Software
Houzz Logo Print
dilly_ny_gw

Does my house need shutters?

13 years ago

We recently redid the roof and siding on our home. We plan to do a new front door (same style, black).

Do you think my house needs, or would look better with shutters? I would get black, paneled style. Issue is that the upstairs windows don't have a lot of space in adjacent areas; however, shutters will fit.

I will post a picture of our house with new siding and roof (flower boxes, landscape and front walk are planned) as well as an older picture when we had louvered shutters. I appreciate your feedback.

Current photo:

Comments (19)

  • 13 years ago

    Older photo with shutters:

  • 13 years ago

    I think you definitely need shutters on the bottom . You might be able to leave them off the top windows---see how it looks when the bottoms are on---but if you do get them for the top I would get slimmer ones that don't crowd the space. Instead of black I would do charcoal and paint the front door the same color as your brick. I know you just had the siding done, but is there a way to perhaps re-route the gutters to the side of the house...I think it would give the front a cleaner look. Really a cute house and it will really look great with the other changes you have planned.

  • 13 years ago

    No!. Such a lovely house. :)

  • 13 years ago

    I think the lower shutters look especially nice with the window pediment, but agree I'd leave them off the upstairs windows. Your home is very pretty and looks good either way.

  • PRO
    13 years ago

    Not sure that shutters will fit upstair anymore, certainly not the same width as downstairs. Here is the image with Charcoal shutters. I think something dark would provide a bigger pop to the exterior.

  • 13 years ago

    Shutters would enhance the front windows on the first floor. I don't think they are necessary on the dormer windows. Black shutters would be very pretty. What color is the front door now?

  • 13 years ago

    Love the shutters on the lower level!

  • 13 years ago

    Another vote for shutters on the lower level, not on top. Keep the hinges and dogs, and use the same size shutter; they fit the window (look around, sometimes they are too tall or too skinny, and it just ain't right)

    Really cute house :)

  • 13 years ago

    For best looks, make sure the shutters are properly positioned!

    That means they should completely cover the vertical trim surrounding the windows. Their inner edges should be even with the inner edge of the window trim. Originally they would have been hinged along the inside edge of the window opening (and have folded INTO the window opening.)

    If you mount them outside the trim they look like elephant ears sticking out ffrom the window. Having them outside of the trim completely changes the proportions of your window openings, and not for the better. I think that if you mount the upper story ones correctly, you will have enough room for them.

    HTH

    L.

  • 13 years ago

    Thank you so much for your thoughts / votes.

    Beverly27, the visuals are great. Thanks so much for taking the time to do that.

    Joanieponie - unfortunately, because of the eves and roof design, I was unable to re-route the gutter after the siding was redone (and I didn't realize it beforehand). I was mad that my architect didn't bring this to my attention! There were originally 3 gutters coming down the front of the house, now I just have one, but still a thorn in my side.

    I'm not sure if it would look half done if I had shutters only on the lowers. Yes, measuring and getting the sizes right are important. Thanks for tips on that Liriodendron.

  • 13 years ago

    Liriodendron is right about the measurements. Look at your existing shutters, they are done as Liriodendron recommends, and copy them in your new paneled ones.

    Dilly, did you replace the windows upstairs? You did beef up the window trim and the dormer eave, which gives them a little more "weight", so they don't "need" the shutter for balance with the windows below.

  • 13 years ago

    Could you paint the gutter to match the brick?

  • 13 years ago

    Definitely shutters on the bottom; none on the top (it makes it too crowded). Paint the downspout part in front of the house the same color as the brick (as in your older photo). Then, when you install your new landscaping, send a vine up and around the downspout. And other plantings to help camouflage it.

  • 13 years ago

    I like the upstairs shutters, even if they are a scooch too big now with the new windows. Shutters that are plastered flat to the wall are a pet peeve of mind, and the fact that these are slightly ajar makes them clearly authentic and, I think, charming.

  • 13 years ago

    Slightly ajar shutters was due to the wind. Lol

  • 13 years ago

    Garden pea - my old gutters were copper and unfortunately diSappeared during my renovation. Anyway, The old gutters weren't painted, but I guess a now the white is jarring.

  • 13 years ago

    I wonder if the downspout would stand out less if it were painted a darker color like in your original photo. Yes to shutters on the lower windows.

  • 13 years ago

    No shutters.

  • 13 years ago

    I love the shutters, and love your house too! They don't build houses like that here in Dallas, but I wish they did!