Software
Houzz Logo Print
catlover5

Where to start re: Undercab lighting

14 years ago

This is a cross post from Lighting and I did not want to hijack krkahn's post . . I know nothing about undercabinet lighting hence I am a newbie too.

DH is currently wiring kitchen for our remodel. We have a 3 ganger that will control the ceiling fan that has a light in it, a light above sink if I so desire (kitchen is L shaped, sink in front of window, room is small, not sure how to get a light above sink with the close proximity of the ceiling fan which is a necessity as we don't have a/c) and undercab lighting which I would like to be able to dim.

The kitchen is L-shaped and I have a break in the cabs from the left of the sink and then beginning again on the right of the sink. Where do I go from here?

My cabs (which are not up yet) have a recessed space underneath but are not smooth, flat and even from cab to cab and the KD did order me a small simple under cab molding (this is a cottage white painted kitchen) to hide the lights.

Where should I research? What should I look for? This is the last item I have and probably should have addressed it sooner but I am wore out from this budget remodel!

Many thanks in advance.

Comments (27)

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I too was completely worn out by the time I had to look into this and confused too by UCL ! This thread will help. I have the wiring ready for "direct wire" so I am going with that and not low voltage. I am using Philips eW Powercore LED bars which are dimmable. They are not inexpensive but are considered very good for task lighting which is what I need. If you don't need/want dimmable you can use more inexpensive direct wired fluorescent bars.

    Here is a link that might be useful: UCL

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Eatrealfood, excellent! Thank you - this link is full of very useful info. Thank you.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My husband bought all our LED UCL from Environmental Lights. com. We got the bar type that are 12'' sections click together for whatever total length you want. While they are no cheap (we spent about $500 in total) we like them a lot and so much more than non-LED lights or ones that are pucks and make a very definitive blotch of light. These spread the light nicely. And my DH called the company with questions and they were very helpful. I would encourage you to do the same.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Environmental Lights - UC LED lights

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    NewSouthernBelle, thanks for the link. I am reading through it now . . . soft white v. neutral white, etc. This will be very helpful.

    Silly question all . . . does u/c lighting work with a wall switch or some sort of switch under the cabinet?

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We also chose those UCLs in belle's link. Not installed yet, but the light they put out looks swell. :) So no live experience, but I'll suggest this: scroll down in the link above to check out their test kits. We got one before biting the bullet on the whole project. The transformer is built into the plug. This will go in my desk area, and we got the little dimmer (not a traditional wall switch) which is also in the link above. We'll put that under the cabinet.

    The rest of the kitchen will have a honking big transformer and it's own standard wall switch with dimmer.

    And my husband also had a great experience with Environmental Lights' customer service. Very helpful and informative.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lighting is a challenge for most of us and a lighting consultant is often best placed to assist you especially if you have a basic lighting plan developed.

    I like to tackle lighting from the perspective of how much and what kinds of lighting before getting to the specific fixture. In a workspace like a kitchen, I like to have about 35 lumens per sq ft of general lighting - this is often provided by recessed can lighting but in older kitchens came from a surface mounted fixture. I am old so prefer soft warm white about 2700-3000 degrees K while younger people used to flourescent lighting may prefer something harsher and bluer on the order of 4000 degrees K.

    For specific workspaces like countertops I prefer an extra 30 lumens (minimum more is better) per sq ft of shadow free warm white lighting. And UC is probably the easiest (but not the only) way to get relatively shadow free lighting.

    There are many possibilities for UC lighting but I dislike those like halogen that emit heat. Also, for you folks in California or other places with restrictive laws, you must find low energy useage solutions. LEDs fit but are very expensive ... flourescents are not quite low energy and have am undeserved bad rep ... xenon is somewhere in between ... there are other options as well.

    UC lighting can be operated from a wall switch or from a switch at the fixture and as well can be dimmable with the proper dimmer. Generally speaking, most energy efficient UC lights run off low voltage and the stepdown from household current can be done at the fixture or at the switch. For new construction it is most flexible to run line voltage wiring to the fixture and buy fixtures with a stepdown driver installed ... conversely, for renovations that do not involve gutting the existing walls, a low voltage solution with switches at the fixture usually is more economical. There are a large number of suppliers of these fixtures ranging from light bars to LED strips to pucks ... you have a broad choice to meet any situation.

    Many folks like to combine mood lighting (lighting for ambience) with their UC lights and thus require a dimmer. My personal observation is that the ambience is hard to pull off this way ... it is often more effective to turn off the UC lights and dim the pot lights instead. If ambience or mood lighting is essential, I think it is best concealed in a soffit above the cabinetry and banked off the ceiling. A lighting planner is best able to help with amount of lighting (I like to provide about 10-15 lumens per dq ft greatly reduced by angling it off a reflective surface like the ceiling) and the style of fixture.

    Lastly, many folks will want some kind of accent lighting ... this is common in kitchens with glass cabinet doors or with display shelves. These spotlights similar to UC lights can be either line voltage or low voltage and switched on the wall or at the fixture - dimming is not normally needed.

    After seeing many plans for kitchens, I have the impression that if even a small fraction of the time spent on finding the perfect pendants was spent planning basic lighting, most kitchens would work better in final use.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Like fouramblues, we got ours from Environmental Lights. Great service, great prices and I LOVE my dimmable UCL.

    HTH

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hello,

    Ditto the posters above with regards to Environmental Lighting, we got the same lights as NSB and spent about the same amount of money. They are fantastic to work with and will help you through the entire buying process. We needed to do a return as well and had no issues. We love our dimmable LED lights!

    Elaine

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you all for sharing your choices with me.

    Dougald, this is very detailed and I appreciate your taking the time to post. My kitchen is very small, this is a budget remodel and I am afraid that I may have under prioritized this task. Thank you for taking time to post.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've got the direct-wire fluorescent undercabinet bar lights from Lowe's and they work very well -- just thought I'd mention them since you say this is a budget remodel (so was ours). There is no flickering and they are instant-on. They are cool white, and I found that I like that much better than the yellow "soft white" CFL's in our central fixture. I have no idea if age has anything to do with it; I'm in my 40's and the soft white makes my cabinets look sickly yellow. The undercab lights I have are not dimmable.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Utilitech undercabinet fluorescent lights

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    northcarolina, thanks for the link. I'll check them out as well . .is cool white "white" white? If so, I would prefer that myself especially since I have white cabs and may end up with keeping the butter yellow walls. I told my husband that I have discovered that people can spend over $1,000 on u/c lights . . . that's not in my budget nor something I want to do. It's a tiny kitchen for goodness sakes! Thank you.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Catlover, the fluorescents are white white bordering on, but not quite, blue-ish. We have 3 undercab lights, two can lights over windows, and one central ceiling fixture. When I saw how much better I liked the color of the fluorescents, I switched our can lights to "bright white" which is somewhere in between cool and soft (maybe 3500K? not sure) and I think I like those best. The color difference between the cool and the bright is really not enough to be a problem. Having soft white in our central ceiling fixture and cool in the undercabs is definitely not an attractive combination, though. ha! I haven't got around to changing the central bulbs yet. Soon.

    The fluorescents take T8 bulbs and they are easily replaced, so you don't have to use the color they come with as long as you can find T8's in the color you like.

    One last thing -- the bright white CFL's I put in the can lights are the ones that take a minute to warm up -- extremely annoying. Don't get that kind. lol. (Unfortunately I threw away the boxes.)

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We put in rigid LED strips which we bought on Ebay. They are not dimmable, but I find I didn't need them to be. They came with a separate transformer (2 strips per transformer, although you can gang up to 4 strips on one).

    We had the electrician put regular wire through the walls just below the cabinets, and wired them to switches in the backsplash, and outlets in the basement, which is where the transformers are plugged in.

    My husband installed the lights, and added tubing to cover the wires on the bottom of the cabinets.

    Here is a link that might be useful: LED rigid strip lights w/transformer

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    NC, thanks for the info.

    It seems like very little progress has been made in the last two weeks with the kitchen. It is very interesting how everyone does their lighting a little bit differently.

    iroll thank you for the link and info. I was only going to tackle this task when I was finished but it seems best to lay it out now and have a plan in place!

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Catlover, I just did a quick purchase of the LEDs linked below for a cabinet snafu. I am probably going to replace them with dimmable LEDs, but these were certainly a great deal, and easy to add without breaking the bank especially for a small kitchen. When I switch out I will move these to my bathroom or another location that could use some undercab lighting. However, they do not dim. The reason I chose them was because they are extremely low profile which I needed.

    Here is a link that might be useful: LOWES LED UCL bar

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks claybabe. Still undecided . . considered doing nothing but really want something. I could really use Candice Olson for a lighting plan here. There has been no change to the mess that is the kitchen for the last 3 weeks as DH has had some work priorities. . . I will check these out in the store and they may do the trick!

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have the uc lights which claybabe posted, from Lowes. They"ve been installed for 2 years and I absolutely love them. We had originally been wired for a hardwired install, but as I was gathering price options, I realized that I couldn't and wouldn't spend so much money, so we found these. The electrician adapted these for his hardwired install. We have never found the lighting to need dimming..they always seem to be just right...with the right price, too.

    Helene

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    That's good to know blubird. It's such a tiny kitchen, this is a cottage in a modest neighborhood, I really don't know how important dimmable is and the cost is a factor too. . . We have a ceiling fan with light that we don't want to get rid of because we don't have a/c but I am trying to squeeze a pendant over the sink in front of the window but in a tiny 8x9 room it may be too close together which then might put more emphasis on the u/c lighting! There will be a light over the stove in the vent hood or OTR mw depending on what I end up with. I think I am going to try these but the cabs are not even up yet! Thank you.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Could you put in a wall sconce, instead of a pendant? Might be more cottage-y. Here's one (I'd probably invert it, though).

    Here is a link that might be useful: Metallic Silver Indoor Wall Scone Light

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We are going with something like this. They are so low profile that you don't need anything to hide them. They are LED and they are dimable.

    Here is a link that might be useful: LED lights

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Iroll, I was thinking about a wall sconce but thought it might look too bathroomy. Maybe I have not found the right one yet.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Rejuvenation has reproduction lights, here are their sconces. I have their Umpqua in polished nickel over my own sink (I have a retro-ish, cottagey look kitchen).
    The finish would make a big difference in kitchen vs. bathroom look.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Rejuvention wall sconces

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Iroll, thanks for the link. These are so pretty. Of course, I like the most expensive one the best. On a side topic, do you have the Kohler Riverby sink? I am considering the 25 inch model but it was more expensive than I wanted to spend but it does have those cool accessories. I purchased the HD sIlgranit knock off but it doesn't fit in the cab without scooping, something I wanted to avoid along with another ss sink.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thought I responded before - we went with GMLARC light bars that are dimmable. 3000K - so not as soft as 2700 but DH likes the look!

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Oh! I just put those LED strips in my entertainment center. Love em! They have a transformer, but you can plug several into one transformer.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We went with a kitchler LED dimmable and love them.

  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We also used Kimberly tape lights above cabinet in our sun room and soon to be in cabinet (dimming version)