Software
Houzz Logo Print
jeff_bowers492

Water Heating for new construction

11 years ago

I'm trying to plan proper water heating for my new home. The number of occupants will vary from 2 - 12 with fairly typical water needs, plus some entertaining of large groups with hot water needed for cooking and cleaning up in the kitchen. The major issue is the two 50 gallon soaker tubs in the master bath. At least one will be used weekly, but simultaneous use will be less frequent, probably on the order of once a month.

We're not planning for jets in either tub, and in the winter our cold water is very cold.

Thanks for any help.

Comments (5)

  • 11 years ago

    Pretty hard to guess what you need with a 2 to 12 range of people. Are the 12 occupants when visitors are staying or is that who will be there most of the time?

    Get a water heater rated for how many people you need it for on a normal day. The following info is from http://www.hgtv.com/remodel/mechanical-systems/choose-the-right-size-water-heater

    Step 1: Allot 12 gallons of hot water per person in the household.

    Step 2: Figure the home's maximum occupancy as the number of bedrooms plus 1. In this case, we have 4 bedrooms, so we add 1 and get 5. Now multiply this amount times the 12-gallon allotment and you end up with an FHR of 60. That's the minimum FHR that this home should needs on its water heater.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks, that's some good basic advice, but I don't see how that addresses the issue of the two large tubs.

  • 11 years ago

    Allot 2/3 of the tub size for hot water. So 33 gallons for a 50 gallon tub. If both tubs operating at the same time then double that. Then take into account number of people and the FHR needed also.

  • 11 years ago

    Options I can think of...

    Boiler system for heating and you get a good water supply too.

    Multiple standard tank heaters. If you get a single 80 gal and drain that to fill the tubs the other 10 people won't have hot water. Multiple tanks can also get the tank close to the source. Greatly increases comfort (no waiting is priceless imo) and reduces the load on the heaters.

    Tankless heaters. Watch out on the size vs how you want to use them. You're not going to be happy following the standard guide if you want high flow shower heads, multiple heads, etc. Plus the temp of the incoming water has to be factored in. Pretty expensive for install but with 2 soaker tubs it sounds like money is no problem.

    Heated soaker tub. You still need enough heated water to fill but these will keep the temp up so you don't have to keep adding more hot water which greatly increases the required size because after filling the tub you'd still need more.

    As for the 2-12 people plus "large groups" there's really no way to size for that other than looking at fixtures maybe. If you have say 10 showers and the 2 soakers and want them all to run at the same time you have to design to that desire. If you can deal with no one taking a shower for some time when the soakers are used that can greatly change the design. If you want all these people to take long showers that can double or triple the needed size for standard tank heaters. If you want max flow heads the changes the tankless requirements. All of this could also lead to increasing the water supply because 3/4" isn't going to cut it. And maybe increasing gas supply if these are all tankless.

    50 years ago a household with 12 people would often still have a single bathroom and people (kids) often shared bath water. Today everyone wants their own private bath so houses are more like hotels. Utilities have to be sized accordingly. For example my wife and I have a single 19 gal electric heater which causes most Americans to roll their eyes. Using standard type guides may be very disappointing. All depends on how you use the system.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for all the info. It looks like tankless might be our best bet. The relative cost shouldn't be too bad since we'd need two tanks anyway, and we can keep it's limitations in mind to avoid too many simultaneous fixtures in use.