Software
Houzz Logo Print
lone_elm_z6

Fixing after planting

11 years ago

Last fall without knowing much I planted a few potted trees, and have been getting educated after the fact. Last weekend I scrapped away soil to the flares, and pulled the stakes out. I did know to mulch when I planted. Problem is I did not do anything to the roots and am assuming they are crammed and choked. When I planted I don't recall them circling tightly at all. I really do not want to dig them up and fix it now -- or should I?

Comments (5)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If in doubt (about the root system being in good shape), and you plan on them being around for a while, yes you should.

  • 11 years ago

    I figured as much, but was hoping for an answer that would fit with my laziness. When I asked the nursery for tips on planting all I got back was not to plant low. I certainly would have done things right if I'd known. They also sent less than stellar specimens and gave the impression of being slack generally. This April I got bare roots from Grimo and Silver Creek nurseries, and they both were great -- really informed and helpful and professional.

  • 11 years ago

    it might help to know what plants you are talking about ...

    but for sure.. if you want to dig up.. and look toward root surgery .. it should be done.. when the tree is FULLY DORMANT ... and preferably leafless ... if not evergreen ...

    so if your plants just leafed out ... i would NOT call a redo ... look toward fall ...

    ken


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you damage the roots of a dormant deciduous magnolia it may just rot and die afterward - this is one kind you definitely do not want to process during winter dormancy. Otherwise even if the leaves shrivel a deciduous tree or shrub planted with root corrections made while in leaf probably really isn't likely to have died completely in many instances - you are subjecting the specimen to this at planting so it does not girdle or topple perhaps many years later. For example, I had several foundation shrubs go over one day under a snow load about 25 years after planting. When I dug them up the roots looked like turnips, due to them having been left too long in 4" pots at one stage in the production sequence. In the case of a tree of some height such sudden failures due to bound roots can even be dangerous or destructive.

    The "root" of the problem is the plant being sold to you with deformed roots in the first place; since this is a pandemic situation thanks to widespread, apparently careless nursery practice we are all stuck with either having a percentage of purchases fail immediately because of intentional root damage at planting or taking our chances with circling, kinked etc. roots.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The trees are Red Oak, Sunset Maple, Karpick Maple, 2 Green Mountain Maples. I'll most likely wait for fall. Other than digging right out, could I get a kind of hand auger and drill down right at the sides and then take hand or branch pruners and cut a line down the sides, quartering -- cutting through the roots and inch or two into the side?

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio