Software
Houzz Logo Print
jody1950

Stainless versus white appliances

18 years ago

This is my first post...so be patient..

We are building a house and I was wondering for those of you that have stainless appliances if you had it to do over again would you still buy the stainless or would you buy white. I would like to hear pros and cons.

Thanks

Comments (22)

  • 18 years ago

    I would get SS again. I like the look better. That said, I am very glad we paneled the DW (and I'd resisted doing so initially!)--one less appliance to muck up! We are two adults living here, so few finger/handprints to worry about, but the inevitable drips and smudges still appear.

    If they're really "bad," I'll wipe the fridge/range down when I see them, if not, I let it go 'til the end of the week when the kitchen is cleaned.

    For me, the trade-off (looks vs ability to stay clean) is worth it. For others, it might not be. You'll have to decide that one for yourself :-)

  • 18 years ago

    I have ss and like the little bit of sparkle it brings to my kitchen. Expect fingerprints though, especially if you have kids. It's not that big of a deal (to me at least) to wipe them away. Another con would be ss is more expensive than white.

    If you want less maintenance, go with a ss look-alike finish that repels fingerprints, white or panels.

    White would not work in my kitchen as I have an ivory island and china hutch, so I would still choose ss or perhaps panels if I could afford it.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the info so far... I forgot that I wanted to also if stainless steel dents easier and if you see the dent marks. I had notice that several stainless steel appliances in the stores are dented. Thanks again for your help

  • 18 years ago

    Jody--For sure, dents are going to be a lot more noticeable on SS (or any glossy/ reflective surface, for that matter) than on white textured steel. Just how easily it dents is going to depend on the gauge & quality of the material.

  • 18 years ago

    I was told by the appliance salesman that SS dents easier. I suppose it's softer. And yes, scratches seem to appear out of nowhere, especially on our range, but there are remedies to get rid of them which I haven't tried for fear of making them worse.

    As for SS over white, I would certainly get SS again. Ours is easy to clean, though it's only DH and myself here so ours doesn't get messy. I prefer SS because it's a medium natural color that goes with anything. White is too stark in a kitchen unless you have very light wood or white cabs, IMO. People tend to "notice" SS appliances (in a good way) and tend to comment on how nice they look. Not sure why since they've been around for a long time now.

  • 18 years ago

    I have all white also, but love the stainless look. If I were starting all over, I would probably get stainless. The white is still classic though. I have to change out my refrig. and am going through the same thing!

  • 18 years ago

    Will stainless go out of style? Will they make a kitchen look dated (2000s) in 10 years or so? I am wondering about stainless vs. white in my remodel. I currently have old (but working!) bisque appliances that blend well with my yellow painted cabinets. If I go with white cabs I might get white appliances. If I go with soft yellow cabs again (my favorite thing about my current kitchen) with soapstone, maybe stainless would look better?

    I do think stainless looks better with darker wood cabinets.

    What kind of cabinet are you planning? What cabinets?

  • 18 years ago

    My appliances are white because of the age/style of my house (c. 100 yrs, sort of cottage-y)

    It was re-doing my kitchen that finally taught me to work WITH the house; to put your stamp on the house's own nature. This house just screamed white appliances, and I happen to love them. Although I do love the sleek stainless look as well. And the white are SO easy to keep clean - just another bonus.

    An aside - I really dislike the 'textured, mottled' white (or black) appliances - the smooth skin looks much nicer, IMHO, & of course is easier to clean.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the replays so far. Our cabinets are going to be a light cherry. also trying to decide on ceramic or hardwood floor . any thoughts

  • 18 years ago

    Personal taste here - I would never put ceramic in a kitchen, because it's just too hard! Hard on the body, cold to the touch, & anything breakable shatters on contact.

    I have cork, & love it! Hardwood elsewhere in the house - love that too :)

  • 18 years ago

    Where can you get white appliances that are smooth, rather than textured? I haven't been able to find an online way to search for "smooth white appliances"! My cabinets will be white, but I was going to get stainless because I, too, dislike the textured white/black.

  • 18 years ago

    FWIW, our cabs are light cherry, we have SS appliances, and a natural white oak floor and they look great together (IMHO!).

  • 18 years ago

    I have a mix of stainless and white. The white appliance I like best is my white range. It's a white Dacor, but a think Dacor no longer makes a white range--too bad, cause it's a professional-strength range, but in white. The range is sooo EASY to clean! No matter how messy/greasy the meal, I just spray the range with a little Formula409, wipe, finished. I don't have to worry about scratches, or "wiping with the grain", fingerprints, special stainless steel cleaners, nothing. The hood over my range is stainless steel, and I really like the looks of the combination. But the hood can be a trial to keep streak-free, and I DO have to worry about wiping with the grain, etc. If I had to do it over again, I'd get the same combination without hesitation.

    My DW is panelled (white cabinetry); my sister has a stainless steel DW door, and it is constantly showing long drips of water down the front, cause you often load dishes that are dripping, or have dripping things nearby. My fridge is the aforementioned white-pebbled. It's a Kitchenaid, and has performed flawlessly, but is the one thing I might change to SS just for looks. Having said that, I'm not unhappy with the white fridge since it also never shows fingerprints or streaks and is a cinch to keep clean-looking. Now, my SS sink...that's another story. If I had to do THAT again, I'd get a Silgranite sink. My SS sink shows water spots almost immediately, and I have always hated those water spots. My do-over for my sink would be Silgranite in the anthracite color - way cool!

  • 18 years ago

    I had white appliances and off-white (BM Navajo) painted cabinets in our last house, and I hated the look. When we moved and began to plan our new kitchen, DH wanted SS appliances and I wanted black (w/cherry cabs).

    I was intent on getting a bottom freezer, but the one we looked at scared me (single door, huge hulking black box). The showroom was clearing the floor for new models, so we got our SS french door fridge for a good price. I LOVE it. DH didn't want to mix SS and black appliances (love how Mysterymachine does that), so we ended up with SS appliances and maple cabs.

    As Debi_2006 notes above, SS is a nice medium, neutral color. It just seems to disappear; reflecting the surroundings. I really love my SS. No panels in my kitchen!

  • 18 years ago

    My appliances are white in my modest, traditional cherry stained kitchen. I have small kids and wanted appliances that didn't fingerprint. I suppose they are stark in contrast (as someone stated above) - you can decide. Here's a picture of my soon to be finished kitchen. BTW - surface on appliances are smooth.

    {{!gwi}}

  • 18 years ago

    rmiriam ~ My fridge is Fisher Paykel - I lucked out big time because I love the style, and the size (I needed a fridge with a small footprint - hard to find!), the bottom freezer, and the smooth finish - this fridge met ALL of my requirements!

    You can find smooth finishes in the (expensive) retro look appliances, but I don't know of too many other manufacturers who have it. You may need to visit an appliance warehouse or store to find out who else has it.

  • 18 years ago

    One deciding factor might be cost. I wanted white and I knew that from the begining, but as I was shopping I did note the price of the SS appliances. I was shocked at the upcharge for SS. For me, had I wanted SS, I would have been convinced to get white as a way to save money. I'd rather put that money into a 'nicer' appliance than a cheaper quality appliance but more costly because it was SS. (I hope my meaning is clear.)

    -Mary Alice

  • 18 years ago

    I want to thank everyone for your help today... Now to decide what will work best for us. Again thanks!

  • 18 years ago

    Samsung makes a smooth white fridge- available at best buy. I love ours, and reasonably priced too!

    akchicao(or anyone who has this combo)- could you post or email a picture of your white range with SS hood? I am in a pickle about what to do in my kitchen. Thanks

  • 17 years ago

    Well, great question. I had white in my first house and loved them, but went for stainless in this most recent remodel in my old farm house b/c I felt it better suited the look (white painted cabinets, farm sink, soapstone counters).

    So far, I love the look. I'm also SO glad I went with a "faux" stainless fridge. Just the handles are stainless, and judging from how many fingerprints are on the handles alone I think it would drive me batty to have them all over the fridge.

    Having said that, not all "stainless look" appliances are created equal! I did a lot of shopping around to find one I think really does look like stainless. I made sure:
    - the sides are painted gray, not black (as they show a little in my kitchen)
    - the finish is not a glossy sprayed on look
    - the "brush marks" (you know how stainless has a 'grain' to it?) looked authentic and went in the same direction (side to side, in my case) as the other real stainless appliances (stove and microhood).

    I got a GE french door unit with a bottom freezer. They call it Clean Steel.

    Good luck!

  • 17 years ago

    white vs. stainless: I have had all white: all black and all stainless: White shows dirt period&stains: but it's a "clean" look to a kitchen if all white is what you are looking for /cabinets/appliances/floor/countertop. If there is white in the granite and the cabinets are white: why not? Then all black I like better: And most of all: I love how the SS cleans up well and always looks new!
    Going out of style SS? I believe it has become more affordable for home owners to buy: (rich people or should I say HIGH END houses have had SS for years!) My Dad Designed and Built high end house in the 70's and 80's with SS. I love the look of SS: that's what I would want in my kitchen.
    I heard on TV (HGTV), local Realtors and customers state that white appliances will keep a house today from selling. Crazy!

  • 17 years ago

    dogridge - i realize your post is old, but if still interested, i have the white/ss combo.microwave and sik are also ss.
    also, for anyone looking for a smooth white fridge, Fisher Paykel's is.