Software
Houzz Logo Print
theanimala

Too many compromises with Inset Cabinets?

17 years ago

Well, it's too late for me, but I realized today how many compromises there are with inset cabinets. I love the look of them and when I found out they were in our budget I changed from full overlay to inset. During the final purchase I found out about the slightly less space, especially on the uppers, so I paid a surcharge to have them made 1 inch deeper. So far all good.

They they are installed (and they look great), and right after my Counter Depth FD fridge is installed, and guess what? More then the doors and handle stick out, part of the black on the side does. Oh well, so much for not having doors stick out. Then this week the warming drawer is installed, and again it sticks out further than expected, because of the flush doors. Today we had the countertop templated, and found out that the top will be 1/2" less deep all around, so that we don't have a crazy deep overhang, which would be the overhang we would have if we had done full overlay. So now I will have slightly less countertop space, in addition to my appliances showing.

I still love the look of an inset kitchen, and while no one issue is huge, overall they do add up. Just want to point it out to the people considering inset.

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    I just had a similar discussion with our KD. She didn't really emphasize ALL of the ways that other things would still stick out....refridge, drawer micro, etc, as you did. The countertop seems like the final straw.

    I am re-thinking this now. Thanks for bringing this up!! Do you have any photos?

  • 17 years ago

    I have inset cabs and no problems with any appliances sticking out, and a countertop overhang of 1". It seems odd that flush doors would result in less counter overhang rather than more, unless the cabinets are bigger? Do you still have time to have them re-template to add back your 1/2" before they cut the counters?

    I'm certainly no expert, but I don't think it's the inset doors that are the trouble; sounds more like your kitchen designer/contractor didn't measure correctly (or measured for overlay instead of inset, which is a real goof). You should request that the fridge enclosure be re-done; you can do a bunch of things like cover the black sides with adhesive stainless sheet, but there's no reason you should be required to live with their obvious mistake when it really bugs you.

    Best of luck!

  • 17 years ago

    Refrigerator: Even w/overlay cabinets many CD refrigerator carcasses/boxes stick out past the cabinets. My refrigerator, for example, sticks out 26", which is 2" past the 24" deep cabinets & approx 1/2" past the counter.

    What we did, based on the recommendation of my KD, is to use a finished end panel the same depth of the refrigerator carcass to cover the black sides. The doors & handles stick out another 4 or 5 inches, but that is normal since, for a standard-depth & CD refrigerator, the doors must stick out past the cabinets/counter/walls/filler directly adjacent to it to open fully.

    Another option, assuming it's possible to do it, is to pull the refrigerator out, open up the wall behind it, and recess the refrigerator into that wall. If it's an exterior wall or if it has plumbing in that wall you probably will not be able to do it; but, if it's just electrical you might be able to move the electrical.


    Countertop: I hope they templated so the countertop covers the WD. You don't want the WD to stick out past the countertop overhang. If not, stop them and have them come out & re-template. (This might also gain you your 1/2" back.)

  • 17 years ago

    I kind of agree with Peanut--the cabinet boxes should be the same if not deeper so appliances should not be poking out!

    I had to skip them not just because of the loss of usable space (small kitchen here) but because we are hard on things--we need overlay to hide all the dings we get when we put things away too quickly.

    I do love the look!

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with other - it was a design error - not the fault of inset cabs. I have inset cabs and don't have any of those problems. My counter is the normal size counter and the overhang is not "crazy deep" - it doesn't affect the use of the cabs at all. My CD fridge is recessed just like buehl's with side panels deep enough so that only the door edges show on the sides - they were ordered to that exact size. My MIL also has inset cabs and a warming drawer and microwave drawer and neither of those are sticking out past the cabs.

    You should at least insist your refrigerator and countertop get redone. May not be much to do about the warming drawer.

  • 17 years ago

    There is more planning with inset cabinets, but IMO it's worth it for the look.

  • 17 years ago

    My KD and fabricator both told me that the typical overhang for inset cabinets is less than for overlay cabinets -- 1/2 inch as opposed to 1 inch -- because the doors and drawers are flush.

    As far as the MW drawer, it doesn't jut out but if my drawers/door were overlay, a little bit less of the lip (or whatever you call it) would be visible from the side.