Software
Houzz Logo Print
angieszen

Farm sink advice

16 years ago

I love the look of the Shaw's farmhouse sink and had my heart set on it but my research pegs it as high maintenance and easily chipped. Oh, say it's not so!

What other options are out there if I want an apron front farmhouse style sink but not stainless or copper? Is there an enamel over cast iron in apron style? I don't want a sink I have to be dainty with...

Comments (13)

  • 16 years ago

    Franke / Villeroy and Boch makes one. That's what I have. No babying around here!

  • 16 years ago

    amac514 -- what did your research say about the Shaw's that made you feel you had to be "dainty" with it? You've got me a little worried -- my Shaw's is sitting here waiting to be built in.

  • 16 years ago

    two kitchen and bath places have told me that they recommend Shaw's sink over any farmhouse fireclay one....with the Shaws they have the least amount of complaints with them coming in a little bit uneven and with chipping.

  • 16 years ago

    My whitehaus foreclay has been installed since the end of February. No problems so far. If I were going to do it over, I MIGHT go with enamel over cast iron. I'm a bit of a klutz. And I've seen some cast iron models I like a lot.

  • 16 years ago

    My Belle Foret fireclay apron front sinks are holding up flawlessly. They were installed in October. They are much less expensive than most of the other options. I have a 30'' and 24''. I also have a enamel over cast iron apron front with drainboards on both sides. It is holding up well, but harder to keep up than the fireclay.

  • 16 years ago

    I have had two fireclay sinks--both Porcher London--and never felt like I needed to baby it.

    I would be more concerned about enamel over cast iron. Ever chip an enamel pot? I have. Ever chip a porcelain bath tub? I haven't. Despite dropping cans of Barbasol numerous times.

    If you can live without smashing your cast iron skillet on the apron of your sink in a psychotic rage, I think you should go for it. Otherwise, abstain. :)

  • 16 years ago

    Kohler "Dickinson" (single bowl) and Hawthorne (double) are porcelain over cast iron apron front.

    Like you I was planning a Shaw's, but now am leaning toward the Dickinson. (It is not ordered, and I reserve the right to change my mind at any time!)

    As mentioned there are many other apron fronts, some vitreous china, some a stronger fireclay, almost all stating to expect some variation in size +/- 2% due to manufacturing. Herbeau Creations, Porcher, Whitehaus, Belle Floret, Barclay, Bella Lavello, etc.

    I have read of people having water pooling at the bottom of their Shaw's fireclay sinks bc the bottom may not be perfectly flat (which would drive me crazy) and of chips. This worried me. When I saw other farmhouse sinks in person, the walls were not as thick and did not look at substantial as the Shaw's, which made me worry about chipping.

    I believe one way to compare them is by weight. For roughly a 30" size in these various sinks- the herbeau creations sink is 180 pounds, Shaw's 160 where the whitehaus is only 100. I'd imagine the heavier bowls to be more durable.

    Not to make your head spin, but there is also the matter of where the drain is located in the different models, drain in the center (like Kohler), off-set (like Shaw's), or nearly all the way to one side (like Porcher) depending on your preference/compatibility with faucet/disposal placement undercabinet etc.

    Hope that helps!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Kohler cast iron apron front

  • 16 years ago

    Forgot to mention another option I read about back in this thread.

    Mitrani Quartz

    I've never seen it in person so can't speak to the feel/durability, but might be something to consider

    Here is a link that might be useful: Previous thread on topic

  • 16 years ago

    One thing to know about the Kohler cast iron/enamel apron front sinks is that the enamel does not extend very far on the sides of the sink so it has to be installed very close to flush with the cabinets. I have seen the other apron front sinks extend further from the cabinets. A minor detail, but it was a bit of a surprise when my Kohler Hawthorne was installed. (also the drains are offset in the 2-bowl Hawthorne)

    Kohler:
    {{!gwi}}

    Franke (momand3kids_pa's kitchen, hope she doesn't mind!):
    {{!gwi}}

  • 16 years ago

    Just wanted to throw another option in - I purchased a Marvel Atlantic Ceramic sink from Vintage Tub & Bath and am happy with it. It was about 1/2 the cost of a comparable Shaw's and at the time I ordered it, it came with the drain, and a sink grid was included. (I would have never bought a grid, but I am becoming a believer - I really like it.)

    My sink is 18" x 30" x 10" deep (I believe there is a smaller one as well) and has an offset drain, but is finished on all four sides so you can have it installed with the drain on the left or the right.

    It hasn't been installed long - 2 weeks - but so far so good, and it looks great.

    I understand from trying to find a cut sheet on the sink that Marvel is a subsidiary of Aga.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Marvel Atlantic Ceramic Farmhouse Sink

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks everyone for the great advice and photos. I am going to have to do more research to figure out what to do ... I do love the fireclay look so I am happy to hear people have it and don't have lots of chipping. That is my preference but I think I have to look into the enamel as well - my husband would love to talk me out of the farm sink and into a stainless but I am trying to stand my ground! I want the farm sink look in a white or off white color.

  • 16 years ago

    corstone makes acrylic farm sink available in multitude of colors that is the same approx price as stainless. Acrylic is the most durable of the materials. You can google it to find the manufacturer website. We sell them for $600-$800

  • 16 years ago

    I'll throw in with my ongoing sink saga: ordered the Shaw's Original farm sink, a pretty thing but amazingly their idea of "biscuit" is very pink-to-pale-dead-salmon, and completely clashes with Aga cream enamel -- our old Aga range is the given around which all else must be planned, 'cause we love it. Very disappointing that the Shaw's people don't talk to the Aga people and coordinate their color chips! I don't want things to be "matchy matchy", but they should play nicely together. The Porcher London fireclay "biscuit" does not clash, but in the panicked eruption of researching 30" alternatives to the Shaw's sink, we had to reconsider a stainless steel apron front (also by Porcher), which the architect and the cabinetmaker thought seemed too slick and cold for our kitchen as it is shaping up, and then we had to consider a slab soapstone farm sink made from the Jucca soapstone that is forming our countertops. That has the appeal of restraining the materials in play -- but then the creamy enamel/ceramic already is in play in this kitchen and maybe the fireclay sink will balance the Aga on the other side of the room? And the architect and I both remember the stone sinks in our grandparents' houses as the "dirty" sink, for potting and washing dogs and fingerpaints -- is a pale, glossy fireclay sink more appetizing for food prep? Does that sound crazy??? Feel free to weigh in.

    To help you picture it, here's a list of the materials in use in this kitchen renovation for a 100-year-old house: board ceiling with fir "straps", cream ceramic tiles, stainless steel refrigerator and dishwasher front, vertical grain fir doors, windows and cabinets with Jucca soapstone countertops, one other, stainless undermount sink for clean-up, probably rubbed stainless hood over a cream Aga cooker with adjacent cream Module (the small conventional Aga), natural cork floor. The apron front sink will be installed under the middle window along a 25' long wall, opposite the Aga. While the materials are high-quality, the overall feeling of the kitchen should be cozy and warm and informal. We've waited ten years to do this renovation. Exciting.

    Have to make farm sink decision within the week!
    Lynn