One is thriving, so since it likes its home I would do the least to stress it unless you are planning on repotting it soon anyway. If you are inexperienced with container gardening, I would suggest you consider letting the weak one go- cut it off at the soil. Then you have one to enjoy while you research care for it.

That's an interesting thought. I didn't think of that as an option. Maybe Cutting it closer to the head and see if it starts to root and re-pot the head? Then the stem would start another small one correct?

Abby, before you bring out the snipper, you might want to wait for the seed pods to mature.

I've recently posted a thread on propagating Echeveria seeds, this post by Ryan will probably help you too. You have been pre-warned though, Echeveria seeds are one of the toughest to sow in the succulent world due to their extreme minute scale in size.

I believe your dominant plant is a Perle Von Numberg. I can't ID the dying sister, perhaps like breathnez suggest, it's time to behead it after you have collected the seeds. A tutorial posted by Andy on beheading his Oplina might help you.

Happy Growing! - Bernard

Very good post suggestions! I will take everything into consideration and let you know the result! As always, thank you for you help everyone!! I will be posting another question this week about some "RARE MIX OF SUCCULENT SEEDS" I bought off eBay.....I know, I know, I know! I'm new at this! Ha! Still getting into the swing of things. Please post on that one when you see it!

Best of luck Abby! I'm staying tuned!