Software
Houzz Logo Print
moonishalfawake

senecio haworthii help?

11 years ago

Help! My senecio Haworthii is slowly withering away. At first I thought the pot I bought it in was too crowded (three plants in a small pot) so I replanted one of them and then left the two smaller ones in the original container. They started to wilt, so I figured they needed more water, but when I watered it (just a few drops) it wilted even faster! It's slowly continuing to shrivel up and I am afraid to water again as I fear that will be the last straw. I've tried moving it to a sunnier location, but am thinking perhaps it needs direct sunlight? Any help appreciated, I just love its fuzzy leaves and would be so sad to see it completely shrivel up on me!


x-posted to South African plants

Comments (32)

  • 11 years ago

    Please post a photo too! Sometimes that helps greatly.

    moonishalfawake thanked ewwmayo
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks! It was getting LOTS of indirect light (north facing window, but the windows in my office are about 20 feet high and the entire wall is windows).

    Not sure on the soil specifics, it's the soil that came with it when I bought it, but it's well draining and pretty light.

    I also forgot to mention that the other one I re-potted in a pot with lots of other succulents, I let sit for a few days after re-planting and then gave the whole pot a good amount of water. The senecio haworthii completely shriveled up over the course of a few days while all the other succulents are perfectly happy, so it made me think perhaps they need less water than I am typically used to with succulents.

  • 11 years ago

    @ewwmayo photos below! When I first bought it (it's in a pot with drainage):

    Now :(


  • 11 years ago

    Looks like a case of overwatering. When in doubt with cacti/succulents, leave them alone. Put this guy in a spot with lots of indirect light and just ignore it for a week, see if it recovers.

    moonishalfawake thanked Becky
  • 11 years ago

    I am trying to see your pot learly in your pics. Do you have the pot with holes inside a pot without drainage? (last photo) If so, then it may not be draining after all. If you must have it in the second pot (which is quite pretty!) I would be sure to lift it up by placing rocks in the outer pot and being sure to let the actual pot drain completely before placing it on top of the rocks in the outer pot. I would check it over the next 24 hours to drain off any other water that may have dripped out, just to be safe. If you don't, the water is still puddling in the bottom and that will rot the roots. It would be far better to get a pot with drainage, such as terracotta, and a tray to catch the drips. Couple that with gritty mix and you may have better results.

    moonishalfawake thanked chefmomster2
  • 11 years ago

    Agreed that it's overwatering. You should definitely repot your Senecio into much better draining mix as soon as possible - it's too wet and the roots are likely in very poor shape. Searching gritty mix in the forums will give you lots of great suggestions on how to make it and why it's good!

    Otherwise, you can doing a soil mix with 50-70% perlite. Make sure to not let the inner pot sit in any excess water either. =)

    moonishalfawake thanked ewwmayo
  • 11 years ago

    That potting medium looks completely inappropriate for the species. It's waterlogged and you never ever want that with succulents.

    moonishalfawake thanked Nil13 usda:10a sunset:21 LA,CA (Mount Wash.)
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks, all! To answer your questions:

    Yes, it's in a pot with drainage. I have only ever watered it twice in about a month and a half, and each time I have let it completely drain out of the small inner pot before putting it back in the white one, and there is about an inch of space between the bottom of the black pot with drainage and the bottom of the white pot, so it has never sat in water since I purchased it. I watered it when I first got it and the soil was completely dry, but after that initial watering it slowly started to wither, so I let it be for about a month and didn't give it any water. When it didn't perk up or seem to get any better I gave it just a few drops to see how that would affect it, and it seemed to make it worse.

    The type of mix it's in has worked fine for my many other succulents, and I have experience growing and propagating succulents successfully, so am not convinced it's that. The soil is completely dry at the moment and has been for quite a while, but it still continues to wither away. Perhaps it was already too far gone when I purchased it? I'll try just ignoring it until the end of the summer to see what happens. For what it's worth the place I purchased it from is terrible and over-waters all their succulents, which I knew but bought this little guy anyway, so it could have been a goner from the beginning!

    Bonus pics of a few of my other, happy, succulents :)


  • 11 years ago

    Those are truly gorgeous specimens!

    moonishalfawake thanked chefmomster2
  • 11 years ago

    Pull the plants out of the pot, knock all that medium off the roots, and let's have a look at those roots.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I fear at this point the senecio haworthii doesn't have any--and perhaps had very few when I purchased it, but just wasn't showing many symptoms yet, and was worsened by my misdiagnosis :( I may have to give up and start over with a healthy specimin if I want one of these fuzzy guys! My chocolate tipped panda plant can tide me over in the meantime...thanks for your input anyway, we'll see if my senecio perks up at all with no water and more light

  • 11 years ago

    You have plenty of plant left. If you remove the existing soil, cut off any rot, dust with cinnamon, and plant dry in an appropriate medium, it should root just fine.

  • 11 years ago

    Agreed, I think it can be saved! Hopefully it improves on its own at least a little.

  • 11 years ago

    I'll try it! Thank you.


  • 11 years ago

    Nil, ew
    if you know - would it root from a leave?
    Rina


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    MoonIsHalfAwake- 2nd picture I snapped to show you of the mother plant.

    The plant is almost a foot tall. It used to be 3 1/2 feet tall until I took cuttings

    from it. I included my hand in the pic for scale. She has given me more than 6 new plants. You can propagate from leaves but, it seems to take forever to root that way. Stem or tip cuttings are your best bet.

    Its companion plants are graptopetalum paraguayense which have similar growing requirements.

    You mentioned that you watered your plant, let it drain and placed it inside of another pot.

    I don't think you realized at the time that even though you let the pot drain out, the soil was still probably moist and water, thanks to gravity, would seep out slowly through the bottom which, created a humid situation for the plant. As you may know, as you've successfully grown other succulents, which look amazing by the way, humidity is something they don't tolerate very well if at all.

    Echeverias and Kalanchoes may have a slightly higher tolerance for it but, the senecio haworthii does not.

    I don't know if others on the forum have done this, but I feel the soil first to check if it's moist, soaking wet, or dry and I still ask the salesperson when it was watered last. You may be able to better gauge when to water the plant when you bring it home.

    I sincerely hope you can propagate something from your plant and at the very least to not give up on this species as it's quite a beautiful plant. When it grows tall and full...and sometimes trails out of the container, it is really a showstopper.

    -All the best.

    moonishalfawake thanked Neil
  • 11 years ago

    Thank you! I am not giving up :) these are all great tips and will use them to try to save this little guy

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Hi Moonishalfawake and Neil,

    I am obsessed with this plant. I have been able to root cuttings twice now, but every time I've left for a holiday, my roommate has overwatered them and they have died. It is a crying shame. I then will get another cutting and try again. I just got a division of a healthy plant from someone. It has a few old roots. I put it in a very high perilite soil in a terecotta pot and watered. It has been a week now and the lower leaves are shriveling up. I took it out of the pot to check the roots. All is as it was. It has about 5" of stem buried in the soil with 2 roots about 1" long. I repotted again with more perilite in the mix, didn't water, and put rocks and fossils around it to crowd it. Do you think I am burying the stem too deep? The leaves are about 1" from the surface of the soil. I didn't let anything scab over before potting because it had a couple of roots. Neil, how have you successfully grown this plant from cuttings? I've also tried to root from leaves but haven't had any success with that method. I have a very stunning collection of succulents and this is the one that always trips me up and I want to succeed in growing it.

  • 10 years ago

    Annie

    As I was reading your post, first thing that made me pause was you saying that there is about 5" of stem buried - and then you ask same question...seems to me too much of stem under ground :). Didn't see Neil around for quite a while, hopefully he will see your post - or others having experience with this plant.

    I don't have this plant (tried once and didn't work, never found it in the stores yet), so I could be wrong...JMO

    (P.S: Why don't you start another thread and post photos of your other plants? We all love to see them!)

    Rina

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Hi Rina,

    I'm debating whether to repot the stem with just a couple if inches below the soil or to lay the stem on top of the soil, perpendicular to the pot, and bury just the pre-existing roots. I have rooted stem cuttings before in this manner. What do you think? I will attach of photo of the piece as it is now

    Sneak peak of some of it's friends:

  • 10 years ago

    Annie--- I take cuttings usually from new growth or "newer" growth to be more precise. Not just a leaf but, a few with part of the stem. I give it several weeks to heal over before i place it in any medium. I hope that helps.


    Rina- Sending you a big <<<HUG>>>

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Hi Neil,

    Yes, that is helpful. Will you please read over what I wrote in the comments above and let me know what you think regarding the stem? What if the piece is sort of like a "pup"?

  • 10 years ago

    Senecio Haworthii will survive in
    a variety of soils,but does best in sandy loam which must drain easily. It is
    happiest in full sun - shade and over watering will result in over-long, leggy
    stems with visible spaces between the leaves. This species is especially water
    shy and will rot if kept too wet. Water only when the soil is completely dry
    and reduce water to the merest dribble during the winter resting period. Plants
    are very easy to propagate by cuttings. Use healthy tip cuttings in early
    spring, allow the cut to dry for 2-3 days, and plant in coarse, sharp, river
    sand. Rooting will take place in a few weeks.

  • 10 years ago

    Annie- I copied that snippet for
    you from http://kumbulanursery.co.za/plants/senecio-haworthii

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Hi Neil,

    thanks for the info. I took the specimen out of the pot again and took pictures for you:

  • PRO
    10 years ago

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I fear all this potting and inpottjng is beginning to take a toll on the specimen :(

  • 10 years ago

    If the root/roots are still viable i would put it in some fast draining potting mix. After a few days I would make sure the medium is moist. It should take hold after a few weeks. I water mine irregularly and infrequently and have grown all of them as cuttings.

  • 10 years ago

    Neil

    Glad to see you around, hopefully you are just busy...Hugs back :)

    Annie

    Too many potting/unpottings are not greatest for any plants, but sometimes better than doing nothing.

    I don't see many roots (but this may be OK for this plant?-since I don't have one I really don't know), but the visible ones look OK. If it was my plant, I would not pot it any deeper than uppermost roots. I use rocks for support especially when just potted up, but don't over do it and leave some space for air circulation.

    It still looks like a healthy plant so I hope it will grow well for you.

    Rina

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Thanks Rina and Neil. You guys are assuaging my fears and addressing all my concerns. I added about 50 percent perlite to the soil and repotted it to the top most roots. Should I now water it? Should I add bromide root stimulator to the water? Thanks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 10 years ago

    Do not water and do not add root stimulator. =)