Software
Houzz Logo Print
donnabaskets

Have you ever tried this? (pumpkins)

11 years ago

FYI for those who don't know, curcubita pepo squash are sitting ducks for squash vine borers. Curcubita moschatas are quite resistant to them. I want to grow Winter Luxury pumpkins this year (pepo). I grew no squash at all last year because of vine borer problems in the hope that I could get rid of them and they'd take awhile to come back (?). I also plan to grow Tahitian Melons (moschata) as a backup for the pumpkins. So, I was thinking about this and wondered if anyone has ever tried growing pepo vines among moschatas? Does this help keep the borers away?

Comments (16)

  • 11 years ago

    I have never tried intermixing them as I grow all my squash and pumpkins using timed planting and under row covers to protect against both borers and squash bugs (my major problem). But it would seem to make some sense. It falls into the reverse of the "trap crop" approach, the "repellent crop" approach. How successful that may or may not be (with other crops) is hotly debated but some of the companion planters swear by it.

    Let us know if it works.

    Dave

  • 11 years ago

    Donna, I think I deciphered your post? I'm not good on the proper names of squash! Google wasn't much help!

    I think that what you are saying is putting something like butternut squash in with your summer squash and/or pumpkins??


    I have vine borers very very bad. I don't grow pumpkins any more because of the borers.

    I don't use many pumpkins anyway. But I love my yellow crookneck squash!

    I might try it too if I am correct?

  • 11 years ago

    Tahitian melon is moschata? That's good to know, though I may not have room for them. I hear they are HUGE. I have a hard time believing that moschata will protect pepos from SVBs. They don't "repel" SVBs, they just can't get penetrated by SVBs. That's like planting carrots with tomatoes to protect from moles.


  • 11 years ago

    Right. I am sure you are correct. I was just wondering if perhaps the borer moths are able to tell the difference between pepos and moschatas and avoid laying eggs on moschatas. I think I will try it just as an experiment, though. Dave, I don't know what you mean by timed plantings. I have tried growing squash under row covers and pollinating the blossoms by myself. I wasn't very good at it. I had greatly reduced yields. And these squash vines will be so large I don't see how I could keep them covered. Any ideas you have are more than welcome.

    Wertach, there are five different species of curcubitas. (squash/pumpkin family). They all have a hollow stem to a greater or lesser degree except moschatas. Borers like the ones with hollow stems. Evidently, they don't like little hollow stems, and that explains why they don't bother my cucumbers. But my absolute favorite summer squash (all pepos)? These are their very favorites plus many other tasty winter squash and pumpkins. Evidently, more and more gardeners are buying only moschatas. I have noticed this year that nearly every seed catalog I received specified the species on every listing.

    And yes, Dan, I double checked my SESE seed packet. Tahitian melons are moschatas. I will be careful to report back on this try, especially if I am successful. Everything's possible in February!

  • 11 years ago

    I've tried covering squash, and you simply have to pollinate manually. But in my mind, doing that covering is more trouble than it's worth. Moschatas are a blessing in that regard. And are the Tahitians OP also?


  • 11 years ago

    Yes. They are open pollinated.

  • 11 years ago

    I guess it is all in what you are used to and maybe how you plant. My squash hills are spaced about 5-6 feet apart in hills of 3 plants each so it is easy to toss Reemay blankets over them and weigh the edges down with soil or stones close into the base of the plants. They look like giant white mushrooms in the garden.

    Early morning hand pollinating takes me about 30-45 min. total given that 1 male bloom can do several female blooms. I don't bother with brushes and all that, just a peeled bloom. And since I don't save seed from them I can even cross pollinate for faster results and better production.

    Timed planting is simply identifying the pest activity dates in your area - for me it is the 2nd week of May and again 2nd week of August for the heaviest borers so I time my plantings accordingly. The first goes in end of March to beat the first invasion and the 2nd planting goes in end of June. Hatch time in your area will vary.

    Squash bugs are much harder to time for as they have an almost continuous life cycle of stages down here.

    Dave

  • 11 years ago

    Other than the moschatas, there is C.pepo option for summer squash. Does require row covers, but there are several varieties of Parthenocarpic zucchini. These set with out pollination. Sure Thing. Partenon, Perfect Pick are some that come to mind.

  • 11 years ago

    this will not work. a plant acts as an insect repellent due to chemicals repelling the bugs. say garlic near other veggies. the SVB flies around and deposits eggs on many stems. All you are getting is 50% reduction. I look at my late July zucchini stems, with 5-8 SVB larvae, and know that 3-4 will still kill them.

  • 11 years ago

    I haven't interplanted so close that the vines were entwined before, but I have planted them right next to each other, with the plants less than a foot apart. The vine borers never had trouble telling the vulnerable plants from the less vulnerable plants. I got eggs on all the plants: more on the C. pepo and less on the C. moschata, but still eggs on everything. It's just that the moschata lived through the experience. I do not think that your experiment would work - but give it a try if you'd like, and let us know!

  • 11 years ago

    Farmerdill, I didn't know there were parthenocarpic zucchini! That is great! And that, I could do. I don't suppose there are parthenocarpic crooknecks? Thanks! I may still plant these two squash together. If one fails, the other should make it and so the space won't be wasted. Since I didn't plant any squash last year, maybe I can get a few pumpkins. We shall see.

    Let's say I decide to cover a vine, uncover it when it begins to bloom, let it set a few pumpkins and then just cover the vines back up to mature the ones it has set. How many fruit could I reasonably expect a vine to set in a few days time? Obviously,the longer the vine is uncovered, the greater is the threat of eggs.

  • 11 years ago

    I've been wanting to try these parthenocarpic plants. I understand that there are parthenocarpic cukes as well, but as far as I can tell, the seeds are EXTREMELY expensive. About a dollar a pop. Parthenocarpic squash seeds aren't cheap either, but they are much more affordable. Maybe a quarter each. One advantage with cukes is that the vine lays pretty flat, so they're easier to cover than are zuccini (though I guess they cover more ground area). I've had mixed results with cukes, re SVBs, but zuccini are dead men walking.


  • 11 years ago

    Sorry I do not know of any parthenocarpic crooknecks, straightnecks, or scallops. Cavili is a another widely available parthenocarpic zucchini. Squash set in one day when pollinated whichmake it easy to hand pollinate. You can grown any bush squash under row covers if you can take the few minutes early each morning to hand pollinate. The problem with insect pollination is that it takes time for the insects to discover the blossoms and start working them. You cannot just flip back the covers and expect them to come immediately.

  • 11 years ago

    ~~".Let's say I decide to cover a vine, uncover it when it begins to bloom, let it set a few pumpkins and then just cover the vines back up to mature the ones it has set. How many fruit could I reasonably expect a vine to set in a few days time? "~~

    The simple answer is none. You would be negating any benefits from the covering. Borers will find the plants, if active at the time, much faster than any pollinating insects will.

    As farmerdill said, growing under cover requires active participation on your part to get a crop. Hand pollination is easy and quick - depending on the number of plants you have - and guarantees a good crop. And the time invested in hand pollination of covered crops is far less than the time one would have to spend preventing or treating an infestation of any UNcovered crop. Do the math. :) More production from fewer plants under cover vs. less to no production from more plants uncovered.

    Dave


  • 11 years ago

    agree with Dave and Dill. Say you uncover four times your plants, each time painting a male first, and then however many females you can find. That is one hour of work. Having one side of the row cover held down by a pole makes entry and exit quick (the pole lies on the ground holding down one side of the cover). also it helps having drip irrigation in place.

  • 11 years ago

    These are all very good points. I hadn't thought of it in that mathematical way. I suppose when it comes to pumpkins that once I have a good number of pumpkins on the vine, I can just stop pollinating, leave them covered and let them mature. I will try the hand pollinating thing again this year. Thank you all for helping me to think this through. And yes, Tahitian Melon is open pollinated. :)

    One more question: How wide are the row covers you use on squash, Dave? And where do you get them?