Software
Houzz Logo Print
annsch

Are 3 different countertop surfaces TOO much?

14 years ago

Hi everyone!! I need your expertise...

We are having caesarstone organic white countertop on island, caesarstone pebble on range wall and BM timid white cabinets. My question is there will be a small hutch with timid white cabinets as well and I am wondering about putting a walnut countertop on there. What do you think???

Here are the aforementioned elements:

Organic white:



Pebble:


Walnut:

Cabinet color (these are not my cabinets--i wish):

Paint color (BM Nimbus)and floor color (darker one):

Is that too much going on? It is a fairly small kitchen (12' x 17').

Comments (17)

  • 14 years ago

    What style of cabinets? Will your hutch cabinets be the same style and is the hutch in a separate spot? How fussy is your hardware and backsplash likely to be?

  • 14 years ago

    I think the wood will warm up the grays. Are you going to have a wood floor? I think it would look very nice :)

  • 14 years ago

    Cabinets are beaded inset. Like this(but mine will not have exposed hinges):

    Hutch will be same style. Will be separate from island and range wall. It is a very small space for hutch bout 25"wide and 18"deep and 7' tall.

    You can see the floor color in the foreground of last picture.

  • 14 years ago

    ALSO--hardware will be simple in chrome, backsplash 2X4 white tile in herringbone pattern.

  • 14 years ago

    HERE IS LAYOUT...HUTCH IS TO THE FAR RIGHT OFF RIGHT END OF ISLAND AGAINST WALL.

  • 14 years ago

    What do you want the hutch to look like, and what will be placed on it? Do you want it to look like a piece of furniture or will it clearly be a built in hutch?

  • 14 years ago

    palimpset--the microwave, toaster and possibly the coffeemaker will be on/in it. I would like the furniture effect yet with the same paint and style as other cabinets not sure if I can achieve that. I wanted glass uppers but that's not going to happen because of cost. :(

  • 14 years ago

    BUMP

  • 14 years ago

    My first choice would probably be to take the piece from the sink cut out and set it in the top of the hutch counter trimmed with a wood countertop border and edge., so it would be similar to an all wood, single color piece but with a more durable top.

  • 14 years ago

    Now there's an idea...

  • 14 years ago

    If the hutch was a "pretty" spot I think you'd be ok with wood. But the counter sounds like it will be a real working counter, now I personally wouldn't put wood on a working counter but lots of people do. In your situation I'd be afraid of mug ring marks, scorch marks, grease marks from butter, peanut butter, etc. But that is just me.

  • 14 years ago

    I have three. I think your plan sounds good. I also think it isn't so much about the number of counters as whether it seems sensible.

  • 14 years ago

    bump

  • 14 years ago

    With a microwave, toaster and coffee maker on a 25" x18" counter, I doubt you will even see the counter top. I am with blfenton - this spot will see heavy use so I would go with a workhorse counter. FWIW, I think a walnut top would look fine, I just wouldn't put it on this hutch.

    I have 3 counters in my kitchen .. White macabus quartzite, soapstone and concrete Caesarstone and they all work very well together.

  • 14 years ago

    Your island - is that a 1' overhang or a raised counter-ledge? Either way - but this would work really well if it was raised - what about putting the walnut on the overhang/raised counter (?) of the island. That would make the walnut look like it is a real part of the kitchen and be big enough to warm up the greys and to make a statement.

  • 14 years ago

    musko--pictures of your countertops? Not sure about the coffeemaker there because of the size of my coffeepot and the microwave will be in an above shelf.

  • 14 years ago

    blfenton--yes that is a 1' overhang but not raised. It is all one level. I really want to keep the island all the same surface.

    The DH and I have decided we will go with walnut on the hutch! YAY! One more decsion down...