Software
Houzz Logo Print
woohooman

How about yeast for slugs?

Beer works, iron phosphate works. But how about active dry yeast?

I have a huge bag of active dry yeast that just reached it's exp. date. It's still good and sitting in the fridge. But there is no way I will make enough bread even in the next year to put much a dent in it. So, I was thinking mix some with water and sugar and setting out for the slugs.

What do you all think? If not slugs, How about earwigs or some other pest?

Kevin

Comments (17)

  • 11 years ago

    Try it. They may like it.
    Suggest you also add a drop of liquid soap.

  • 11 years ago

    Sounds like slug food. Protein, carbs, fat, what's not to like if you're a slug? But I assume you mean as a trap. Beer and yeast traps are standard for slugs. One tablespoon of yeast per cup of water should do it. If you add sugar, it'll just erupt, so I wouldn't do that.

    Active dry yeast in the fridge will be good way beyond its listed expiration date. The expiration date is for room temp (and it usually works well way after that anyway, even if kept at room temp). I'd just make a lot of bread. In fact, if the yeast is really getting old, it'll just work a bit less well than unexpired yeast. So just use twice as much in your bread. Protein, carbs, fat, what's not to like if you're a bread eater?

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Jean and dan.

    dan: good to know that yeast will last much longer than the exp. date. There's still no way I could make THAT much bread. It's one of those 2 lb bags of Red Star. I got tired of paying for the 3 tiny packets of Fleischmann's, so when I saw this bag at Smart and Final, I scored.

    What else is yeast used for besides bread and spirits in the kitchen?

    Kevin

  • 11 years ago

    Think seeds. Seeds don't die suddenly on a specific date. The older they are, the lower their germination rate will be. But seeds a few years old, and not mistreated, will likely produce for you. Also, seeds last vastly longer when kept chilled.

    Dry yeast kept in the freezer will probably be just as viable two years after the listed expiration date as yeast kept at room temp until the listed expiration date.

    Yeast is nutritionally rich. Dissolve a spoonful of it in anything you make. Sauces? Casseroles? Yogurt? Go for it. Some people swear that if you consume yeast before imbibing (one teaspoon per beer, right before you start drinking), it keeps you from getting drunk. Be careful, because there are yeast allergies.

    Now, we wouldn't want to keep those slugs from getting drunk in a beer trap, would we?

  • 11 years ago

    I tried the yeast Vs beer for beer drown trap as well as kill bait. The yeast did not seem to work / attract them as well as beer did. For the bait: a simple mixture of flour + Ironite (Iron sulfate) with or without a drop of pyrethrin made into a paste / slurry seemed to work well.

  • 11 years ago

    People often recommend AGAINST eating baker's yeast without cooking it first. People do often add brewer's yeast to foods for extra protein and B vitamins.

  • 11 years ago

    Yes, I have seen that. Some believe that bakers yeast can actually start growing in your stomach. Then again, maybe if you're drinking a lot, the alcohol will kill it first! Allegedly, if you eat the yeast on an empty stomach, the acids and enzymes will kill the yeast. But if you have a lot of stuff in your stomach, including sugars, the acids and enzymes are diluted, and the yeast will start doing it's stuff on that sugar, leading to bloating.

    If you're going to eat a lot of it, yes, you might make sure it gets cooked first.

  • 11 years ago

    use coffee ground or crushed egg shells to deter slugs

  • 11 years ago

    Anything with sharp edges can harm the slugs belly, making them bleed. That is what crushed egg shell does. You may also try to add pavers/play sand. But need to get rid of the very powdery parts. You do that with coffee ground too. So that it wont keep a lot of moisture and will have more sharp edges.

    I mix crushed egg shell, coffee ground, sand and some slug bait (just to give it a punch). This way I can use it generously more places.

    What is called "slug Bait" is not really a bait, meaning neither slugs are attracted to it nor they eat it. The chemical in them cause bleeding in slugs belly. Slugs are vegetarians.

    ANOTHER WAY to fight them (in limited space) is just get a bamboo skewer and a flash light at night and just SKEW them as you find them, one after another, without even touching them.

    Well of course, if money is no object, you can spread tons of SLUGGO everywher. But I find it too expensive. Beer is equally expensive. Average (cheap) beer costs about a buck for a bottle. And you are not sure that the slugs will accept your invitation for the party. hahaha

    Seysonn

  • 11 years ago

    In my experience, and that is gardening in an almost permanently damp climate which is slug and snail heaven, coffee grounds, egg shells, sand, paving stones or any other physical barrier makes absolutely no difference to slugs or snails. They do not 'bleed' when crossing such things since they lay their own slime trail as they go along. Slugs and snails are the no. one pest in UK gardens and nothing works on them except picking or poison. I've shown this picture before but here it is again: A Hosta in a pot 3 feet off the ground and surrounded by crushed egg shell.

  • 11 years ago

    what? rotating chickens through gardens completely eliminate them. but it does take planning and land.

  • 11 years ago

    You could hire neighborhood kids to remove slugs more cheaply and easily than raising chickens.

  • 11 years ago

    Our PNW is a slugs heaven too, Floral.
    The egg shell I see in your picture won't work. The pieces are too big and they actually make a kind of smooth pavement. The mixture I recommended has to have a full coverage with a minimum thickness of about 1/8" to be effective. Then I frugally dress it with some cheap slug poison to give it a kick.

    As I said, hand picking is more effective if you are diligent. Star early in the season, reducing the chances of multiplying.

    CHICKENS ???. Un less you let them in the garden at night and they are willing to stay there, WON"T work. Slugs come out after dark. And sometimes in a heavily overcast drizzley day time.

    Seysonn

  • 11 years ago

    Chickens scratch. They uncover slugs hiding in the daytime, kicking them out of their hiding places. A local small nursery kept bantams at one time, to the delight of customers browsing and they were quite good for the garden. But the display gardens were extensive, and the chickens could be fairly disruptive/damaging in it if plants were not at a more mature age. If you are going to try chickens, don't let them loose at seedling stage or protect those plants when young.

    Coffee grounds, pavers, sand, egg shells do me absolutely no good whatsoever. I won't deal with beer traps. Ammonia water spray at night (flashlight, after dark) and slug bait keep the population down.

  • 11 years ago

    LOL... nice to see this thread get so much attention.

    I'm with the side that says deterrents are worthless. Poison works. Beer works. Chickens(geese, etc)(no room for fowl though). I was just wondering if I could use my overabundance of yeast on them. I made a couple yeast traps and they did attract and kill some of those spirally snails. They look like decollate snails(which are supposed to eat slugs), but as many as the sprallies I have, one would figure that there wouldn't be a slug problem at all.

    Seysonn: I suspect that the POISON you add to your eggshells et al is what's working. Not the actual eggshells and coffee grounds.

    Kevin

  • 11 years ago

    Seysonn: I suspect that the POISON you add to your eggshells et al is what's working. Not the actual eggshells and coffee grounds.

    Kevin
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    Maybe so. But the other stuff at least works as a substrate so i just use a little bit of the poison. That also lasts longer because of the drainage. So I get a big bang for the buck, at least. Next year I will experiment methodologically .

    Seysonn

  • 8 years ago

    Yeast is only an attractant,,,,,,,,,a poison (iron) is needed


    BES