Hi, I will have my Crystal cabinets in a couple of weeks. Crystal had a certain color of white I couldn't find anywhere else and I liked their green core. This probably doesn't help make your decision but I know others here have crystal. About 9 months ago there was a thread about which cabinets were at the top, middle and bottom in terms of quality. If I remember correctly Crystal was in the top 3. I will search for the thread
Katy

I have my Crystal Cabinets, but they are not installed. I peeked into some of the boxes and I am so happy!!
I live in Minnesota and visited the Crystal Factory where the cabinets are built. I saw some incredible cabinets!!
I really liked the fact they are truly custom. I designed my range hood with different mouldings and appliques. The motto at Crystal is if you can dream it, they can build it. I dont know how to post pics, but I will put attach a link so you can see some of what I have. The two door styles that I used are French Country square and Grandview. I didn't look at Brookhaven, only Woodmode so I can't offer an opinion on the Brookhaven.

Here is a link that might be useful:

Here's that old thread you might find interesting. I read it over several times when I was trying to decide on cabinets.

What sold me on Crystal was their finishing touch and it is totally custom. My cabinets are for a rustic cabin and Crystal was able to create a look that is not only unique but also high quality with a bit of green aspect (core). Everything I was looking for.
I hope this helps a little, next are the countertops, faucets, knobs, backsplash...
Katy

Here is a link that might be useful: Cabinet Comparison

I have seen Crystal Cabs in person. I love them. If I could
redo my kitchen with them I would. Someday when I build
a new kitchen Crystal Cabs will be my choice.

I have nothing against Brookhaven, I have just seen
Crystal in person, felt them and love their whites.

{{!gwi}}

Crstal also has a couple of other lines. They are called Keyline and Quest.
I agree with BoxerPups about the finishing. It is amazing.
When the box with my sink base was opened, I was thrilled.
Hopefully you will be able to check out doors you like from both the Brookhaven and Crystal dealer and compare them.
Also, I am pretty sure you can't order from Crystal without okaying a sample door(a door they make up especially for you in the wood and stain you request). Make sure you get one from Brookhaven if you decide to go with them.

Bumping for any new opinions on Crystal vs Brookhaven cabinets.