Software
Houzz Logo Print
wes_s

Island counter overhang

17 years ago

As we near completion of a complete kitchen remodel, we have a snag (among many).

We have an island with cooktop on one side and a eating area on the other. We specified to the granite people that we wanted a 12" overhang on the eating side.

Unfortunately, they measured/calculated the overhand from the face of the cabinet box and since we have storage in that area with overlay doors, with the doors installed, the overhang is down to 11". This seems too shallow to me and my wife is very upset.

Of course the granite folks say, "We always work off the box and not the doors/drawers."

We have the project on hold while we think about this and other things. I don't want to get into a contest with them but for $7,000 I'd like to be happier.

The contract simply says, "12" over hang" so am I screwed?

Comments (9)

  • 17 years ago

    We had EXACTLY the same situation. Once our marble countertop went on, we regained 1.5 inches because the edge of the stone overhangs the plywood underlayment. Ask your fabricator what the final overhang will be once the stone is installed; you might end up with your 12 inches, or maybe even 12.5 inches, depending on your edge treatment.

  • 17 years ago

    I am sorry you didn't get what you expected, but I am afraid I have to agree with the granite installers on this one. They have no idea what thickness your finished doors will be, if they will be inset or full overlay, or if they are thin slabs. They only "known" to them is the face of the cabinet box. Sorry.

  • 17 years ago

    I ended up with an 11" overhang on my peninsula after all was said and done. We are very happy with it. But, we do not have a cooktop there. I would make sure you have enough clearance from the cooktop "splatters/heat". I know a lot of people here have many opinions on this subject. Is your granite in yet?
    Barb

  • 17 years ago

    one inch in not a big difference: keep it: if your wife can think clear and see if she is able to live with the inch. Make them give you a discount.
    2-3-4" difference would be a big deal probably to me.
    Also, templates are important: when they come to re-measure before cutting stone.
    Especially on bar tops & islands. Fabricator should say: how big do you want your island?: period: 75x55 example vs your existing top: 73 x 43. (most fabricators: do this on a countertop that is 25 1/2" they fabricate the countertop to 26") they always add for a small overhang.) When I have a customer who wants to extend their bar top or island to have a larger over-hang : I get them to sign the drawings to their kitchen approving the change. Also, we allow customers to come in the day of fabrication and approve seam and template placement on the slabs while the slab is on the cutting table. Cuts down on after-the-fact issues!

    7K: you should get what you want: but 1" is so small. I seriously would ask for a discount. (on the contractors side: if there is no granite left from your kitchen: that means the fabricator "pays" for a new slab!!!!!!)
    Best wishes~

  • 17 years ago

    Are you kidding? Your UPSET about 1" on the overhang? How in the world did you ever make it through a kitchen remodeling project if you're hung up on the difference between 11" and 12" on a seating overhang?

    Go to your neighbors and families' houses and check what their overhang is. Or go to a kitchen showroom. I would bet you will find overhangs from 10" to 14" and you won't notice much difference.

    However, in all actuality, you shouldn't even have an overhang with seating directly behind the cooktop. It's unsafe and not recommended by the NKBA or most kitchen designers.

    Best of luck to you.

  • 17 years ago

    You're not going to notice a difference between 11" and 12", but it IS a safety issue to have so small a clearance with seating there across from a cooktop. 15" is the recommended overhang for counter height seating--without a cooktop. And, you need a minimum of 12" clearance behind the cooktop unless against a wall (or knee wall with bar height above). For the maximum safety, add that 12" to the 15" for counter level seating across from a cooktop. That means that the ideal recommended depth of your island would be 41". So, I would put a bookcase or something else behind your island and give up the seating. Or, cut the granite down and build a knee wall to put bar height seating at and get a bar counter with 12" overhang for the area. Or, redo the island for the increased overhang and 41" depth.

  • 17 years ago

    maydl,

    In our case, there is no plywood underlayment. We will not gain anything. Eleven inches it is.

    ccoombs,

    Normally I would agree with you, however, my cabinetmaker steered me to this installer and they work closely all of the time.

    The cabinetmaker makes one style and one style only, "Euro-style" boxes with full overlay doors.

    The granite lady had a full set of drawings including renderings and knew full well the situation.

    The cabinetmaker added to the confusion since we originally specified frame-and-panel plant-on panels on the ends of the island. He built them then my wife had second thoughts about installing them. He then made notes to the granite folks telling them to adjust the overhang depending on our final decision so that there would be an inch and a half overhang BEYOND THE PANELS. So even though they have the look of doors, he considers them part of the "box" and overhangs the 1 1/2", but when they are ACTUALLY doors, they don't get extra overhang.

    So I effectively have 1/2" overlay above drawers/doors, 1 1/2" on the island ends and 11" on the eating side. I'm inclined to add the panels and reduce the end overhang to 1/2" too.

    bbtondo,

    We have four and one-half feet between the cook top on one side and the breakfast bar on the other. The old setup had a Jennair electric cook top with integral downdraft vent system. We are installing a Kenmore induction cook top with a telescoping downdraft, so we will actually have more splatter protection.

    The granite is sitting in place but has not been cut yet. The Swanstone sink that went right from our supplier to the granite shop had an unacceptable flaw in it so we are holding for a replacement.

  • 17 years ago

    "Or, cut the granite down and build a knee wall to put bar height seating at and get a bar counter with 12" overhang for the area."

    I ditto that idea! best said!

    What is the point of an island? really: it's something that gets in the way: to me: just because everyone else has one doesn't mean it's the best idea.
    Everyone has their own opinion regarding kithcen design.
    I agree with the NKBA re: NOT having seating directly behind the cooktop. mentioned by round the house:
    we installed an island with "steel round cylinders" (special order from California) that sit on top of the island to make a 9" high bar top above the island for bar seating for the dining experience! Looks great in the customers house with the Sapphire Brown granite she picked and stainless steal appliances.

  • 17 years ago

    Well, some comments came in between the time I started composing my last message and the time I actually sent it, so a few words of update and response.

    All of this stuff is a replacement for existing cabinets, island, etc. The house is CMU (concrete block) and slab on grade. Thus all wiring and piping was literally cast in concrete and I was not about to move anything. Additionally, the floors are brick pavers and due to 28 years of "patina" any changes there were out of the question. So the island footprint had to stay the same or larger. Because of cast in concrete electrical and a 6" vent pipe under the slab, changes in this area were also out of the question (at least budget wise).

    So to the questions of whether an island is a good idea or not, and so forth, the engineering constraints were set and I have to make the best of the situation. Would I do it differently if I were starting from scratch? Of course, but hindsight is 20-20.

    As a retired engineer (EE), amateur woodworker, machinist in my pre-engineering days and veteran of several remodels, IÂve managed bigger projects than this one, but this is my first dealing with granite fab. Hence the original question.

    As a married man, with a wife who has wanted this done for the 18 years weÂve lived here, IÂm also trying to make her dreams come true. So if her heart was set on one thing and she got something else, itÂs an issue whether or not itÂs a practical difference or not.

    Ditto the knee wall. AinÂt going to happen.

    But, thanks for all the suggestions.