Software
Houzz Logo Print
queen_gardener

Fire Island - should I get??

11 years ago

Hello! I almost bought Fire Island, but it just looked like slug bait. It's neat and pretty, but the leaves were so thin. I would like something like that for my hosta/classic shade garden in the corner of the yard. Anything I plant far away from the house just has to have some slug resistance. I know about the Diatomaceous earth, but I dig around in this bed way too much to waste my money on that yet. Maybe when I get the bed the way I want it, and it settles down - like in a few years, or maybe never, lol.

So what do you know about Fire Island?

Comments (16)

  • 11 years ago

    I just don't want to use chemicals - my kids and I dig in the gardens all the time, and I hate to poison other good bugs, or the birds that are pecking in that dirt to get worms (and hopefully slugs). I will put out egg shells, and I tried home made slug traps last year, and whatnot. I just know that if I buy that Diatomaceous earth, it will ALL be turned under within the year.

    So I thought about putting it in a pot . . . how do you winter over your pots? Just leave them out? I'm in Ohio.

    I will look up English Sunrise!

    Thanks!

  • 11 years ago

    I understand your reasoning re chemicals. :). I leave my pots outside, tucked beneath shrubs, upright or lying on their sides out in the open. They get plenty of snowcover as insulation. If I am overly protective about certain ones I overwinter them in the garage. I don't fuss other than that.

    The bonus about potting your eventual choice of Hosta is that you can move it around at will for esthetic reasons or in the quest for that ideal location where it grows the way you want it to, or the way it should according to its ideal.

  • 11 years ago

    Here's mine and I have had no problems with slugs but it did have a rough winter 2 years a go and was reduced in size about half of what it was!

    Gary

  • 11 years ago

    Jo, I think your pic of the golds showcases the attractive, ruffled one in the center which certainly grabs my attention. Marrakech? Fruit Punch? Or another?

    BC

  • 11 years ago

    Oh, you clever one, BC! ;) First guess does it! Marrakech it is....I wanted to post it again by itself because it is just gorgeous! So I snuck it in with FI instead. Kind of steals the thunder away from Fire Island, I think! Lol

  • 11 years ago

    This photo is less distracting


  • 11 years ago

    you don't see the red very much, at least not in pics. also, it doesn't seem like a strong grower - the pots at the store were rather pathetic, to be honest, and I like strong, vigorous growers. Marrakech is prettier, how is it? . . . if English Sunrise has thick leaves and is a sturdy hosta, I would try to find/trade for it.

  • 11 years ago

    Fire Island is a very strong grower for me and the colour is so vivid that I would say it glows.

    I don't use chemicals - I pick our icky friends off the leaves in the evenings for about 2 weeks in June when they seem to all come out. This has worked well enough for me so far that I am not looking for any other method of control... Your kids would probably be willing to slug hunt with you since it involves flashlights and trying to spy the slimy things (kinda like where's Waldo).

  • 11 years ago

    Josephine - I love your English Sunrise. I have gold coloured weedlings from June - hopefully one of them will turn out to be something like ES. (June self seeds in my yard.)

  • 11 years ago

    Ooo - I just bought June!!! I love it already, and it's just a baby! I get seedlings all around my huge hostas that were here at the house, I think they are Sagae and Frances Williams. I'm trying to trade them off right now, as I hate to kill them. Some of them look really neat. Do hosta seedlings show what they're going to be right away, or does it take a couple years, or what? I can tell some are bluer than others, and they have lots of different leaf shapes. I have a couple pics up in my Idea Book.

    My kids do like slugs, so I will offer a reward to the best slug catcher :-)

  • 11 years ago

    I can't kill the hosta seedlings I find either...so then I have to look for someone to take them if I have several that look the same - which luckily doesn't usually seem to be much of a problem when it comes to hostas. :)

    It can take many years for a hosta to mature - especially the larger ones - so you never know exactly what you might be giving away with a young plant...

  • 11 years ago

    urk, I didn't need to hear that . . . ! :-) lol, I'm not a hosta breeder, don't have the space to keep them all! I just let nature do it's thing, and keep some.

  • 11 years ago

    good for you! I figure if it will kill a slug it will kill a worm. And I'm fortunate to find worms in every shovel I put in the soil. I've thought about putting copper rings around the base of my plants. If it works I would consider FI too!

  • 11 years ago

    I've left both Fire Islands right out in the sun and they are gorgeous! I even went nose to nose, looking for any sunburn....they look like they would burn, but no.

    Marrakech is one of my all-time favourites! Also very sun tolerant. It is another I give more sun exposure to prolong the gold.

    English Sunrise has thicker leaves, great substance and very sun tolerant.

    Any of these three are great - but nothing beats a JUNE! If you just want one.

  • 11 years ago

    I just bought a June - really cheap at a local store! I'm so glad I did! Might have to get the Fire Island, which was a bit more expensive, but was larger.

    Actually, I just remembered what I did last year for slugs that really helped - I bought a package of those copper scrubbies, and I cut them up with scissors all around the base of the hostas that were getting chewed up the worst. I also have several worms in each shovelful of dirt, even with the clay, and I'm always in the dirt, so I use non-chemical measures as much as possible. I put the cut up copper scrubbies and egg shells and some barberry trimmings around the hostas that looked like Swiss cheese. And since I've always got my hands in the dirt, I got poked and scratched by my own slug deterrents!!!

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations