Software
Houzz Logo Print
labdunbar_denver

Mahogany dining table - refinish or paint?

11 years ago

I bought this table used because it collapses small for every day family of 4 dining and enlarges for large gatherings. It is mahogany. I am debating sanding, retaining and sealing, or painting base one color and top another (colors in open family room). I have refinished a table before but never painted. Thoughts and opinions?

Comments (31)

  • 11 years ago

    It's a matter of taste of course, but I don't like painted tables and once you paint you can't go back very easily, I removed paint from a wood nightstand once and was sorry I even started that project - it was a huge amount of work. It is also hard to get a nice smooth finish when you paint a top like this, so you may find it frustrating to achieve the look you want. Also, dining tables take a lot of abuse and paint will likely scratch and need to be repainted. I have seen many wood dining tables in stores and catalogs with black bases so if you like that look you could probably get a black stain or paint the base (which wouldn't get the wear and tear of the top). I would vote for refinishing the wood.

    labdunbar_denver thanked Robbi
  • 11 years ago

    I'm going to guess this is an average piece from the 1940's with a thin mahagony veneer over a plywood base. If so, go ahead and paint as there is nothing special about the materials or construction.

    labdunbar_denver thanked retroearth
  • 11 years ago
    Not paint!!
    labdunbar_denver thanked tessiewhite
  • 11 years ago

    Refinish, and I do not think this is veneer. You may like to try Howard's Refinisher, they make a mahogany color and no stripping is involved. I have used it on dozens of furniture pieces and exterior doors and am always pleased with the results.

    labdunbar_denver thanked babbs50
  • 11 years ago
    I have one just like this and refinished it. It's beautiful!
  • 11 years ago

    Refinish it. You may want to get a professional quote, at the time ask if it is veneer and if the two spots have eaten into the wood or will need something extra on them. You may find out if it is a cheap replica or a more expensive piece. Then decide what to do and evaluate your own skill to do it yourself or have the professional do it .

    labdunbar_denver thanked Vicki Denson
  • 11 years ago

    It is solid wood and I'm pretty sure it's mahogany because of the fine grain. I have other mahogany pieces and this looks like it. These tables on local craigslist go for under $300, sometimes much less. I've never used Howards Refinisher. I'll take a look at that. I do know when I refinished a tabke, it was a lot of work. Looked great though.

    Thanks everyone for your input.

  • 11 years ago

    I'll be doing the work myself, I might add. I did not find name brand labelling on the underside of the table, so I'm not concerned with value. I just want to use the table well. It's highly versatile!

  • 11 years ago

    Even veneer, if still intact can be refinished. Just be extremely careful when sanding. I think this table would look weird painted, so I'd stick with refinishing.

    labdunbar_denver thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    The painting idea came from a table similar to this that someone posted for sale on craigslist. I had not even considered it for painting until I saw one done. I like wood... just a big job to bring it back to a state of beauty.

  • 11 years ago
    I had a smaller table like yours wish I saved from being thrown away by my neighbor. It had a fake mahogany top somebody had glued to the table in the 60's. Because everybody thought it had no value I got it for free and took it to a professional carpenter. He discovered immediately the fake top and fixed it up for me for no money at all, really.
    Maybe you should ask around an see if a pro can fix it for you? To get a perfect finish on such a large table can be tricky. It's definitely worth it! Wether it's and old or new table.
    And you don't have to take the one on high street. Ask around!

    Best of luck!
    Thérèse

    PS. I live in Sweden and I looked on the Internet and found my "jewel of carpentry" outside Stockholm. Much cheaper and a real pro.
    labdunbar_denver thanked tessiewhite
  • 6 years ago

    Refinish, don't paint. Respect the mahogany, even if it is veneer. Good luck.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Agree. Mahogany was meant to be seen.

  • 6 years ago

    Refinish. If sometime you want a lighter look,put a tablecloth on.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    refinish for sure!

  • 6 years ago

    Do not paint it.
    We finally got Grandma's table like this after two cousins ruined it because they got talked into a lighter finish. Take your time and do it right. I have refinished several pieces with Miniwax Polyshades. It really isn't much harder than doing a good durable paint finish. what is different is it takes several coats to get that rich mahogany color. The first two coats will look bad but smooth them with superfine steel wool and wipe with a tack cloth between coats. You can build a deep beautiful and durable finish and it is worth the time.

  • 6 years ago

    I always thought paint as to hide paint grade wood or flaws.

    I have a matching plant stand


  • 6 years ago

    Hi labdunbar_denver -

    Your table is lovely and I would not paint it.

    Before attempting to refinish it yourself, I would get advice from an expert.

    There was a thread on Houzz about a year ago by Edge Grain Wood Studio on which he showed a table he did and omg, I about salivated when I saw how beautiful his work is.

    Maybe you can message him and invite him into this thread and he can give you his opinion.

    as I recall, the piece he showed had a veneer, and he refinished it marvelously, of course, he is a professional.


  • 5 years ago

    I’m thinking about refinishing my dining room table but I want a much lighter colored wood. Any suggestions on how I can achieve this?

  • 5 years ago

    I refinished a cherry table. I stripped it and then bleached it for a lighter finish.

  • 5 years ago

    How did you achieve the bleached cherry look? I have slowly been redoing each room in my house and it is now time for the dining room. Everything in the room is being changed, so I don't have to coordinate with existing wallpaper, rug, etc.



    I have a Stanley Stonleigh 60th Anniversary collection mahogany table that has seen better days. The chairs and base of the table are in good shape, but the top is not. No major scratches, but the finish has been dulled in many places, and there are fine scratches in many places. Don't love the reddish mahogany, and the chairs have lightened to almost a fruitwood color from the sun. I have seen a few tables lately that have the driftwood or taupe look which I find interesting and would go much better with my new decor. Ideas?


  • 5 years ago

    I followed these instructions. It was not a hard process.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    It is a lovely table but these can be found pretty easily at thrift shops. Still, if it is mahogany it would be a shame to paint it. If you are into it, it would be pretty easy to strip it, sand it to a very smooth finish and seal with a rub-on polyurethane. I like rub-on since the topcoat is not thick and doesn't give a wood under plastic look. I would also finish it off with a coat of furniture wax to give it extra shine.


    Ok, going out on a limb here! If you do want to paint would you consider a decorative stencil design that does not cover the entire surface? It might add interest to a lovely but commonly found table. Just a suggestion. The design wouldn't have to be elaborate - just something to break up the large solid plane of wood. Good luck on whatever you decide to do.

  • 5 years ago

    It would be a shame to paint it grey, but Susie's table is a nice compromise.

  • 5 years ago

    Susie, what are the instructions for bleaching the table?

  • 5 years ago

    See the link above. But after stripping the table, I applied household bleach with a sponge/towel. I let it dry and repeated around 5 times until I reached the desired color.

  • 5 years ago

    I don't think I would want to paint the table, although that would probably be easier. I know it would be a lot of work (but I have the time) but I was thinking of stripping and staining with a grey/driftwood color. I've been looking for pictures of one of these types of tables done that way, and I haven't seen a lot... maybe there's a reason? LOL I have contemplated just stripping the top and staining back to the original color, but I'm just not feeling the mahogany, unless I can update the table some other way. Maybe new chair cushions/slipcovers, or a stencil as Norwood Architects suggested. I'll have to look around to see if I can find any pics for stencils. Thanks for the input all!

  • 5 years ago

    Susie, I don't see a link to your instructions? I would love to research the bleaching technique. Thanks!

  • 5 years ago

    The website is www.repurposeandupcycle.com. Go to search key words and type How to Strip furniture. See if you can find it that way.

Sponsored
Daniel Home
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars20 Reviews
Premier Interior Design Team Transforming Spaces in Franklin Co, Ohio