Software
Houzz Logo Print
fduk_gw

Climber in pot (sort of....)

Hi this is probably a stupid newb type question, but here goes anyway. I have Souvenir de Madame Leonie Viennot, currently in a pot. At the end of the season I intend to transfer her to a permanent pot. This pot will be at the end of a bench in front of my shed, and the plan is to allow her to grow up and all over the shed, and possibly the fence either side. (The shed is sat in a corner.) It's not far off a maximum sun area, apart from at the very bottom, which is why I decided to grow the rose on a little before planting. It's not the warmest spot in the garden during winter, but from reading about this rose, it's pretty tough for a tea-noisette, and it's only once in a blue moon that I get even -10c where I am.

I was thinking of making her a bottomless planter, about 2ft by 2ft square, and 18 inches deep. I am going to dig out and amend the soil under the planter with the idea that the rose will root down into the soil underneath. The planter could probably be bigger, up to 2ft by 3ft 6, and 2ft deep if need be. Visually, the smaller size will look better with the bench, but I am more concerned with the rose's health. So the question is, does it need to be bigger?

The next question is soil - over here I guess the standard advice is John Innes no 3. Any recommendations? Once in place I don't intend to tip the rose out every few years to root prune etc, so it need to be mix that is suitable long term. My underlying soil is sandy and free draining, so I guess I also need to be concerned about making sure there isn't a distinct demarcation between the planter soil and the garden soil, so the rose will find it easy to root down through the planter.

Advice? Problems I haven't thought of yet?

Comments (11)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The lighter the pot soil you use is the easier the rose will grow its roots in the soil below. I would use your native soil mixed with a bit of peat based substrata or with your compost based John Innes. You may have to water more frequently while the rose is young but I guess that would be a problem for me in my climate not for you. I'm not sure why you can't plant her directly in the ground in the first place though. Is it for gaining 'free' height?

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    absolutely, John Innes is a great base but on its own, it gets a bit claggy and loses structure on its own so if you can find Levington's 'Jack's Magic' or any of the New Horizon composts, or grit or perlite, it will help with aeration and drainage. Up to a quarter of the JI can be replaced with a compost mix (or leafmould) or any of the mineral amendments (clay hydroleca, chick flint, horticultural grit, perlite, vermiculte et al). I would also use a good proportion of garden soil which, as well as equalising (to some extent) the difference between pot and garden soil, it also has the added advantage of being teeming with microlife (unlike bagged mixes which are sterile and inert). If you can scrape some soil from beneath a tree, there will be lots of arbuscular mycchorhizae which attaches to the root system, increasing surface area and uptake efficiency. Finally, I like the organic Osmo slow-release fertilisers (they do a good rose one) which you should find online (not many garden centres stock it). I get mine from Fargro or LBS horticultural supplies. A spring topdressing lasts all season.

  • 11 years ago

    I totally replace my native sand with my homemade soil mixture and have never had issues with the roots not not wanting to leave the planting hole and move into the surrounding soil. Maybe that's a problem with heavier clay type soils?

  • 11 years ago

    I'm a muppet. I write a novel and forget to include the pertinent point. There's a bloody great ash about 20ft north, and although the rose will be out of the shade zone, it's definitely not out of the root zone. So the pot will be to give it a leg up to get established. It's also a visual thing, If I put the rose in the ground there the eye will follow along the bench, and kind of drop off at the end. I've been unhappy about that corner since I put the slabs in, it's never looked right. If I put a planter there it will fill up the corner and make it look finished. At the moment it's untidy and not in the naturalistic way, more in a scruffy alley way!

    New Horizon is readily available - I use their peat free compost all the time, so that's not a problem.

    So do you think the size would be ok to get it started? Or should I go for larger?

  • 11 years ago

    Well I wouldn't hold my breath that the ash will be there for long - chalara is romping through the species at a frightening rate.
    And anyway, I wouldn't be worrying too much about tree roots - my entire 5 acres is crossed and recrossed by a vast web of poplar roots but the arbuscular mycchorhizae associated with many native trees seems to have a beneficial effect in optimising water and nutrient uptake for shrubs and perennials which are growing totally within the rootzone. There are at least 150 species of fungi which symbiotically live in a holistic ecosystem - tree roots are NOT your problem. Shade is another matter altogether but unless the rose is deeply shaded out (and you say not), then I would just carry on. As the roots will be able to escape from the bottom of the pot, the ultimate pot size is fairly irrelevant (apart from the aesthetic value) as long as it is large enough to allow water penetration around the trunk. Go right ahead - at the very worst, it will be relatively easy to undercut the roots from beneath the pot and move the whole shebang.


  • 11 years ago

    Cannot advise as to potting mix, as we don't follow the same system here in the US. I've never heard of John Innes, 1, 2, or 3!

    What we do sometimes do for tree roots is to dig a deep hole and put a cardboard box in the the ground, then fill it with native soil. The cardboard will break down over time and the roots of the tree and the rose will eventually penetrate in both directions, but it ought to give the rose a decent head start. You could also use one of those sturdy pressed paper pots. My impression is that they might last a little longer than the cardboard box. Be sure to bury the rim under soil, or at least under mulch, because if exposed to air it will wick the moisture away. It is possible that in your much rainier climate this will not be an issue. It would be a problem here.

  • 11 years ago

    ..I realise this is not your plan, but I would try a different rose. Souvenir de Mme. L.V. seems to have the kind of blooms that I would not want to see covering a shed, the blooms look delicate and feminine... and secondly, in my garden at least, this rose is a staller so far... it's extremely slow to take off.. in fact I think it's putting its middle finger up at me currently.... not a rose I would want to place for quick effect, but perhaps in 10 years it might look something...


  • 11 years ago

    I am inclined to agree with Marlorena - teas in general can take around 6 or 7 years to get to mature size (or even longer).. This, possibly more than their less hardy tendencies, has hindered the popularity of growing teas in the UK, plus when they do reach maturity, they can be very big indeed in small UK gardens.

  • 11 years ago

    Hmm. Everything I've read about this one calls it a walloping great rose once it's got it's legs under it. However this is my first year growing teas and it's still an experiment so I'm listening pretty carefully to those of you with experience!

    Might wait and see what it looks like in autumn before making a final call, it's growing on ok right now, but that doesn't necessarily mean much. I don't mind really if it takes a few years to get going, but I would resent having to scrap the idea and start again if it never makes a reasonable size.

    Re chalara fraxiniea. Ugh, don't remind me. I've not seen it locally, but I'm a bit wigged out about it - not only are there big ashes just beyond the garden boundary where they could flatten the shed (and on a piece of 'no man's land which would make tracking down a responsible party very, very difficult! ) but there is a huge one on the boundary with a neighbour, who likes it and won't hear of it being removed and it's big enough that if it fell towards the house it would cause considerable damage.



  • 11 years ago

    ..whilst it wouldn't be my choice, I think you should stick with your plan if it's what you want to do... we learn as we go along what works for us or not... so I hope you will be pleased with the result over the course of time...

    ...Something I've seen before in some climbing/rambling roses, including one with this type of Tea/Noisette heritage in Alister Stella Gray, that they sit there doing nothing all summer then after a hot July/August they throw up a long cane in September and take off... so I hope this rose will do the same for me, and you,.. otherwise I might lose patience with it...
    ...this rose is apparently quite variable, with many clones in existence all slightly different in one way or another...


  • 11 years ago

    In TX, we saw a mature SdLV. Planted in the ground, it had climbed up a big sign and draped over the top. It was huge, and a traffic-stopper. I haven't grown it, so I don't know how long it would take to get going on its own roots, but once mature, it really is a big rose. (Your climate may make a difference, however.)

    As for those pressed cardboard pots . . . We tried some of them, years ago.

    Those pots weren't in great shape by the time we got them into the ground, and we figured they would break down fairly quickly. We went ahead, though, and slashed them all over to hasten that process.

    3-4 years later, we went back to remove those roses (which weren't happy). Those pots looked exactly as they had when we buried them. They had not even BEGUN to break down, and had pretty much imprisoned the roots of the roses. We didn't try THAT again!