15 years ago

    my favorite from what dianalo shows is the shaw mod links!!

  • 15 years ago

    OK, I have figured it out. Here it is with the orange. I also like the ModLinks. Of course, that's the most expensive one!

  • 15 years ago

    Wow -- my hat is off to you and dianalo for those great pics! It really makes a difference (to me) to see the whole room; it gives me a better idea how all your pieces relate to one another.

    So seeing your whole room I have to say I like a simpler design. The Trellis is still my fave for your room: it is v. simple but it has a bite to it so it's not boring. My second favorite is that orange -- thump thump went my heart. I'm a sucker for orange but I think it could really pull everything together in a harmonious way.

    Your Shaw rug is just too much, I'm afraid. Or it appears to be too much to me, and too much saying "look at me! I'm so exciting!" If you had all milquetoast furniture then yeah, maybe, but lucky you you do NOT -- you've got gorgeous, fun furniture. I'm a more-is-more kind of gal, so for my eye to steer away from more pattern really makes me listen.

    I also really like the Overstock Circles, but you wrote it's sold out. While that's kind of a bummer I'm still rooting for Trellis or Orange.

    You have done a beautiful job in there already. You should be proud of yourself!

    And thanks again to you and Diana for those pictures -- sooo helpful!

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks, RM, for the feedback! The Circles rug is sold out, but should be restocked. I signed up for an email notification so who knows, but I am leaning towards the bolder colors better.

    The ModLinks might have worked better had we gone with the chocolate brown sofa as in the picture. But, it does have black, brown, green, and ivory/tan, which can be ordered with any of those colors as a background. That way, there'd only be the orange chair with the pattern. Of course, we won the green vintage sofa at the estate auction, so that put everything up in the air again.

    Don't know if you've ever seen our kitchen, but here it is.It opens up to the LR. We're definitely not afraid of color!